Get unlimited digital access to $0.99 for 4 weeks.
News Opinion Op-Eds

Outside audits for all state departments

It is time for our state to have independent audits of all departments and agencies.

The appalling misuse of federal education funding discovered earlier this year is already well known. Baltimore City and Prince George's County schools wasted over $540,000 of federal stimulus money and funds intended to educate some of our poorest populations. Instead of putting more teachers in the classroom or updating textbooks and supplies, the money paid for parent/teacher harbor cruises, makeovers, theater tickets, watches for administrators and catered dinners. All at the same time that the General Assembly was pushing to increase funding for Baltimore City Public Schools.

In 2012, it was discovered that our state government paid out benefits such as Medicaid, adoption assistance and welfare without being able to verify whether many recipients were qualified. The Maryland Department of Human Resources kept such poor inventory records of a $4.2 million food distribution program that we have no way of knowing if there was theft or fraud. Reporting errors at state universities interfered with the U.S. Department of Education's student loan and grant programs. There were many cases of over-reporting the student population, resulting in the unlawful retention of federal aid.

These and other issues were recently uncovered not by internal state audits but by the "single audit," the annual independent review required by the federal government on the state's use of almost $13 billion in federal funds. This independent audit of federal dollars only underscores the need for independent audits on the spending of state dollars.

When other states have tried independent audits, as opposed to internal audits, waste and fraud were frequently uncovered. Gov. Chris Christie brought in independent auditors for New Jersey's health programs and uncovered $700 million in misuse, fraud and double billing. An outside audit in New York recently revealed that the state Medicaid program had overcharged $15 billion over the past 20 years.

And last month, Massachusetts received the results of an independent audit that found $80 million in welfare payments were misappropriated, with much of it going to dead people.

Maryland does not do independent audits. The cases of unconscionable waste and misuse of federal funds stated above only came to light through outside audits conducted by either a federal inspector general or private sector accounting firm. There is no reason to believe that the same state officials blatantly wasting federal dollars are somehow being more responsible with state money.

In order to build a new Maryland, we must first understand where the money is currently spent. Only then can we eliminate government waste and provide the best service possible with the resources we have.

Despite what Gov. Martin O'Malley seems to think is an endless base for tax revenue, our state has limited resources. Waste is one of the persistent problems that diminishes the impact of vital programs.

It is not a coincidence that we uncover state agencies misappropriating federal funds more often than state funds. While all federal funding goes through a rigorous external, independent review, state spending receives, at most, an internal review by the Office of Legislative Audits.

The audits office is well respected for objectively investigating the workings of our state government. It routinely brings to light cases of fraud and abuse, such as last year's audit uncovering inappropriate working relationships between State Highway Administration officials and the contractors they were responsible for overseeing. Unfortunately, it rarely is able to identify the run-of-the-mill government waste that is costing the state tens of millions.

The value of independent audits in both the public and private sectors is indisputable. Through higher taxes and federal government largesse, the O'Malley administration has increased the state's annual spending from $28 billion when he took office to $37 billion. Not only has this rapid increase created more opportunities for waste, but the speed and scope of the expansion has, for many programs, outpaced effective oversight.

Every dollar Maryland spends comes out of the pocket of a hardworking taxpayer. Government waste is unacceptable.

Bringing in professional, independent auditors to review every department and agency will allow us to root out the waste and redirect funds to programs where they will do the most good. Independent audits work.

Ron George, a two-term state delegate from Anne Arundel County, is a small business owner and Republican candidate for governor. His email is

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • What did Hogan tell the NRA?
    What did Hogan tell the NRA?

    Based on what Republican gubernatorial candidate Larry Hogan has said about gun control, it's hard to see what the National Rifle Association would find appealing about him. He has said that although he opposed the strict new gun control legislation Gov. Martin O'Malley championed two years...

  • Statistics don't tell the whole story of Hogan's win
    Statistics don't tell the whole story of Hogan's win

    I must disagree with commentator Thomas F. Schaller's column on Maryland's gubernatorial election ("Race had a role in Hogan's win," Nov. 11).

  • Polls are not in public interest
    Polls are not in public interest

    Mileah Kromer discusses the reasons that the results of pre-election polls concerning the race for governor were largely incorrect, particularly the timing of the polls on which media and the campaigns relied ("Hogan and Brown: tortoise and hare?" Nov. 12). I do not doubt that she is largely...

  • Race played no role in Hogan win
    Race played no role in Hogan win

    I read Thomas Schaller's column ("Race had a role in Hogan's win," Nov. 11) regarding Larry Hogan's win over Lt. Gov. Anthony Brown in the 2014 Maryland gubernatorial election. He basically states that the areas Mr. Hogan won had more white people then black.

  • Leopold: New governors should be sworn in before the General Assembly session
    Leopold: New governors should be sworn in before the General Assembly session

    Sixteen years ago, I sponsored legislation that called for a constitutional amendment that would have allowed incoming governors to take office prior to the commencement of the General Assembly ("Hogan names ex-Senator Neall to transition team," Nov. 12). The bill, which would have allowed...

  • Enough with the talk of race in analyzing elections
    Enough with the talk of race in analyzing elections

    Race, racism, racist. I am so tired of hearing these words whenever a candidate loses or a policy is defeated ("Race had a role in Hogan's win," Nov. 11). Lt. Gov. Anthony G. Brown lost to Larry Hogan because Mr. Brown ran one of the worst campaigns in recent Maryland elections. He even...

  • The Republican revolution hits Dundalk
    The Republican revolution hits Dundalk

    The recent election was historic for Maryland. The citizens of Maryland voted in a Republican for governor and three new Republican county executives, District 6 is completely Republican now and there were many other Republican winners. There are now 14 Republican senators and 50 Republican...

  • Is Hogan inevitable in 2018?
    Is Hogan inevitable in 2018?

    I couldn't decide whether I was more amused or bemused by Richard J. Cross III's op-ed about the possible Democratic candidates for governor four years from now ("Who will challenge Hogan in 2018?" Nov. 15).