Become a digitalPLUS subscriber. 99¢ for 4 weeks.
News Opinion Readers Respond

Don't equate AP with academic excellence [Letter]

I believe that all high school educators recognize the importance of challenging our very best students, while simultaneously helping them develop the critical thinking, written and oral communication skills and habits of mind needed for success in today's world. I am not convinced that Advanced Placement courses achieve those goals ("Some parents, educators are rethinking the role of AP," Jan. 18).

AP courses unquestionably provide challenge. But the courses, by design, are narrowly focused and do not cross disciplines. Because the courses are directed toward taking a standardized test created by the same organization that administers the SAT, their focus ultimately becomes test prep and not the fostering of creative, independent thought. The College Board seems to have recognized this and in recent years has begun implementing changes intended to stimulate students' analytical thinking.

I encourage high school students and their parents not to simply equate AP with academic excellence and to explore other options to enrich their educational experience. In particular, the International Baccalaureate — offered at a range of private and public schools in both Baltimore City and the surrounding counties (including City College and Milford Mill) — offers not only challenge and mastery of a subject area but also an interdisciplinary approach that fosters independent thought.

On the same day The Sun ran its story about advanced placement, it also published a piece by University of Maryland Baltimore County President Freeman Hrabowski stressing the vital importance of university research ("Prioritize university research". The IB program requires diploma candidates to complete an extensive independent research project. The result is students entering college prepared to undertake the kind of work Mr. Hrabowski highlights. According to a University of Virginia study comparing AP and IB students, IB students were more prepared for college-level course work, more likely to have executed research while in college and intended to conduct future research.

I believe in the importance of challenging our best high school students, developing their skills and preparing them for success in college. But we can't simply assume AP courses are the best way to achieve that goal.

David C. Faus, Brooklandville

The writer is headmaster of St. Paul's School.

-
To respond to this letter, send an email to talkback@baltimoresun.com. Please include your name and contact information.

Copyright © 2014, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Unshackled from the golden handcuffs of AP [Letter]
    Unshackled from the golden handcuffs of AP [Letter]

    I read The Sun's investigative report on Advanced Placement courses ("Some parents, educators are rethinking role of AP," Jan. 18) with great interest, in part because our school, on principle, has never offered AP classes. Our rationale is simple: We believe the AP program and its heavy...

  • Md. is still No. 1 [Letter]
    Md. is still No. 1 [Letter]

    When Education Week released its latest assessment of state education systems last week, the news for Maryland was once again great. Maryland remained the only state in the nation to receive at least a "B" across all six categories. Maryland was one of only five states to narrow the achievement...

  • AP courses are a good deal for students and their parents [Letter]
    AP courses are a good deal for students and their parents [Letter]

    While I appreciate letter writer Linda Jacobs' position regarding Advanced Placement courses, for her to call them foolishness is excessive and lacks any appreciation of what the purpose of an AP course is ("AP courses don't equal education," Jan. 22).

  • Some parents, educators are rethinking role of AP
    Some parents, educators are rethinking role of AP

    One local parents group and a university suggest top students scale back on the college-level classes

  • Alternatives to the AP [Letter]
    Alternatives to the AP [Letter]

    I am a junior at Perry Hall High School in Baltimore County who is currently taking three Advanced Placement classes this year. By the time I graduate I will have taken 11 AP exams, so I can appreciate the point of your recent article about how the stresses of an AP class affect a student's...

  • AP classes are often misused [Letter]
    AP classes are often misused [Letter]

    As a retired AP English teacher, I appreciated Liz Bowie's extensive discussion of the current misuses and abuses of the College Board's AP program ("Some parents, educators rethinking the role of AP," Jan. 18).

  • Revisit 'old-school' police programs
    Revisit 'old-school' police programs

    The recent influx of citizen unrest due to a rash of officer-related homicides has left the American citizenry skeptical of the greater good police departments bring to communities nationwide, especially that of traditionally violent neighborhoods that tend to have a majority of minority...

  • Torture can never be justified
    Torture can never be justified

    The Senate report's summary of the "enhanced interrogation" techniques the CIA used on terrorist detainees after 9/11 reads like something from a horror novel ("CIA strikes back after Senate torture report," Dec....

Comments
Loading