Summer Sale! Get unlimited digital access for 13 weeks for $13.
News Opinion Op-Eds

Supercommittee should take a look at the Puerto Rican miracle

Since the congressional supercommittee appears unable, or unwilling, to take a lesson from Indiana or Virginia -- where Republican governors have made spending cuts and delivered budget surpluses without damaging the social safety net -- members might wish to consider Puerto Rico and what its governor, Luis Fortuno is doing.

Mr. Fortuno is Puerto Rico's first Republican governor in 42 years. In 2009 when he took office, the U.S. territory had a $3.3 billion budget deficit. Three years earlier, Moody's Investors Service downgraded the commonwealth's bond rating to junk status while in deep recession.

Like Virginia Governor Bob McDonnell and Indiana's Mitch Daniels, Mr.  Fortuno is turning the economy around by cutting government spending 20 percent overall, which has lowered the deficit by 81 percent. He eliminated more than 20,000 government jobs, reformed government services, trimming costs, and cut operational spending 10 percent, eliminating official vehicles, cellphones and credit cards.

Following five years of recession, the commonwealth's economy is showing signs of recovery. Moody's took notice, upgrading Puerto Rico's bond status to A3, its highest rating in 35 years. Standard and Poor's raised its outlook on Puerto Rico's credit from "stable" to "positive." It is Standard and Poor's first positive review since 1983.

Over the next six years, newly implemented tax cuts will return $1.2 billion to those who earn the money. Added to this is a 7 percent tax credit for corporations and a reduction in the corporate tax rate from 41 percent to 30 percent.

As for "infrastructure" about which President Obama so often speaks, according to the governor's office, Puerto Rico has created an "aggressive public-private partnership law to encourage private investment and bring efficiencies to schools, roads, airports and water and energy projects."

What's not to like about this? It produces results Democrats say they want, especially infrastructure, and it does it with economic policies Republicans endorse.

In an interview in his office, located inside La Fortaleza (The Fortress), one of the few medieval castles remaining in the Americas, I asked Governor Fortuno what advice he would offer his fellow Republicans on illegal immigration and how to win more Hispanic votes.

"I think the Republican Party has done an awful job handling this issue," he says. "It makes no sense for us not to bring more Hispanics into the party because Hispanics are naturally conservative. The tenor of the public discourse surrounding this issue has sounded anti-Hispanic at times."

What would he recommend to change the tone?

"First, show up; show respect. Most Republican candidates don't do that. They talk about 15-foot fences and then try to address the issues of greatest concern in the Hispanic community. They are no different from other communities most of the time. On immigration, Republicans say, 'we want legal immigration and we are the country, thanks to legal immigration,' so we need to try to address this issue with a different tone than we've had so far."

Another issue: What about Cuba's post-Castro future?

Fortuno thinks any resumption of relations between the United States and the communist nation should be conditioned on an improvement in human rights, which he says are "grossly" violated by the Castro brothers.

What about the growing relationship between Venezuela and Iran?

"Daily flights," the governor interrupts.

What can the U.S. do to lessen Iran's influence in the region?

"Energy is the big issue," he says. "As I travel and talk with leaders, they feel the U.S. has not helped them sufficiently to fill their energy needs. Economic development is the only way to address (Iran's influence). Each country has its own challenges, but the U.S. needs to help fill that economic void and if we don't, others will."

The 51-year-old governor is handsome and charismatic.

He'll need that and more to win re-election in 2012. While Governor Fortuno is gaining ground in popularity after the massive government layoffs (he now trails his likely Democratic opponent by single digits), changing from a dependency culture to one of personal responsibility takes time.

Maybe the supercommittee should visit San Juan. A little face time with Luis Fortuno might improve the group's chances of a debt resolution.

Cal Thomas is a syndicated columnist. He can be reached at

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Schaller fails to see danger of U.S. debt

    Columnist Thomas F. Schaller's analysis is incredibly myopic ("Avoiding Europe's austerity nightmare," April 18). To compare the economic condition of the U.S. to those of Greece or Spain at the beginning of the economic crisis is comparing apples and oranges.

  • Military spending is misplaced U.S. priority

    On April 17, I will be protesting war taxes at Baltimore's main post office. I realize that taxes fund many good programs — education, environment and diplomacy. But sadly when 57 percent of the federal budget goes to the Pentagon, the government's priorities are out of touch with the pressing...

  • A better budget remedy than the Buffett rule

    You end your editorial on the Buffett Rule ("The Buffett Rule backlash," April 13) with the question, "Where will the $50 billion come from to balance the budget, if not from this minimum tax plan?"

  • Skeptical of Buffett and need for higher taxes

    First, I'm an 80-year-old living on Social Security, and I know all the tax loopholes need to be closed ("The Buffett Rule backlash," April 13). But isn't it correct that Warren Buffett owes the IRS a great deal of taxes for a number of years? Let's have a true picture of Mr. Buffett.

  • The Buffett Rule backlash

    The Buffett Rule backlash

    Our view: Taxing the wealthy at rates others already face wouldn't solve the nation's deficit, but it would restore a modicum of fairness to the tax code

  • Godless Republicans turn back on poor and sick

    Some churchmen take exception to some of President Barack Obama's positions on matters of faith. I suggest these men of faith take a closer look at the true meaning of religion. All three Abrahamic religions — Christianity, Judaism and Islam — have as their central theme the commandments to protect...