Unlimited Access. Try it Today! Your First 10 Days Always $0.99
News Opinion Op-Eds

Reform bail system, don't discard it [Commentary]

The Sun editorial on amending the bail system ("Better Bail," Nov. 29) argues that changing the bail system from a financial-based system to a risk-based system would provide a fairer way of getting defendants to court regardless of financial status, but such a move would likely create many more problems that it will ever solve.

Judges make decisions about bail with input from prosecutors, defense attorneys and pretrial investigators. The system we have now, while far from perfect, mandates that defendants who deserve release on some kind of bail will get a bail as long as there is a surety attached to them coming to court.

By having bail bondsmen involved, there are licensed, bonded, insured officers of the court who take on significant risk for a defendant deciding to skip town and not appear for court.

The reality show "Dog: Bounty Hunter" showcased these risks when star Duane Chapman and his team were dispatched to locales across the country to chase suspects who skipped their obligation to come to court.

Bail bondsmen can be on the hook for hundreds of thousands of dollars if their clients don't show up to court, and they are a very good check and balance on defendants thinking of skipping.

Bondsmen are required to take 10 percent down, such as $10,000 on a $100,000 bond, though most will take less up front and collect the rest in a payment plan.

It is true that poorer defendants (and their families) won't always have the money to make bond even when the amount might be reasonable for more well-off defendants. But that's a reason to improve the system, not throw it out.

Cash bails are not the answer. They force clients to come up with cash, the entire amount, and poorer defendants rarely can afford that, whereas someone in their family might be able to afford putting up equity in a home as surety, where less cash is needed.

Requiring bondsmen to collect less than 10 percent is an option. If bondsmen were forced to collect only, say, five percent on bonds higher than $50,000, then more defendants could afford the bail if payment plan amounts could also be amended.

Without having some kind of prod, defendants released in a risk-based system, which seeks to gauge their likelihood of flight or danger, won't have any incentive to come to court with nothing holding as surety. The higher-risk defendants would still be sitting where they are now, held without bail in jail until their trial dates.

The state would be forced, on the lower-risk ones, to spend thousands of dollars chasing those who disappear and have no assistance from the bondsmen. Now, bondsmen have the onus to chase skips because it's their money — or insurance rates — on the line.

So, let's improve but not jettison this system.

Thomas Maronick Jr. is a Baltimore lawyer and radio host on "The Tom Moore Show" on AM 680 WCBM. His email is tom@maronicklaw.com.

To respond to this commentary, send an email to talkback@baltimoresun.com. Please include your name and contact information.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Maryland's pretrial detention is unfair [Commentary]

    Delays in reform lead to added taxpayer expense and unnecessary incarceration for some defendants

  • What lurks in the shadowy corners of the Internet
    What lurks in the shadowy corners of the Internet

    Ever heard of "doxxing" or "revenge porn"? How about the names Violentacrez or Craig Brittain?

  • Respect the office, if not the man
    Respect the office, if not the man

    I am no fan of President Barack Obama. I have been openly critical of him, particularly of his foreign policy. I think he has led this country in the wrong direction, both when he could reign unopposed during his first two years backed by a full Democratic majority and when we, Republicans, let...

  • Childhood obesity: an epidemic

    During the last legislative session, I introduced a bill to give Maryland's children a better tomorrow. It required restaurants to offer only water or milk with children's meals (included in the meal price) instead of high-sugar and caloric beverages. Other beverages would still have been...

  • Obama can't escape war
    Obama can't escape war

    There's a certain irony in the fact that the American president who won the office vowing to end the two wars he inherited finds himself after six years as much a wartime president as the man he succeeded.

  • Helping ex-offenders stay out of prison
    Helping ex-offenders stay out of prison

    Every year, roughly 10,000 people leave prison and return to Baltimore City; 4,000 of them — 40 percent — will return to prison within three years. This must change.

Comments
Loading