Unlimited Access. Try it Today! Your First 10 Days Always $0.99

Op-Eds

News Opinion Op-Eds

Harvest of disappointment

As the growing season winds down, one Baltimore City school garden has harvested next to nothing. A project intended to enliven lessons or inspire healthier eating came down to four neglected beds yielding two cinder-block-sized zucchini.

The garden brings to mind an all-too-common twist on the line from the movie "Field of Dreams": If you build it, they won't necessarily come. School-community collaborations like this project have a lot to recommend them and are a favored vehicle for doing more with less at schools. But largesse on one side, in this case the side of the broader community, isn't enough to produce the desired result. However beautiful the dream, the school won't come if it wasn't sufficiently involved in the first place.

A garden at Guilford Elementary/Middle School seemed like a bright idea in the spring of 2011. An energetic young Americorps VISTA member under the wing of a community development organization won money to build the beds. The VISTA worker, juggling many responsibilities, tried to interest teachers or other staff members in the garden as a teaching tool, and got a few nibbles. Who would be against more hands-on science, care for the environment or better nutrition?

But in the new school year, no school staff member emerged with a commitment to the project, perhaps because everyone was already busy and no one knew how to make the garden fit with their existing priorities. The money for it was there, though, and several volunteer master gardeners, trained by University of Maryland's Cooperative Extension Service, were ready. So four sturdy, shin-high garden boxes were built in a day. An involved neighbor also sowed winter wheat that could be turned over to enrich the soil in the spring. The garden was equipped with a tumbling composter bin and a hose on a caddy.

When spring arrived, a staff member from a local university came with a student volunteer to lead an environmental club for an hour a week. Students pulled some of the wheat and stuffed it into the composter. They pressed some seeds into a bed and scooped out a place for a few strawberry plants. The flat with the remaining seedlings languished on the edge of a board for weeks.

In April, Baltimore City school board member Robert W. Heck commented on the garden at a public board meeting, saying he drove past the school often. He asked if he had spied corn growing on the school's grounds. "Well, no, not corn," someone from the school told him. "It's wheat." Calling the garden "a positive note," Mr. Heck urged the school to let him know how the harvest turned out.

In the summer, with the winter wheat still tall in three of the boxes and no one tending the plants in the fourth, money not yet spent from the grant went to a plastic tool shed stocked with trowels, gardening forks and rubber gloves. Within a week or two, young teens, who were also probably students at the school, tore apart the padlocked shed near the garden and scattered the tools. A representative of the community organization reassembled the shed and bought more tools. In another week or so, the shed was smashed beyond repair, most of the tools gone. There had been no one ready to use them anyway.

Where did the project falter? The incentives at play were part of it: Recognition accrues to organizations and the people in them for getting money, starting a project, building something, chalking up partnerships, looking environmentally conscious. The hard work of making a project meaningful in the life of a school — meaningful enough that people on the scene will own the innovation — can easily go unrewarded. In this case, a package of good intentions and misplaced incentives was tied with a bow of wishful thinking.

As this fall rolled around, the neighborhood volunteer weed-whacked the winter wheat into stubble, and the compost bin became an impromptu trash can. After I toted home the giant zucchini, the garden lay fallow except for the tiny strawberry patch.

Maybe that good earth produced some opportunities for students at the school. I'm not sure. Certainly, there are no "bad guys" in this story, and the school and the community have generally had good relations. But I can say that money and time were wasted, projects and partnerships appeared in reports as accomplishments and a school board member took pride in an illusion.

When money is scarce and children are depending on schools to have a chance at a decent life, that's not much of a harvest.

Bess Keller is a graduate student in public policy at University of Maryland, Baltimore County, and a resident of Baltimore. Her email is besskeller@gmail.com.

Clarification: The original version of this article implied that money from the Parks and People Foundation was used to pay for the garden boxes described in the article, which was not the case.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • How to make a garden bloom at Guilford Elementary/Middle

    In "Harvest of disappointment: Good intentions weren't enough to make a garden thrive at on Baltimore school," (November 23), Bess Keller wrote a compassionate and thorough account of the garden project at Guilford Elementary/Middle School — lessons learned about deficiencies in processes. I would...

  • School partnership will go forward despite setback

    A recent op-ed on the Guilford Elementary/Middle School vegetable garden focused on one project that didn't meet expectations ("Harvest of disappointment," Nov. 23). Yet discussions have already begun about how to incorporate the garden into the curriculum next spring, and we hope that this still...

  • Don't hurt my brother
    Don't hurt my brother

    Baltimore illustrator McKenzie Elizabeth Ditter created this poster as part of an effort to raise money for a homeless youth drop-in center that was burned in the rioting. A silent auction of artwork created by local artists will be held at 7 p.m. Friday at Gallery 788 to fund rebuilding. 

  • Police charges in Freddie Gray case are incompetent at best
    Police charges in Freddie Gray case are incompetent at best

    Baltimore State's Attorney Marilyn Mosby's "quick" and "decisive" action in charging six Baltimore police officers a mere two weeks after the death of Freddie Gray reflects either incompetence or an unethical recklessness.

  • Reject the Exelon-Pepco merger
    Reject the Exelon-Pepco merger

    Woefully inadequate. Harmful to Maryland consumers. Not in the public interest.

  • A better Baltimore region depends upon quality education
    A better Baltimore region depends upon quality education

    The eyes of the world remain focused on what's occurring in Baltimore, but the issues underlying the recent unrest are neither new nor unique to our region. What we see people expressing is much more than anguish over the death of Freddie Gray while in police custody, as tragic as that event was....

  • Changing police mindsets post Freddie Gray
    Changing police mindsets post Freddie Gray

    As a former Baltimore City police officer, a former news reporter on Channel 2, and now a member of the clergy and a law enforcement chaplain in Northern Virginia, I am sad watching what is happening in my beloved hometown. Having served in patrol in the Western District for a short time back in...

  • TV's Baltimore is not our city
    TV's Baltimore is not our city

    My city is angry. My city is hurting. The recent events that are tearing Baltimore asunder are an unfortunate tipping point that is not simply the result of an isolated incident, nor are they issues that are within anyone's possible understanding to navigate and resolve. The problems are vast and...

Comments
Loading

79°