Save 75% - Only $49.99 for 1 full year! digitalPLUS subscription offer ends 12/1
NewsOpinionOp-Eds

Food and wine go together

WinesConsumersWegmans Food Markets, Inc.

The kerfuffle over the proposed wine store in Wegmans' newest location in Columbia heralds the next looming battle in consumers' fight to modernize Maryland's alcohol policy. The recent Howard County liquor board hearing demonstrated the intensity of both sides' arguments. The local retailers, backed by the alcohol distributors, fear increased competition — while consumer groups clamor for greater convenience and selection, and lower prices.

The alcohol industry in Maryland has traditionally dictated its own regulations. Two companies distribute 90 percent of the wine and spirits sold in Maryland, according to industry testimony before the General Assembly last year. These distributors work very closely with packaged goods stores to maintain the status quo because it is in their best interests. The distributors oppose allowing grocery or chain stores to sell alcohol — even though they would actually sell more by volume — because of their fear of the chains' purchasing power. Under the current system, with only one liquor license allowed per Maryland applicant, the distributors have little to fear from one problematic account. Were the state to allow Giant to sell beer and wine in all 98 of its Maryland stores, however, Giant would have significant say in when, what and how much it was willing to buy.

The enactment of direct wine shipping legislation in 2011, followed this year by the legalization of corkage, has been the dawn of Maryland consumers' understanding that the state actually determines what we drink and how much we pay for it. Most consumers want the convenience of purchasing groceries and a bottle of wine or craft beer in the same location — a right enjoyed by millions of Americans in most other states. In fact, there are already a number of chain store licenses issued within Maryland and even entire jurisdictions on the Eastern Shore that permit chain store sales. It's no wonder Marylanders are confused as a result of this county-by-county inconsistency. The root cause of this patchwork approach is the authority granted the liquor boards in the state's 24 political jurisdictions.

During the most recent General Assembly session, the Prince George's County delegation considered a bill that would have allowed a chain store liquor license in a Bowie mall that had seen better days. The legislation ultimately died because so many others wanted chain store sales and tried to pile onto the original bill.

The Food Marketing Institute, the national trade association for food retailers and wholesalers, came out with a report at the end of last year entitled "FMI WINE STUDY: The Economic Impact of Allowing Shoppers to Purchase Wine in Food Stores." The study made some interesting findings:

•Open states that allow widespread supermarket sales have about four times as many retail wine outlets per average adult population as closed states.

•Legalizing chain store wine sales nationwide is projected to increase federal and state taxes collected by more than $5 billion and increase employment by 168,000, resulting in a total economic impact of $14.3 billion.

•Package goods stores remain relatively unaffected, continuing to maintain healthy counts in states where wine chain store sales are legal. Allowing sales at chain stores has only marginal impact on existing stores.

The report notes that "[w]hile adapting to a changing economic environment is often difficult, states that have made the change have found their fears preceding the change were unjustified."

The current system, set up in 1933, has started to show its age. Maryland consumers want to be able to visit wineries and have wine shipped to their doors. They want to be able to take a bottle of wine for a special occasion to a restaurant and enjoy it with a meal. And they want to be able to do one-stop shopping at a grocery store. Maryland consumers have won the first two of those battles. It remains to be seen whether our legislators have the political will to advocate on behalf of consumers and win this one as well.

Adam Borden is the president of Marylanders for Better Beer & Wine Laws. His email is aborden@mbbwl.org.

Copyright © 2014, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
WinesConsumersWegmans Food Markets, Inc.
  • Chuck Hagel leaves Obama's war against war
    Chuck Hagel leaves Obama's war against war

     The surprising decision of Secretary of Defense Chuck Hagel to leave his Pentagon post after only 21 months of service has been widely greeted as a combination of his frustration in the job and a conclusion at the White House that he turned out to be the wrong man...

  • Don't reduce city schools' capital funding
    Don't reduce city schools' capital funding

    Baltimore should be proud of its tremendous achievement to secure approximately $1 billion to fully rebuild and renovate up to 28 school buildings over the next 5 years — the first phase of the city schools' 21st Century Buildings program. This is the single largest investment in...

  • Giving thanks for ugly fruit
    Giving thanks for ugly fruit

    It was the last outing of our harvest season, and 500 pounds of apples lay before us in 25 bags. A group of nine harvesters from the Baltimore Orchard Project combed through the fruit trees for the last of the yield at this impeccably-kept orchard so we could give the fruit to those in need.

  • 'OUR Walmart' is a union front
    'OUR Walmart' is a union front

    The Friday after Thanksgiving, also known as Black Friday, is reliably one of the busiest shopping days of the year. And, just as reliably, you can expect a group called OUR Walmart, which is financed by the United Food and Commercial Workers union (UFCW), to attempt to disrupt the day with...

  • Cold War all over again?
    Cold War all over again?

    Reading the latest headlines transports me into my childhood, which was spent in a country that no longer exists. I grew up in St. Petersburg, then in the USSR, in the mid '70s and '80s. The Cold War was in full swing. The news stories that involve Russia now are almost identical to the ones...

  • Better management of manure long overdue
    Better management of manure long overdue

    We commend Gov. Martin O'Malley's decision to proceed with science-based management requirements to reduce the significant flow of Chesapeake Bay-choking phosphorus from farmland already saturated with an excess of the nutrient. We fully support the proposal and urge the new governor and...

Comments
Loading