Unlimited Access. Try it Today! Your First 10 Days Always $0.99

Op-Eds

News Opinion Op-Eds

Government is broken, but there is another way to heal what ails us

Can government solve the problem of poverty in America? It is a question worth asking because partisan politics is eroding the federal government's lead role in developing the social welfare policies that have defined much of the country's domestic agenda since the 20th century. Witness the collapse of the Farm Bill in the U.S. House of Representatives last month due to partisan acrimony over its largest spending component, the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, commonly known as food stamps. As a nation, we must evolve from a government-centric safety net just as we moved away from poor houses, orphanages and insane asylums a century ago.

Our government is not the solution. Our divided House and Senate seem incapable of action except in a dire emergency, and sometimes not even then. The result is a dysfunctional domestic agenda. Lyndon Johnson's War on Poverty and Ronald Reagan's admonition that "the best social program is a job" formed the basis of domestic policies decades ago that reflected the mood of the country at the time. There is no governing mission statement like these today with which to move the country in a coherent direction.

Paralysis in Washington and the state capitals has consequences in our communities. The long-term viability of the basic entitlement social safety net programs of Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid is under threat, but they are seen as actuarial abstractions likely to be taken up by some new commission whose recommendations will ultimately get ignored. Social programs that fall under the discretionary budget, such as Head Start, child care and substance-abuse programs are now subject to the sequester, the arbitrary default spending plan that emerged from failed budget negotiations.

As inertia grips the beltway, the rest of the country is splitting into red states and blue states. The number of state capitols dominated by one political party is at historic highs, resulting in uneven implementation of major federal policy initiatives. Maryland embraces the new health care law in its entirety, other states have done all they can to reject it, and some, like Florida, can't make up their minds about whether to take federal money to expand Medicaid.

In between the political left and right, however, is a secret jewel in the free market system. Social enterprises do not rely on government support. Evolving from the corporate philanthropy of Andrew Carnegie and the creation of Goodwill Industries in the 1890s, social enterprises today include organizations like Poverty Cure, an international network of organizations fighting global poverty. They advocate putting the person at the center of our economic thinking and promoting their potential for success.

Social enterprises are attracting world attention as economies in Europe face systemic challenges more difficult than our own. British Prime Minister David Cameron, addressing a conference of social entrepreneurs in June, described social enterprises as a solution to "problems that have frustrated government after government, country after country, generation after generation. Issues like drug abuse, youth unemployment, homelessness and even global poverty."

Closer to home, social enterprises are transforming communities in Main Street America. No law or government program can match the dedication of committed members of a community. I am the CEO of an organization that started as a homeless shelter. Years later, we realized the permanent value we can provide to our community was not temporarily housing people, but providing work in our catering and thrift-store operations.

Baltimore-based Second Chance, Inc. creates "green collar" jobs by taking apart buildings that would otherwise be demolished and dumped in a landfill. The organization then offers the reclaimed materials to the public at a discount, helping fund job training and workforce development programs. Salvaged items available for sale range from rolls of chain link fence to marble fireplace mantels.

Instead of waiting on a top-down solution that may never come, the social enterprise model is a community-driven approach that turns profits, attracts investors and solves social problems. The next evolution in combating poverty is not an uncertain leap with a massive new government program, but a series of deliberate steps in communities throughout our country.

Vann R. Ellison is President and CEO of St. Matthew's House, a Florida-based non-profit organization helping homeless individuals find gainful employment. His email is vann@stmatthewshouse.org.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • The market's invisible, oppressive hand perpetuates poverty
    The market's invisible, oppressive hand perpetuates poverty

    Vann Ellison is right about three things in his recent commentary on poverty and social enterprise ("Beyond government," July 10): Our country hasn't done an effective job of addressing poverty. Partisan gridlock weakens the social safety net and social enterprises can be effective in getting people...

  • TV's Baltimore is not our city
    TV's Baltimore is not our city

    My city is angry. My city is hurting. The recent events that are tearing Baltimore asunder are an unfortunate tipping point that is not simply the result of an isolated incident, nor are they issues that are within anyone's possible understanding to navigate and resolve. The problems are vast and...

  • Police charges in Freddie Gray case are incompetent at best
    Police charges in Freddie Gray case are incompetent at best

    Baltimore State's Attorney Marilyn Mosby's "quick" and "decisive" action in charging six Baltimore police officers a mere two weeks after the death of Freddie Gray reflects either incompetence or an unethical recklessness.

  • Structural accountability after Freddie Gray
    Structural accountability after Freddie Gray

    Those of us who have lived or worked in Baltimore for years know that the city's devastation started long before the recent tragedy involving Freddie Gray and the ensuing protests. Decades of overreliance on incarceration and policing as primary responses to solving — and suppressing — problems...

  • Baltimore, then and now
    Baltimore, then and now

    Of all the images captured of this week's riots in Baltimore, none was more arresting than that of an irate mother chasing, berating and striking her would-be rioter son.

  • Helping Nepal recover
    Helping Nepal recover

    The shaking started just a few hours before a big early birthday party was scheduled for me; I'll turn 90 in June. I was at my house in Nepal, not far from the center of Patan, a city right next to Kathmandu, talking to my driver, Runjin, about hanging some Tibetan flags in my bedroom. As we both...

  • School lessons to be learned from Freddie Gray
    School lessons to be learned from Freddie Gray

    Baltimore can be proud of its civic response to the rioters and to the criminal charges brought against six police officers. We can be optimistic that police brutality will decrease measurably. But the aftermath of the tragedy of Freddie Gray should be far from over. As a city, state and nation,...

  • Expand Job Corps to prevent Freddie Grays
    Expand Job Corps to prevent Freddie Grays

    Events in Baltimore remind us that the dropout-to-prison pipeline costs us all. What most of us don't realize is how much it costs: trillions of dollars in uncollected taxes and unearned income that never enters the economy. A 2010 study by Northeastern University estimates the loss in unpaid taxes...

Comments
Loading

75°