Get unlimited digital access to $0.99 for 4 weeks.
News Opinion Readers Respond

Alonso undeserving of accolades

I read Kalman Hettleman's commentary ("Alonso's special-ed legacy," Aug. 20) with interest. While the "One Year Plus" initiative may be laudable, there were so many other things that transpired under Baltimore City Schools CEO Andrés Alonso's tenure that were not.

Consider that Mr. Alonso forced principals to take sole responsibility for performance responsibilities that by contract belonged to others. What I am saying is that employees under the auspices of the Baltimore Teachers Union could under perform with little to no consequence. The principal of the school where that employee worked would be demoted or fired. Additionally, there is a saying somewhere that if "something untrue is said enough, people will believe it." That is the case with Mr. Hettleman's statement about Mr. Alonso's claim of "extensive school autonomy." Mr. Alonso never gave principals any autonomy. He just claimed that he did.

I was a high school principal in Baltimore City for 18 years. There was a time when principals did have autonomy and ran schools effectively. Northwestern High School made considerable gains under my leadership with initiatives that I was allowed to put in place for students. The initiatives included school uniforms, flexible scheduling based on student need, evening school, extensive technical education programs and more. My immediate superiors were true partners and had every single initiative approved for me. That would have never happened under the CEO who told principals at one of our initial meetings that he was "a control freak." He certainly told the truth about that. He put so many controls in place that principals could barely get into classrooms because they had to (and have to) send so many reports and e-mails.

I could say more, much more, and would be glad to do so if anyone were interested. However, I'm pleased that I can write this response. I could not have done so if I were still working, but thanks to God and years of hard work, I retired July 1 of this year.

I sincerely wish all Baltimore City Public School employees, parents and students the very best for School Year 2013-2014. They have a leader in the intern who has been the voice of reason and fairness under the Alonso regime. Tisha Edwards is going to be an excellent interim CEO and she would certainly get my vote for the permanent position — but someone else from outside who knows nothing about our school system or its children will probably be brought in from outside.

That's what generally happens.

James I. Scofield

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Dwyer should step down

    During the past year, Del. Don Dwyer Jr. has been cited three times for breaking the law ("Del. Dwyer charged with driving under the influence," Aug. 21). Once for boating under the influence causing an accident, once for crabbing on a day not allowing such activity, and once for driving...

  • Manning jailed while Iraq war's instigators go free

    Sometimes I worry about our American value system and how it is expressed in our legal system. Pfc. Bradley Manning has just been sentenced for his role in the release of sensitive security data and we are desperate to apprehend Edward Snowden for similar activity ("Bradley Manning sentenced to...

  • Loan money to doctors, not bars

    In "college town" Towson, even the sports bar needs our tax money to build up and sell more booze ("State board OKs Greene Turtle loan," Aug. 22).

  • O'Reilly is telling the truth
    O'Reilly is telling the truth

    Why didn't the Associated Press writer covering the story about Fox News' Bill O'Reilly contact NBC and CBS about what happened in the aftermath of the Falklands War ("Reports contradict O'Reilly protest memories," Feb. 26)?

  • Stand up for clean water
    Stand up for clean water

    Having been born in a fishing town in Maine and raised in Annapolis, one of the oldest ports on the Chesapeake Bay, I feel a strong connection to our nation's water and the things that live in it. Gov. Larry Hogan's recently proposed and loose regulations of poultry farm pollution have me and...

  • The risks of fracking outweigh the potential benefits
    The risks of fracking outweigh the potential benefits

    State Sen. Bobby Zirkin's bill putting strict limits on fracking demonstrates the growing concern elected officials have about opening Maryland's doors to the oil and gas industry ("Frosh wades into fracking fight," Feb. 25).

  • Democrats side with foreigners
    Democrats side with foreigners

    Democrats are telling Republicans to put the American people first and pass a clean Department of Homeland Security funding bill because Democratic senators will not accept anything other than a clean bill ("Congress OKs deal to avoid shutdown at Homeland Security," Feb. 27). Republicans say...

  • Why the higher-ups at the Baltimore City jail got a pass
    Why the higher-ups at the Baltimore City jail got a pass

    I have no sympathy for Derrick Jones and other employees at The Baltimore City Detention Center who allowed themselves to be corrupted by the Black Guerrilla Family ("Jail supervisor, National Guardsman sentenced to 20 months in BGF case," Feb. 27).