Try digitalPLUS for 10 days for only $0.99


News Opinion Op-Eds

The right to birth control

Each year in Maryland, approximately 75,000 women unintentionally become pregnant. Of those pregnancies, about 36,000 end in abortions and 8,000 end in miscarriages. Additionally, many unintended pregnancies lead to premature births, low birthweight babies and poor maternal health outcomes. Almost all of these unintended pregnancies are preventable with modern contraception, which should be readily available for every American.

We, as medical students at the Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, strongly disagree with any employer — religious or otherwise — that would refuse to provide full insurance coverage, including contraception, for its employees.

Last year, the Institute of Medicine recommended that the U.S. government require health insurers to provide certain preventive services without co-pays or deductibles, including contraceptives, as part of the Affordable Care Act. National Catholic leaders, including Cardinal-designate Edwin F. O'Brienof Baltimore, have said that they would not comply with the law on religious grounds. After President Barack Obama announced a compromise on Friday — that insurance companies must provide free contraceptives when employers refuse to pay — Catholic officials still were not moved.

As physicians in training, we see contraception as an essential component of effective primary care, not as a political line item in Washington or the Vatican. Just as we provide tetanus shots and Pap smears, we prescribe contraception to maintain the well-being of our patients. Universal contraceptive access is a matter of reproductive justice and a major determinant of whether both men and women have control over their own futures, regardless of socioeconomic status.

There are about 695,000 women of reproductive age in Maryland who are sexually active and do not want to become pregnant. Unintended pregnancy rates are three times higher for those below the federal poverty line than for those above it. Given this reality, universal access to contraception is essential to preventing thousands of unintended pregnancies, miscarriages and abortions — a goal one might reasonably expect religious leaders to support.

Contraception is simply not an optional add-on to the health care we provide. We discuss birth control in our medical school classes as an essential tool to prevent maternal morbidity, birth defects and fetal death. Women who become pregnant unintentionally are more likely to get an abortion, smoke while pregnant, enter late into prenatal care and give birth to a low-birthweight baby. For women with underlying medical conditions, unintended pregnancies substantially increase the risk of permanent disability or death. Moreover, the health benefits of contraceptives extend well beyond preventing unintended pregnancy. In a recent national survey of oral-contraceptive users, 58 percent of women used the Pill for purposes other than family planning, such as menstrual pain, acne or endometriosis.

The significant risks of unintended pregnancy explain why 94 percent of primary-care providers in the U.S. agree that tax dollars should be used to provide contraception to low-income women, according to an article published last month in the journal Contraception. We are students who entered the medical profession in order to help those who need our care most, and we have no desire to practice medicine with our hands tied by ideological employers.

The Affordable Care Act does not require anyone to receive health care services that they do not want; it allows Americans to avoid unintended pregnancies through safe and effective means. Our country's employment-based health insurance system does not give employers the standing to deny their employees safe and effective health care.

While the Affordable Care Act undoubtedly has limitations, the required coverage of certain preventive services is effectively a no-brainer. If our country's health system is ever going to transition from primarily treating illness to a focus on preventing illness, then we must start making evidence-based preventive services widely available.

In Maryland alone, taxpayers annually pay for 14,500 government-funded births from unintended pregnancies, costing $94.8 million from the federal budget and $93.8 million from the state budget, according to an analysis in the Guttmacher Institute's Perspectives on Sexual and Reproductive Health. While the goals of each insurance company are to minimize costs in providing care to individual patients and their families, our society needs to advocate for preventive services like contraception to avert a stifling burden of disease for years to come.

As physicians in training, as Baltimoreans, as patients and as Americans, we believe that access to contraception and other essential health services is a human right. The Obama administration's announcement that insurance companies must provide contraception averts an immediate threat to women's health; however, we fear the continued erosion of women's right to access contraception in the name of religious liberty. We look forward to practicing medicine in a country where all individuals have the right to complete health care — including contraception without deductibles and co-pays.

Max Romano is a medical student at the Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine. His email is Contributing to this article are Hopkins medical students Meghana Desale, Lorena Leite, Tatyana Lyapustina, Kathryn Miele, Amir Mohareb, Samuel Scharff, Naomi Rios and Katie Washington. The views expressed are the authors' and not necessarily those of the Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Government and medicine: Not always what the doctor orders

    Max Romano and fellow medical students at Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine ended their recent op-ed with this sentence, "We look forward to practicing medicine in a country where all individuals have the right to complete health care — including contraception without deductibles and...

  • On birth control, young Republicans get it

    On birth control, young Republicans get it

    Two-thirds of young Republicans believe that every woman should have access to affordable birth control, 65 percent believe that insurance companies should cover contraception without co-pays and 51 percent believe that the federal government should continue to fund contraceptive services for low-income...

  • Where OB-GYNs stand on over the counter birth control [Letter]

    Where OB-GYNs stand on over the counter birth control [Letter]

    A recent exchange within your opinion pages debated the benefit of over-the-counter access to oral contraceptives, with a letter to the editor ("Sun wrong on OTC birth control," Sept. 16) citing the American Congress of Obstetricians and Gynecologists as being supportive of recent proposals from...

  • Pills don't prevent STDs

    Pills don't prevent STDs

    This letter is in response to Susan Reimer's column about the GOP's attitude about birth control ("On birth control, young Republicans get it," April 15). I think Ms. Reimer's opinion is very narrow-minded. While I agree that young people often have premarital sex with no desire to procreate, I...

  • Birth control bait-and-switch [Editorial]

    Birth control bait-and-switch [Editorial]

    Our view: GOP candidates are touting their newfound support for expanded access to contraceptives, but the ploy could backfire

  • Why is Mikulski trying to 'fix' the Supreme Court's decision? [Letter]

    Why is Mikulski trying to 'fix' the Supreme Court's decision? [Letter]

    On her website, Sen. Barbara Mikulski proclaims that she is joining other senators to introduce a "legislative fix to protect women's health" following the Supreme Court's recent decision in the Hobby Lobby case. Whether you are for abortion or against abortion, whether you think your employer...

  • Pushy pro-lifers [Letter]

    Pushy pro-lifers [Letter]

    Letter writer Mary Catalfamo claims that Planned Parenthood denies any pregnant women immediate, free access to the full spectrum of information and counseling ("Supreme Court decisions won't limit women's rights," July 9).

  • An effort to shame, cloaked in the guise of women's empowerment [Letter]

    An effort to shame, cloaked in the guise of women's empowerment [Letter]

    Regarding the recent rant by small business woman and political activist Michelle Jefferson ("Stop griping and get a grip, ladies," July 11), it seems that she missed the most basic and fundamental message of the women's movement in the last century: don't leave your sisters behind.