Save 75% - Only $49.99 for 1 full year! digitalPLUS subscription offer ends 12/1

School funding mandate hurts counties

Laws and LegislationBudgets and BudgetingLocal GovernmentJustice System

A recent editorial in The Sun on education funding indicated that Maryland's counties are backing down from their support of public schools and transferring local government funding responsibility to the state. In Anne Arundel County, nothing could be further from the truth.

Here are a few facts:

Since the introduction of the Thornton Commission's "Bridge to Excellence Program," Anne Arundel County has increased its unrestricted funding for K-12 education by more than $194 million and a total of $207 million in excess of minimum funding requirements during that decade. This represented a 64 percent increase in county funding during a period when student enrollment increased only 2.5 percent.

Further, the county's contribution represents a substantial and ongoing local commitment to educating children. That $207 million excess amount accounts for 94 percent of the growth in the county's contributions to its schools.

Stated otherwise, over the period of the state's Thornton funding formula, Anne Arundel County provided its school system $1.94 for every $1 it was required to give. That's nearly twice as much as the law requires.

The problem is not a lack of county funding. The underlying problem is that Maryland's constitutional requirement of a thorough and efficient system of public education imposes fiscal mandates on the counties without ensuring fiscal accountability from local boards of education. For example, state law imposes a minimum level of county funding for schools but then forbids local governments from any reasonable level of fiscal oversight — such as the number and salaries of nonclassroom employees.

In the current fiscal environment, the state mandate forces counties into a no-win decision to fund schools at state-mandated levels and drastically curtail public services such as police, fire, senior centers and libraries.

The cold reality of my five-year tenure as county executive makes this point directly and unequivocally: The Board of Education budget has increased 17 percent, while the budgets of all other county agencies in the aggregate have declined 7 percent.

The state's maintenance of effort mandate has come up hard against the prolonged economic downturn that has decimated county budgets. In an era when the expenditure of every tax dollar should be microscopically scrutinized, the state's mandate ensures that county boards of education get an increased level of funding every year. This eliminates any incentive for a board to develop efficiencies or reduce nonclassroom spending to focus on the children. (The state includes Anne Arundel on its list of school systems failing to meet maintenance of effort requirements, an assertion that we strongly dispute.)

This insular view of budgeting allowed the Anne Arundel County school board to ignore the recommendation of the county executive and budget decision of the County Council and purchase a $4.5 million computer system for human resources and payroll needs. This decision was made despite the fact that, in the interest of efficiency, the county offered its payroll system to the board. After struggling for four years to make the system work, the school board finally gave up and declared the system inoperable.

Another example of the "silo" approach to budgeting empowers school boards to negotiate labor contracts completely independent of county labor relations. In recent years, this has resulted in nonclassroom employees of the Board of Education receiving salary and benefit increases that had been denied to county employees performing similar functions.

The Sun's comment that it's time for some "tough love" is on point but focuses on the wrong target for that "love." State laws governing school boards and their budgets need greater transparency and accountability. It's time for a major revision to Maryland's school funding laws to include increased local oversight over non-classroom expenditures, recognition of the significant county funding increases in past years, and a system of combined state and county funding that recognizes that the sources of all those dollars — the taxpayers — are not a bottomless well that supplies annual school budget increases regardless of the cost to other essential county services.

John R. Leopold is the Anne Arundel county executive. His email is

Copyright © 2014, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
Laws and LegislationBudgets and BudgetingLocal GovernmentJustice System
  • Chuck Hagel leaves Obama's war against war
    Chuck Hagel leaves Obama's war against war

     The surprising decision of Secretary of Defense Chuck Hagel to leave his Pentagon post after only 21 months of service has been widely greeted as a combination of his frustration in the job and a conclusion at the White House that he turned out to be the wrong man...

  • Giving thanks for ugly fruit
    Giving thanks for ugly fruit

    It was the last outing of our harvest season, and 500 pounds of apples lay before us in 25 bags. A group of nine harvesters from the Baltimore Orchard Project combed through the fruit trees for the last of the yield at this impeccably-kept orchard so we could give the fruit to those in need.

  • Don't reduce city schools' capital funding
    Don't reduce city schools' capital funding

    Baltimore should be proud of its tremendous achievement to secure approximately $1 billion to fully rebuild and renovate up to 28 school buildings over the next 5 years — the first phase of the city schools' 21st Century Buildings program. This is the single largest investment in...

  • 'OUR Walmart' is a union front
    'OUR Walmart' is a union front

    The Friday after Thanksgiving, also known as Black Friday, is reliably one of the busiest shopping days of the year. And, just as reliably, you can expect a group called OUR Walmart, which is financed by the United Food and Commercial Workers union (UFCW), to attempt to disrupt the day with...

  • Better management of manure long overdue
    Better management of manure long overdue

    We commend Gov. Martin O'Malley's decision to proceed with science-based management requirements to reduce the significant flow of Chesapeake Bay-choking phosphorus from farmland already saturated with an excess of the nutrient. We fully support the proposal and urge the new governor and...

  • Cold War all over again?
    Cold War all over again?

    Reading the latest headlines transports me into my childhood, which was spent in a country that no longer exists. I grew up in St. Petersburg, then in the USSR, in the mid '70s and '80s. The Cold War was in full swing. The news stories that involve Russia now are almost identical to the ones...