Get unlimited digital access to $0.99 for 4 weeks.
News Opinion Op-Eds

Obama's relevance hangs on Dem showing in midterms [Commentary]

Congressional midterm elections, the poor cousin to presidential voting in the American political system, will take on a critical role for President Barack Obama in November. The results may well determine whether he will become a premature lame duck two years before his second and last term expires.

If the Democrats lose the U.S. Senate, where they hold a practical 55-45 voting control with the help of Independent Sen. Angus King of Maine, the Republicans will be able to intensify the obstructionism with which they have paralyzed the Obama legislative agenda in the House of Representatives over the last nearly six years.

The loss of six Democratic-held Senate seats (or five, if Mr. King decides to caucus with the Republicans, a move he has said he might consider) would hit Mr. Obama with a double whammy of partisan opposition in Congress for the first time.

It doesn't help the president's cause that, historically, voter participation drops in midterm elections, including among the black, ethnic and minority voters so critical to the success of Democratic candidates. Mr. Obama's party has shown notable dedication to driving up its turnout this fall, but without a presidential nominee at the top of the ticket in each state, the effort may be compromised.

There are two basic approaches to achieve the desired result. One is to pour paid party staff, volunteers and campaign money into the Senate races in the most hotly contested states. The other is to attempt to "nationalize" these races by emphasizing broad issues that the Democratic Party, and Mr. Obama, are pushing.

In other words, by campaigning not on local issues embraced by the Democratic incumbent or nominee, but rather linking him or her to issues of national significance and to the Democratic president, the hope is to carry that candidate to office through party loyalty or issue affinity. But does Mr. Obama have long enough coattails anymore?

In 2008, his huge personal appeal as potentially the first black American president and an effective campaigner brought the Democrats not only the White House but control of both houses of Congress. However, in the 2010 midterms, with Obama off the ticket, the House Democrats suffered their largest defeat in 72 years, and with their lost majority went much of Mr. Obama's political muscle.

The House Republicans used their new leverage to erode Mr. Obama's strength, to the point that in 2012, with him again leading the Democratic ticket, he was re-elected but failed to regain control of the House. There, the Republicans under Speaker John Boehner used a burgeoning national issue — Obamacare — to preserve and increase the House GOP majority and remain a political thorn in the Democratic president's hide.

Now, in 2014, in the wake of the flawed early rollout of his health-care insurance law and mounting foreign policy crises, it may not make much sense for the Democrats to "nationalize" this fall's congressional midterm elections.

Mr. Obama's concerted efforts to disentangle the country from what he has called "a perpetual war footing" seem to reflect a wide weariness on the American home front. But the current inflaming of Ukraine and the Middle East gives critics like Republican Sen. John McCain and others ample grounds to "nationalize" the midterms against a president of diminished popularity.

Under the most ordinary circumstances, a second-term president approaching his constitutional exit from the Oval Office inevitably loses political clout. This time around, Mr. Obama's influence is already being sapped somewhat by the very early Democratic focus on Hillary Clinton as Mr. Obama's successor as the likely 2016 party presidential nominee, should she run.

All this leaves Mr. Obama in a situation far different from 1995 when Bill Clinton, harassed by the threat of government shutdown from another House Republican group led by Newt Gingrich, felt obliged to declare that "the president is relevant here." Mr. Clinton toughened up then and Mr. Gingrich had to surrender.

Mr. Obama may be facing a similar threat of irrelevance now in the midterms. If his party can't hold onto the Senate in November, his final two years as a lame duck may well mean more of the same legislative frustration as we saw in the last six.

Jules Witcover is a syndicated columnist and former long-time writer for The Baltimore Sun. His latest book is "Joe Biden: A Life of Trial and Redemption" (William Morrow). His email is

To respond to this commentary, send an email to Please include your name and contact information.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • The Sikh's public relations problem
    The Sikh's public relations problem

    In 2013 the popular retailer GAP featured a turbaned Sikh actor in a major advertising campaign. Sikh-Americans were thrilled. When the company responded to the vandalism of the ad in New York by using the original photo as the background of its Twitter page, Sikhs' spirits were buoyed even...

  • Allow children sentenced to life a second chance
    Allow children sentenced to life a second chance

    I am a successful Baltimore businessman and nonprofit leader, but when I was 17, I made the worst mistake of my life. I overreacted during an argument and took a man's life. I was convicted and sentenced to life in prison in Maryland.

  • Reserve ignition interlock for hardcore offenders
    Reserve ignition interlock for hardcore offenders

    Maryland lawmakers are considering new legislation that would require every drunk driving offender to install a Breathalyzer, known as an ignition interlock device, in his or her car. Putting more interlocks in more vehicles might seem like a sensible way to curb alcohol-related fatalities, but...

  • From now on, she walks to school
    From now on, she walks to school

    Since there have been parents and kids, each generation has struggled to understand the other. To me, it appears that children today are much less accountable and have fewer responsibilities than I did growing up. One of our kids is an over-achieving, motivated 17-year-old girl. All of her...

  • No bees? No food.
    No bees? No food.

    The honey bees are in trouble. Since 2006, beekeepers have reported average hive losses of 30 percent or higher each year. In 2012, Maryland beekeepers lost nearly 50 percent of their hives.

  • Reject the proposed merger of Exelon and Pepco
    Reject the proposed merger of Exelon and Pepco

    Since 2008, University Park Community Solar LLC has attempted to make community solar more feasible for other Marylanders, through the organizing and building of one of the first community solar projects in the nation and through our efforts to provide information and free technical...