Summer Savings! Get unlimited digital access for 13 weeks for $13.
Op-Eds
News Opinion Op-Eds

Rethinking the food vs. fuel debate

This year's drought, along with recent news reports of the lowest corn yield in 17 years, has rekindled the food vs. fuel debate — and, for good reasons. When Congress passed the Energy Independence and Security Act in 2007, an ambitious schedule for incorporating ethanol into the nation's fuel supply known as the Renewable Fuel Standard (RFS) was established. Though ethanol was sold as a way to make our energy supply more secure, little consideration was given to what every farmer knows: Mother Nature can be fickle, as this year's drought proves.

Congress made several faulty assumptions, among them: that future supplies of corn would be plentiful, that demand for motor fuel would increase and that the state of fuel-making technology would ensure our energy future. Lawmakers just bet the market wrong.

This revelation led Maryland Gov. Martin O'Malley to join Delaware Gov. Jack A. Markell to rightly ask the Obama administration for a waiver of the RFS. Likewise, North Carolina Gov. Beverly Perdue, Arkansas Gov. Mike Beebe, Georgia Gov. Nathan Deal and New Mexico Gov. Susana Martinez have petitioned for waivers.

Coming into this year, the nation's corn supply was down a cumulative net 1.3 billion bushels from what was projected in 2007, when the first four years of the RFS was charted out — and the RFS has another 10 years before it is fully implemented in 2022. In 2009, corn yields reached record levels; since that time, annual yields measured by bushels per acre have dropped year over year for the past three years, and the USDA's survey of crop conditions is expected to be 123.4 bushels per acre this year — down 25 percent from 2009.

Corn supplies are not the only faulty assumptions locked into the RFS. Energy consumption and production are also quite different than were projected in 2007.

Ethanol was proposed as a means to reduce dependence on imported oil. That trend is well under way, notwithstanding ethanol, as domestic crude oil production is up 11 percent since 2006 via new finds of domestic oil — specifically the Bakken Shale formation in North Dakota, estimated to hold more than 8 billion barrels of crude.

On the demand side, motor fuel usage has dropped for a variety of reasons. The sluggish state of the economy over the past few years has played a part, but the vast bulk of the decreased consumption, however, is part of a longer-term trend.

As more new, fuel-efficient cars hit the roads, older, less fuel-efficient cars are retired. Also, there are more diesel engines now, a trend also driven by fuel efficiency concerns. And while baby boomers age, there are also fewer young people to join the driving-age population — a double squeeze, since older drivers drive fewer miles

Lastly — and, ironically, done in part to ensure corn supplies weren't over-committed to ethanol — Congress mandated the use of cellulosic ethanol, a fuel that for all intents and purposes did not then exist. So far this year, according to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, which monitors biofuel use, no cellulosic ethanol was delivered to the motor fuel supply. Nor was any supplied last year either.

While the EPA did adjust the mandate down to 6 million gallons last year — a 97 percent reduction from the original quota — oil companies were charged more than $6.8 million in fines for not buying fuel that was not for sale. Not surprisingly, oil companies have sued the federal government over these fines.

With the benefit of a half-decade of hindsight, it's time to reform our renewable-fuels policy and create a clear, effective vision that considers Mother Nature, motor fuel demand and fuel-making technology. Only then will the real winners be both food and fuel.

Dave Juday is an economist specializing in agriculture and conservation issues in the Mid-Atlantic area. He is principal of the Juday Group. His email is dave@thejudaygroup.com.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • How to kill the summer job

    How to kill the summer job

    I had a lot of summer jobs. I was a foot messenger in New York for a couple of summers. I worked as a receptionist and mail room flunky. Before my junior year of high school, I briefly sold ice cream snacks — sort of yuppie bonbons — on the street for a company called Love Bites. The uniform was...

  • Unmasking Dr. Huxtable

    Unmasking Dr. Huxtable

    Like many African-American women, when I heard about the sexual assault accusations against comedian Bill Cosby I was shocked and disappointed. I had difficulty separating my memories of Bill Cosby and his popular '80s sitcom with the new picture that was emerging of a predator whose victims claimed...

  • In Baltimore, hope can be a dangerous thing

    In Baltimore, hope can be a dangerous thing

    On a warm summer Saturday last month, while many of you were relaxing with your families or running errands, I attended the funeral of a 16 year old.

  • Suspensions are the symptom, racism is the cause

    Suspensions are the symptom, racism is the cause

    When my daughter was a junior in high school, she became captain of her softball team. One morning, while she shared some snacks I had brought her with a couple of teammates, a teacher accused her of selling food. He then confiscated my daughter's bag, violating the school board policy that gives...

  • Addressing the work family balance

    Addressing the work family balance

    Whatever you think about Sen. Bernie Sanders and business billionaire Donald Trump, it is exciting to see the chorus of viewpoints being offered by more than a dozen presidential candidates (16 on the GOP side alone). The summer of 2015 is hardly going to be a sleeper.

  • Debates vs. debates

    Debates vs. debates

    WARWICK, England -- When it comes to debates the Oxford Union, which bills itself as the "world's most prestigious debating society," remains the gold standard. Begun in 1823, The Union, in modern times, has hosted debates that have included such luminaries as Ronald Reagan and the Dalai Lama....

Comments
Loading
79°