Try digitalPLUS for 10 days for only $0.99

Op-Eds

News Opinion Op-Eds

Marches and more police won't stop Baltimore's violence

Violence in Baltimore is not unique or even out of the ordinary — it is to be expected. For those of us who grew up in neighborhoods that were more like war zones and in communities that were more like deserts, the truth underlying the violence within this city can be found in our own narratives, our minds, bodies and souls. For those of us who have struggled to survive on little to nothing, went to schools that operated more like prisons than places of critical learning and engagement, or suffered harassment within various institutions because perceived or actual sexual orientation, the context underpinning not only the violence recently but also the violence that has persisted since my childhood is crystal clear.

Whether we are discussing violence writ large in Baltimore or this recent upsurge of gun violence in the city, it behooves us to see these incidents not as abnormalities but as symptoms of underlying social and cultural issues that have gone unchecked for decades. With drastic cuts to vital civic support services over the years, it is no surprise to me that violence persists and spikes. I hope that we take this moment, on the heels of devastating news about gun violence, to have a different conversation and provide different solutions for this pernicious series of events.

While more policing seems intuitive and the obvious way to stop the violence in Baltimore, it will not. History has shown us, especially in Baltimore, that more policing simply displaces violence but never effectively stops it. That is what has happened as a result of the blue light cameras, and it could be seen again last week when four people were shot just around the corner from a block that police had effectively walled off. Some might even argue that greater policing only serves to create and sustain root cause issues that fuel violence; it sends more people to prison, which makes them unemployable and prone to more crime when they return to their neighborhoods.

It is my belief that to meaningfully address the issue of gun violence we must remedy the underlying causes. I grew up in South Baltimore, mostly Cherry Hill, one of the most economically depressed neighborhoods in the city. I now know from experience and education what I knew intuitively as a child — that we must rectify black unemployment and underemployment if we are to effectively deal with gun violence. We must talk about both race and racism, what it means to be both black and of low socioeconomic status in Baltimore, and how it often forces people to the margins all the while denying them access to vital support services.

To effectively address gun violence in Baltimore City we must address the contexts that produce violence. We must dismantle the school-to-prison pipeline, stop intimate partner violence, and not only interrupt bullying based on perceived or actual sexual orientation and gender expression but also create affirming spaces for all youth to feel safe and supported. The reality of the situation in Baltimore is indeed dire and holistic, and systematic approaches are what is needed to curb the tide of violence.

Therefore, I do not believe that events like the recent 300 Man March or more police presence is enough to rectify this string of gun violence or the long history of violence that has plagued Baltimore since my childhood. These types of responses attempt to address individual level issues, which is absolutely critical, but they fall overwhelmingly short in addressing the larger systematic and sociocultural context that fuels and sustains violence in its many manifestations. What is truly required to address gun violence in Baltimore cannot and will not be remedied by 300 men and will most likely only be exacerbated by increased police presence.

Instead, what we really need is authentic dialogue around race, gender, sexuality and how some kinds of violence are treated differently from others. We need to hear not only from the men who are most immediately impacted, but we must also hear from women and the youth. Ultimately, we need more affordable housing, increased employment opportunities, better schools, more parks and playgrounds, more recreational centers, affordable child care, an increased minimum wage and meaningful employment for youth. In reality, effectively addressing gun violence should be less about capturing the "bad" guys but instead should be concerned about the social and cultural forces that produce them.

Durryle Brooks, a Baltimore native, is a doctoral student in Social Justice Education at the University of Massachusetts Amherst. His email is dnbrooks@smcm.edu.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Baltimore's violent spring

    Baltimore's violent spring

    I watch with incredulity as my Baltimore teeters. Major crises have seemed to grow exponentially these past few weeks. Politicians and people of law enforcement are buckling at the knee. With few exceptions, they seem helpless, at times hapless.

  • Who will stand up to the violence?

    Who will stand up to the violence?

    Baltimore's Western Police District, the part of town where 25-year-old Freddie Gray was fatally injured following his arrest in April and where the subsequent protests and violence were centered, has seen nearly as many murders so far this year as it did in all of 2014. Of the 95 homicides so...

  • Metrics of Baltimore's distress

    Metrics of Baltimore's distress

    Reading your paper lately has become quite depressing. Perhaps you could start publishing a front-page table showing the number of people shot to death each day, plus the number of heroin overdose deaths and the number of infants delivered in the city's hospitals.

  • Can Batts get the job done?

    Can Batts get the job done?

    Police Commissioner Anthony Batts says violence is out of control in the Western District in part because his officers find themselves surrounded by people with video cameras every time they show up to do even the most routine police work. To give him some credit for his first significant public...

  • Batts is not the problem

    Batts is not the problem

    I like Police Commissioner Anthony Batts. I like what he says about Baltimore and I like what he says about policing. He has not been anywhere near as successful implementing his style on the Baltimore City Police Department as we might have wished. The big question is what to do about it ("Batts...

  • Spate of shootings deserves protest

    Spate of shootings deserves protest

    Where are the protesters and politicians now ("Deadly month sees 35 killings," May 26)?

  • Why aren't black leaders talking about personal responsibility?

    Why aren't black leaders talking about personal responsibility?

    Nothing will change until that happens.

  • Baltimore is reeling

    Baltimore is reeling

    Baltimore is on its knees. It is probably the only major American city where the prisoners ran the detention facility with the full cooperation of jail employees.

Comments
Loading

73°