Get unlimited digital access to $0.99 for 4 weeks.
News Opinion Readers Respond

If abortion is murder, many should be headed to prison

Christopher Dreisbach is right that if abortion at any stage is murder, then it's difficult to oppose Rep. Todd Akin's claim that an aborted fetus resulting from rape is an innocent victim ("Abortion ethics not so simple," Aug. 28).

But it is equally difficult for Mr. Akin and others who claim to believe that abortion is murder to explain why abortionists, and their accomplices and co-conspirators, should not be subject to the penalties we apply in the case of other premeditated murders.

In about two-thirds of the states I believe that penalty would be death for the doctor performing the abortion, for anyone knowingly paying for it, and in many cases for the woman undergoing the abortion whether she paid for it or not. Others involved, for example, assisting nurses and anyone knowingly driving the woman to the clinic, would be subject to life imprisonment. In the other states, all would be subject to life imprisonment, in most cases without the possibility of parole. Not all prosecutors would seek the maximum penalty in every case, but those penalties would be available.

In my experience, few or none of the people who claim to believe that abortion is murder are willing to have anyone involved subject to these penalties. They seem to think that if abortion is criminalized, there will be no abortions, so no penalty will ever need to imposed. This is, of course, a fantasy.

Their reluctance to impose penalties for murder on people involved in abortion leads me to doubt their sincerity when they claim to believe that abortion is murder.

Vincent Daly, Baltimore

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • City teachers sacrifice while top officials live high on the hog

    I am outraged to read the article in The Sun ("City schools officials play loose with credit," Aug. 26) regarding credit card charges in the amount of $500,000 incurred by Baltimore City school officials. Thousands of dollars were spent on very questionable purchases, including gourmet...

  • The crux of abortion debate: Is it murder?

    I was surprised and delighted to open The Sun and read an inspiring commentary on the op-ed page ("Abortion ethics not so simple," Aug. 28). Christopher Dreisbach has finally given this topic the objective, honest look it so rightly deserves. This kind of material not only credits him, but...

  • Reader comments should be screened

    While I understand that allowing comments on news articles is a way to engage readers and to stimulate thoughtful conversation on controversial topics, many of the comments I've read associated with articles in The Sun are irrelevant to the issues, offensive, provocative, and embarrassingly...

  • Obama record is no asset

    The Sun editorializes that "the incumbent is a known commodity" ("Who is Mitt Romney?" Aug. 28), and that is President Barack Obama's problem — he is a known commodity.

  • States not looking for pension bailout

    In its latest siren concerning public pension plans ("Beware the next federal bailout," Aug. 22), the Maryland Public Policy Institute (MPPI) relies on confusion and unjustified fear when it asks if there is another federal bailout coming. There is a simple answer: No.

  • Let Netanyahu speak
    Let Netanyahu speak

    I find it necessary to respond to Frederic B. Hill's odious and erroneous op-ed, "Boehner's unwise move" (Jan. 28).

  • Congress has right to hear Netanyahu
    Congress has right to hear Netanyahu

    In his commentary ("Boehner's unwise move," Jan. 28), Frederic B. Hill claims it was unwise for House Speaker John Boehner to invite Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to speak at a joint session of Congress because it shows deference toward him before an Israeli election.

  • Sick leave can be a lifesaver
    Sick leave can be a lifesaver

    I'm offended by the comments of Del. Kathy Szeliga about whether Maryland should mandate paid sick days ("Lawmakers put paid sick leave on agenda," Jan. 26). I don't need paid sick days to fish. I need paid sick days and job protection because I have cancer and lost my job when I took time...