Become a digitalPLUS subscriber. 99¢ for 4 weeks.
NewsOpinionOp-Eds

Why did the U.S. go to bat for Morsi?

ElectionsMohamed MorsiExecutive BranchChicago Tribune ColumnistsEgyptian Protests (2012-2013)U.S. Department of State

Mohamed Morsi holds a singular distinction.

While president of Egypt, he was the world's only democratically elected leader to motivate more than 20 million of his people, one-quarter of the population, to sign a petition calling for his ouster.

Millions of these people began showing up at angry, sometimes violent demonstrations in Cairo and other cities a week ago, the one-year anniversary of his rule. They're irate about Mr. Morsi's blatant leadership failures. Egypt is riven with enervating economic, political and social problems of the sort it has never experienced before. That prompted military leaders to warn Mr. Morsi on Monday that if he didn't find a solution within 48 hours, they would. He didn't, and they did, in what Mr. Morsi's supporters are calling a coup d'etat. The military has named an interim leader and announced plans for new elections.

So why has the United States been so doggedly supporting Mr. Morsi? U.S. Ambassador Anne Patterson spent last week trying to convince several groups to stay out of the demonstrations.

For example, Egyptian papers reported that she asked the Coptic Christian pope to urge his flock not to participate — even though Mr. Morsi stood by watching as Islamic fundamentalists injured and killed hundreds of Copts. The pope politely told her he couldn't do that.

Washington has been standing up for Mr. Morsi because it's a knee-jerk State Department reaction. State's bureaucrats feel a need to support many leaders of important countries, no matter how incompetent and feckless they may be. During Egypt's 2011 uprising, the Obama administration stood by Hosni Mubarak until it was perfectly obvious he was about to fall.

This time, word of Ms. Patterson's foolish and pointless effort got out, and some protesters waved banners lambasting the U.S. One said: "Obama Supports Terrorism." On Egyptian TV, Mustafa Bakari, a former member of parliament, showed a photo of Ms. Patterson meeting the Muslim Brotherhood's leader, Mohammed Badie, and called Ms. Patterson "a member of" the Brotherhood's "sleeper cells."

Mr. Mubarak was a ruthless dictator, but in some ways Mr. Morsi was even worse. Last month, for example, he appointed a former member of a terrorist group as governor of Luxor — even though that same group once massacred scores of tourists in the same city. The outrage over the appointment was so loud that the tourism minister quit, and a few days later the new governor was forced to resign.

That's a PR fiasco. But the problems run much deeper. Mr. Morsi's policies (or lack of them) have so ravaged the economy that inflation is running at about 8.5 percent. Unemployment is nearly 15 percent — the highest in memory. Gas shortages have led to many-hour lines at gas stations. Daily electricity shortages are widespread, and the country is facing bread shortages everywhere. At the same time, Mr. Morsi was prosecuting many of his critics.

For all this and more, Mr. Morsi and his aides repeatedly blamed the news media and, as he recently put it, "remnants of the old regime."

All of that has driven public approval so low that it's comparable to Richard Nixon's at the height of the Watergate scandal. Mr. Morsi lost virtually everyone in the country except Muslim Brotherhood followers. Even Salafists, the state's Islamic extremists, gave up on him.

A new Zogby poll of 5,029 Egyptians nationwide shows that only 28 percent of Egyptians support Morsi. He "has virtually no support among Egyptians not affiliated with the president's party," the poll said.

Given that, it's especially confounding that the U.S. has been standing up for him.

I wonder if the State Department is aware that Mr. Morsi was also a 9/11 denier, one who showed his contempt for the U.S. by charging that the September 2001 attacks were a U.S. government plot intended to justify American aggression against the Islamic world.

In a Brookings Institution interview three years ago, Mr. Morsi said: "When you come and tell me that plane hit the tower like a knife in butter, then you're insulting us. How did the plane cut through steel like this? Something must have happened from the inside."

My advice to Ambassador Patterson: Just stay out of it. Egyptians have every right to protest, just like anyone else. Criticizing them is hypocritical. You're in your early 60s, so you certainly remember the massive demonstrations in Washington against Nixon and the Vietnam War.

Don't Egyptians have the same right?

Joel Brinkley is the Hearst professional in residence at Stanford University and a Pulitzer Prize-winning former correspondent for The New York Times.

Copyright © 2014, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
ElectionsMohamed MorsiExecutive BranchChicago Tribune ColumnistsEgyptian Protests (2012-2013)U.S. Department of State
  • In Egypt, signs of hope, not 'hijacking' [Letter]
    In Egypt, signs of hope, not 'hijacking' [Letter]

    I have been working in Egypt on various development projects for more than 15 years now and have been present here for seven to eight months in each of the past three years. I have personally witnessed every significant sociopolitical event here over that time and am in constant conversation...

  • The limits of power
    The limits of power

    Our view: A suspension of U.S. military aid may be too little, too late to force Egypt's generals to restore civilian rule

  • Obama's bungled Middle East policy
    Obama's bungled Middle East policy

    It can now be said that President Barack Obama was instrumental and outspoken in causing the ouster of Egypt's President Hosni Mubarak, even though Egypt had been a friend of the United States and had kept general peace in the Middle East for some 30 years, especially between Egypt and...

  • America's exasperation doctrine
    America's exasperation doctrine

    Liberals and conservatives alike are getting tired of seeing no results from our entanglements with the Middle East

  • Obama is out of step in Egypt again
    Obama is out of step in Egypt again

    Our view: America's continued support of Egypt's military is strategically and morally untenable after Wednesday's violence that left hundreds dead

  • Egypt's descent into chaos
    Egypt's descent into chaos

    Our view: Two weeks after deposing the country's first democratically elected president, Egypt's generals offer little hope for a speedy restoration of civilian rule

  • Egypt's revolution, Part II
    Egypt's revolution, Part II

    Our view: The country's fledgling democracy is imperiled anew by the generals who are once again calling the shots

  • Egypt at a crossroads
    Egypt at a crossroads

    Our view: With violent protests in the streets against President Morsi, time is running out for a political solution to the country's crisis

Comments
Loading