Try digitalPLUS for 10 days for only $0.99

Op-Eds

News Opinion Op-Eds

Don't force higher math on our kids

I am about to be highly critical of the new math curriculum to which our children are being subjected. Before doing so, let me state for the record that I am not a Philistine. Personally, I happen to enjoy math — enough to return to school after retirement and take college-level courses to find out what this thing I'd heard of, calculus, was all about.

I am not an educator. My wife and I are college graduates. We have two sons, one of whom was graduated from college and one grandson who is currently in the eighth grade and who will probably attend Poly.

As I understand it, the new curriculum is in large measure an attempt to respond to the fact that the United States lags many other countries in math and science. Another objective of the program is to try to make mathematics relevant to the "real world."

These laudable goals are doomed to failure; the curriculum is far too difficult for most students. I fear that the proverb, "The road to hell is paved with good intentions" fully applies. Clearly, the new curriculum will benefit those who aspire to enter engineering, physics, medicine and similar professions. Further, virtually all of our colleges and universities have a mathematics requirement (more about that later). By all means, challenge these students with the new curriculum — perhaps with even more difficult work.

For all others, I argue that math beyond algebra I (perhaps any algebra) is totally unnecessary and irrelevant. Perhaps even algebra itself. The experience of one person hardly constitutes a scientific study, but I spent my entire professional career as a certified public accountant turned computer programmer and needed to use algebra exactly twice. Both times the mathematics was basic.

Many students continue to struggle with fundamentals, up to and including simple fractions, decimals and percentages. The average student (really, all students) will need instruction in financial literacy. Students need to understand the concept of interest. They need to know how to prepare a budget. They need to know how to comparison-shop.

They do not, however, need to know quadratic equations or the formula for calculating the area of a circle or even that A squared plus B squared equals C squared. They need to understand traffic signs. They do not need to know what the sine of 30 degrees is. They need to develop self-esteem — not be frustrated with concepts that have no relevance for them.

I would teach the new curriculum only to those who aspire to professions that require mathematics beyond algebra 1 and 2. Many colleges will continue to require advanced math. I think this is unfortunate, but it is reality. Therefore, as a practical matter, I would also include those who plan to attend college regardless of career objectives.

For those who will probably not go on to college, the new curriculum should not be required but should certainly be available. I leave it to the administrators to figure out the complications presented by such a dual program.

I have spoken to a few middle school math teachers about the new curriculum. They have been circumspect. After all, they have to live with it. But all said that they had concerns. I suspect that they are really thinking what I have stated — that unless major changes are made, the new curriculum will be used to pave the road to hell.

David Tager is a semi-retired resident of North Baltimore. He helps his grandson with his math homework and the rest of the time spoils him rotten. His email is midwood57@aol.com.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • The importance of math education

    David Tager and others have expressed dismay over the "higher math" that has been imposed upon kids ("Don't force higher math on our kids," Nov. 5). But schools would be doing students a great disservice if they relaxed the math requirement in today's environment.

  • Parents need to teach the joys of math

    Parents shouldn't try to shield their kids from the hard work of getting a good education by protesting the tediousness of math. Math is not just a bunch of abstract equations, it is the language we use to describe how things work.

  • Stop setting up kids for math failure

    David Tager expressed what has been on my mind for so long ("Don't force higher math on our kids," Nov. 5)! As a parent of a college sophomore and a high school senior, I have seen the effects of forced higher math for years. My children are high achievers and successful students in language, reading,...

  • The burdens of being black

    The burdens of being black

    I was born human more than a half century ago but also birthed with the burden of being black. I discovered racial discrimination early in life. I grew up among the black poor in Hartford, where a pattern of housing segregation prevailed. One city, but separated North end and South end on the basis...

  • Partnerships improve health care in Maryland

    Partnerships improve health care in Maryland

    For decades, as health care costs continued to spiral upward and patients were stymied by an increasingly fragmented health care system, policy leaders, politicians and front-line caregivers strained to find a better way to care for people.

  • The deep roots of housing bias

    The deep roots of housing bias

    The Supreme Court's ruling last week that factors other than intentional racial discrimination can be considered in determining whether policies promulgated by government or private entities violate the 1968 Fair Housing Act is simply a reminder that the century-long struggle to end such practices...

  • Political polarization leads to bad legislation

    Political polarization leads to bad legislation

    The Supreme Court's decision in King v. Burwell, permitting 6.4 million Americans to continue receiving subsidies to buy health insurance on the federal insurance exchange, elated liberals and enraged the right. Conservatives have already begun decrying the "traitors" who, though appointed by Republican...

  • Baltimore's broken roadways

    Baltimore's broken roadways

    Baltimore's traffic congestion is awful, causing adverse quality of life and economic consequences. Add to that the effect on air quality and cost of health-related problems caused by vehicle pollution.

Comments
Loading

70°