Try digitalPLUS for 10 days for only $0.99


News Opinion Op-Eds

A crisis in Central America

A crisis of enormous economic and humanitarian impact is unfolding in Central America, and it's hard to find much mention of it in our national media, other than constant references to a result of the crisis: tens of thousands of human beings, many of them unaccompanied children, trying desperately to enter our country illegally. They are attempting to escape the poverty, gang violence and drug wars raging in their home countries, and they are flooding our border and overwhelming our immigration authorities. More than 50,000 children have already arrived, most of them now detained in facilities along the border, and every indication is that this is simply the beginning.

The White House on Monday indicated that most of the arrivals will be deported home, without much discussion of the homes to which they'll return. With the growing recognition of the importance of Hispanic influence in the United States, one might expect more attention would be paid to what's happening in the countries from which this tidal wave is coming. But some things are slow to change. Latin America never seems to capture much of our national attention, unless war breaks out or a World Cup arrives in Brazil.

Central America was a hot political issue in the 1980s, with civil wars and human rights concerns in El Salvador, Guatemala, Honduras and Nicaragua. President Ronald Reagan gave nationally televised speeches and appointed a presidential commission, chaired by former Secretary of State Henry Kissinger, to address the issues we faced. When those immediate challenges faded, however, so did our collective focus on events in what is sometimes called our "back yard" but really is our "front yard."

When George W. Bush, the Spanish-speaking governor of Texas, was elected president, I assumed U.S. foreign policy would focus intensely to our south. But 9/11 happened, and ever since our attention has been mostly on the Middle East, with occasional thought of a "re-set" with Russia or a "pivot to Asia." Central America, arguably of equal or greater import to our immediate interests given the threats posed by drugs and the deluge of illegal immigration, apparently remains on the back burner for the Obama administration, as it did for his predecessor. We need to move it to the front of the stove.

Almost 30 years ago, as a member of the Kissinger Commission, I joined with my colleagues in proposing a major U.S. program to promote economic development, education and job creation in Central America. Republicans like New York Rep. Jack Kemp and Ambassador Jeane Kirkpatrick joined Democrats like Washington Sen. Henry M. "Scoop" Jackson and AFL-CIO President Lane Kirkland to advocate spending $450 million to jump start the effort.

We felt that this could lessen the causes of the existing civil unrest and offer opportunities to young people so they wouldn't feel their only hope for a brighter future was to hop a train heading north. However, for all the usual reasons, nothing came of it, and one can only speculate on how different things might be today if that kind of investment had been made over these decades educating young Central Americans and stimulating economic opportunity. I still believe it would have been much cheaper than our military expenditures and the costs of dealing with the massive drug and immigration challenges we now confront. And we might not be witnessing the unbelievable tragedy of children dying in our southwestern desert.

It's past time for another presidential initiative to consider ways to improve conditions in Central America, address the challenges of drugs and migration and work with all responsible actors in the region. In the spirit of President John Kennedy's Alliance for Progress, this should not be a purely North American venture. Frankly, given our recent perceived indifference, that wouldn't be taken seriously by many of our neighbors in any event. Far better for President Obama to ask Former Costa Rican President Oscar Arias to convene a White House sponsored summit to begin this process. The Nobel Prize winner for his crucial role in bringing peace to Central America is perhaps the most respected individual in the region, and he has a proven record of actually achieving difficult goals. Many of us who care deeply about Latin America and its relations with the United States would be eager to support such an effort.

There are many crises in the world, but none of them hits closer to home than this one. We continue to ignore it at our national peril.

Michael D. Barnes is a former chair of the Western Hemisphere Subcommittee of the House Committee on Foreign Affairs. He is a Senior Fellow at the Center for International Policy in Washington. His email is

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • A call for compassion [Commentary]

    A call for compassion [Commentary]

    We cannot expect other countries to open their borders for refugees if we're unwilling to do the same

  • U.S. needs more young immigrants [Letter]

    U.S. needs more young immigrants [Letter]

    A recent article described the efforts of young people to escape poverty and terror in Central America and seek refuge in the United States. There are those who argue that we should stem this flow of refugees and send those in our borders back to where they came from. I say, nonsense, welcome as...

  • Obama requests $3.7 billion to address influx of immigrant children

    Obama requests $3.7 billion to address influx of immigrant children

    Mikulski will play role in moving request through Senate

  • We're going to owe a lot to Caitlyn Jenner

    We're going to owe a lot to Caitlyn Jenner

    Caitlyn Jenner — who purposely did not spell her new name with a K — is going to absorb an unimaginable amount of attention for the rest of her life. Whatever is not emotionally draining is going to be bruising. I do not envy her, but we owe her our gratitude.

  • Hogan fails on forfeiture reform

    Last month, Gov. Larry Hogan vetoed a civil asset forfeiture reform bill that had been passed nearly unanimously by the State Senate. Senate Bill 528 would have closed the "equitable sharing" loophole that perversely incentivizes Maryland's law enforcement agencies to circumvent state forfeiture...

  • The Common Core can't speed up child development

    The Common Core can't speed up child development

    Recent evaluations of the state's preschoolers have determined that only 47 percent are ready for kindergarten, compared to 83 percent judged ready last year. This drastic drop isn't the result of an abrupt, catastrophic decline in the cognitive abilities of our children. Instead it results from...

  • The mixed blessing of Bill Clinton

    The mixed blessing of Bill Clinton

    In Bill Clinton's 1992 election victory, he talked of voters getting "two for the price of one," referring to his wife, Hillary, as a brainy political activist who would bring an added bonus to his presidency. By and large it worked, as her popularity soared, especially among Democratic women.

  • Expanding autism program could help thousands in Maryland

    Expanding autism program could help thousands in Maryland

    In my work with children on the autism spectrum, I have witnessed and been deeply touched by the sacrifices that families make and the struggles they face to obtain necessary services for their children. Their journey to ensure their children have the best lives possible is often frustrating, isolating...