Unlimited Access. Try it Today! Your First 10 Days Always $0.99

Readers Respond

News Opinion Readers Respond

The problem with the 'bag tax' [Letter]

The check-out inquiry was "paper or plastic?" But it's no longer a choice. Merchants love plastic. It's easy to store and less expensive than paper. Multiple bags can handle heavier items. Thin plastic wraps around whatever is in the bag and around one's hand. But that clinging feature is horrible for the aquatic environment ("Plastic bag fee for city shoppers proposed – again," May 9).

The new bag ban fans are local governments. Montgomery County and Washington, D.C., have them. Baltimore City is exploring having one. For the local political leadership, they can reach over their shoulders, pat themselves on the back for raising revenue, using portions of the revenue for environmental projects. The Sun has voiced its disapproval ("Bag the bag tax", May 12) based upon the city's image and that the tax falls upon the less affluent.

Local jurisdictions should go beyond tinkering with a serious environmental problem. A great example is recycling. Public attitudes and compliance have changed with making it easier to recycle. The best results come when recycling containers are supplied.

For bags, if a tax is the preferred approach, then use the revenue to purchase reusable bags, distributing them to less affluent communities. Good quality bags can be purchased for under a $1.

Or another approach is to require the dispenser of the bags to give the customer a 5-cent per bag credit when the customer supplies the bag, as Giant Foods currently does.

Back to the environment. The source of the bags in the waterways is more than Baltimore City. The Inner Harbor's tributaries are the Patapsco River and the Jones and Gwynns Falls, which flow from Baltimore County. Hopefully the city and county can work together for regional, comprehensive solutions.

Theodore Levin, Pikesville

To respond to this letter, send an email to talkback@baltimoresun.com. Please include your name and contact information.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Ban the bag
    Ban the bag

    The Maryland General Assembly is currently considering a bill that would ban plastic bags in Maryland ("Advocates try in Annapolis for plastic bag ban," March 10).

  • Let's get rid of plastic bags
    Let's get rid of plastic bags

    I am writing in support of legislation introduced by Del. Brooke Lierman to address the plastic bag consumption in Maryland ("Advocates try in Annapolis for plastic bag ban," March 10).

  • Bag ban casts Baltimore as 'Chump City'
    Bag ban casts Baltimore as 'Chump City'

    Nobody asked columnist Dan Rodricks about banning plastic bags, and nobody asked Baltimore retailers or shoppers either ("Nobody asked me, but City Council needs spine," Nov. 23).

  • What's so bad about plastic bags?
    What's so bad about plastic bags?

    Plastic grocery/retail bags have many post first-time uses ("Bag it, City Council," Nov 11). We use many of them along with an inner paper bag as liners for our house garbage cans. They are efficient and easy to handle. Once thrown into the garbage, they are hauled away to the Baltimore waste-to-energy...

  • Let's just ban the bags
    Let's just ban the bags

    I have a problem with plastic bags and the bag tax issue ("Council passes body camera bill, plastic bag ban, but veto looms," Nov. 17). So much time and energy has been spent on this issue. When we take a step back and look at the bigger picture, there are so many daily issues, each much more pressing...

  • City bag ban would be about as effective as its gun laws
    City bag ban would be about as effective as its gun laws

    I wish the Baltimore City Council luck with its plastic bag bill ("Bag it, City Council," Nov. 11). Hope it works out better than the gun laws in effect.

  • Bravos for the bag ban
    Bravos for the bag ban

    For the first time in a long time I'm proud of Baltimore City and the City Council, not for passing a proposed 5-cent tax on plastic grocery bags but for going all the way and banning them outright ("Baltimore City Council moves to ban plastic bags," Nov. 10).

  • Let's ease up on city retailers
    Let's ease up on city retailers

    Wow! Dan Rodricks offers an argument against plastic bags based on an old John Waters movie. What a stretch ("We can learn to live without plastic bags," Nov. 13)!