Try digitalPLUS for 10 days for only $0.99

Op-Eds

News Opinion Op-Eds

Too many occupational licenses

Not all occupation licensing laws on the books in Annapolis actually protect Maryland consumers from harm. It's pretty clear that many of these laws misuse state sanctions to protect existing businesses from unwanted competition. Now a new study by the Washington-based Institute for Justice can help Maryland lawmakers decide which of these laws serve the public and should stay — and which should go.

The report, "License to Work: A National Study of Burdens from Occupational Licensing," examines licensing practices for 102 lower-wage occupations in all 50 states. If you want to work in one of the 42 occupations licensed in Maryland, you may need to meet a minimum age requirement, demonstrate a certain level of often-irrelevant experience and training, pass an exam that may have little to do with your job, and pay a licensing fee.

Some licensing requirements make sense. But of the 102 occupations reviewed in the report, only seven — cosmetologist, pest control applicator, school bus driver, city bus driver, emergency medical technician, truck driver and vegetation pesticide handler — are regulated in Maryland and all other states.

Beyond this handful of occupations with widely recognized public health and safety issues, the report questions the motives for licensing many others. "Occupational practitioners," the authors write, "often through professional associations, use the power of concentrated interests to lobby state legislators for protection from competition through licensing laws. Such anti-competitive motives are typically masked by appeals to protecting public health and safety."

There are three ways to sort out the occupations that need state oversight from those that serve no compelling public purpose:

•First, if consumers in more than half of the states get along just fine without regulating an occupation, there is a good chance Maryland's licensing requirements are not necessary. Of the 42 occupations licensed in Maryland, 20 are licensed in fewer than half of the other states. In this category we find the following occupations licensed in Maryland, along with a small number of other states: social and human services assistant, tree trimmer, animal trainer, travel guide, upholster, floor sander contractor, packager and farm labor contractor. Licensing such trades is both unnecessary and foolish.

•Next, if the licensing requirements in Maryland are a lot stiffer than those in use in other states, there is a good chance Maryland's requirements serve mainly to protect existing businesses from competition rather than protect consumers. For example, in Maryland, a pest control applicator needs a year of experience, while the national average is 191 days. To get a massage therapy license requires 327 days of training here, compared to a national average of 139 days.

•Last, if licensing requirements have little to do with protecting the health and safety of Maryland consumers, chances are they have a lot to do with protecting existing businesses from competition. Occupations with little or no public health and safety-based issues, but still licensed in Maryland, include: sheet metal contractor; terrazzo contractor; door repair contractor; mason contractor, drywall installation contractor and glazier contractor.

For those occupations that do not clearly present an obvious need for the state to protect the health and safety of Marylanders, the report identifies private-sector alternatives to state oversight.

One option is voluntary certification through professional associations. This allows practitioners to distinguish themselves but also allows consumers to decide for themselves how much value to place on such credentials. The National Institute for Automotive Service Excellence, for example, presently confers its ASE certificate on about 350,000 mechanics.

In addition, instead of state sanctions, third party consumer organizations such as the Better Business Bureau and Angie's List hold occupational practitioners accountable for the quality of their goods and services.

The report ends with this advice for state policymakers. "When reviewing current or proposed licensing laws, policymakers should demand proof that there is a clear, likely and well-established danger to the public from unlicensed practice. … Forcing would-be workers to take unnecessary classes, engage in lengthy apprenticeships, pass irrelevant exams or clear needless hurdles does nothing to ensure public safety."

Ronald Fraser writes on public policy issues for the DKT Liberty Project, a Washington-based civil liberties organization. His email is fraserr@erols.com.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Tree removal is hazardous work

    Regarding your recent article about the licensing of tree experts, this is very dangerous work, where fatality and injury rates are among the highest for any profession ("Too many occupational licenses?" May 31.)

  • Act to prevent a crude oil derailment in Maryland

    Act to prevent a crude oil derailment in Maryland

    Two years ago, dozens of runaway rail tanker cars carrying 1.5 million gallons of crude oil derailed in the center of the Quebec town of Lac-Megantic, creating a massive explosion and resulting in the death of 47 individuals and the destruction of over 30 buildings. But what would happen if this...

  • You can't compromise with culture warriors

    You can't compromise with culture warriors

    I loved reading the "If You Give a Mouse a Cookie" books to my daughter.

  • Gerrymandering reform: putting the interests of the people before the party

    Gerrymandering reform: putting the interests of the people before the party

    Last week the Supreme Court paved the way for fundamental gerrymandering reform by upholding redistricting commissions that are independent of state legislatures in its decision in Arizona State Legislature v. Arizona Independent Redistricting Commission. Gov. Larry Hogan now has a historic opportunity...

  • Could a state property tax cap stimulate Baltimore's economy?

    Could a state property tax cap stimulate Baltimore's economy?

    When Gov. Larry Hogan announced his rejection of the Red Line, an east-west rail transit line in Baltimore City, he seemed to derail the high hopes of Mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake and many other supporters of the $2.9 billion project. "He canceled a project," lamented the mayor, "that would have...

  • Urban America should give up on the Democrats

    Urban America should give up on the Democrats

    In my lifetime (I was born in 1950), the Democrats have had an extraordinary opportunity to run some of America's largest cities and apply their brand of liberal policies to the social and economic problems that have plagued them. Look at the history in just eight of these cities, according to...

  • Inequality of opportunity in the U.S.A.

    Inequality of opportunity in the U.S.A.

    We like to tell ourselves stories about the virtues of America, particularly as Independence Day rolls around each year. There is, perhaps, no better example than the story we tell our children that no matter your race, gender or wealth, in America you can become anything you want to be. This particular...

  • The burdens of being black

    The burdens of being black

    I was born human more than a half century ago but also birthed with the burden of being black. I discovered racial discrimination early in life. I grew up among the black poor in Hartford, where a pattern of housing segregation prevailed. One city, but separated North end and South end on the basis...

Comments
Loading

73°