Become a digitalPLUS subscriber. 99¢ for 4 weeks.
News Opinion Op-Eds

Black students sent away

Those who know the story first-hand have dwindled to a precious few.

For more than 40 years, Maryland taxpayers paid for the graduate education of hundreds of African-American teachers, lest they breach the walls of segregation at the University of Maryland.

From the mid-1930s until 1957, the teachers boarded trains in Baltimore for weekend and summer study at some of the finest schools in the land, including New York University, Columbia University, Oberlin College and the University of Chicago.

Tuition, travel and living expenses were paid by a state government afraid of lawsuits like the one that forced the University of Maryland to open its law school to an African-American, Donald G. Murray, in 1935. (Murray's lawyer was a young African-American from Baltimore named Thurgood Marshall.)

Those who took advantage of the "out-of-state scholarship program" returned to Maryland to take up positions among the educated black elite. They've long since retired. Many have died.

The oldest, Lena K. Lee, a longtime principal who became a lawyer and served 16 years in the General Assembly, will be 98 in July.

"I'm the last leaf on the tree," says Lee, who commuted to New York University on and off for nearly two decades before earning a master's degree about 1950. "I obviously didn't go straight through. Some winters I just couldn't take it."

Larry Gibson, a University of Maryland law professor and authority on civil rights litigation, has studied the out-of-state scholarship program.

"After the Murray case, they really got it going about 1937, and it was well-funded after that," Gibson says. "The irony, of course, is that a lot of African-Americans got their degrees at top-flight schools, schools like Barnard and New York University."

Another irony is that after the Brown decision opened the University of Maryland to all races in 1954, many of the out-of-state scholarship recipients earned advanced degrees at the school that once shunned them. And one of them, Wilbur G. Valentine, 87, served for a time on the University of Maryland Board of Regents.

"I didn't waste time on resentment," says Valentine, who graduated from what is now Coppin State University in 1936. "There was nothing you could do about it at the time. [Segregation] was the law of the land. And when Brown came along, we all wondered why it took so long."

Most of the scholarship holders were working teachers with undergraduate degrees from Coppin or Morgan State College, which then had no graduate education schools. Some teachers got up at 4 a.m. Saturday, caught a train to New York and took classes all day, returning late to Baltimore. Some stayed over Saturday night, but all had to be back in their Baltimore classrooms early each Monday.

"By the time you got to New York, you were worn out," remembers Lena Lee, "and of course we couldn't ride the Pullmans. This great country actually tolerated that."

But Lee, like so many others who studied out-of-state because their flagship university was strictly segregated, refuses to harbor bitterness. "You would be stupid to stay angry, especially if you've lived as long as I have," she says.

Betty Williams, 80, was Lee's pupil in the fourth grade. After she graduated from Morgan in 1944, Williams received a Maryland scholarship to study English at Columbia University.

"I had a desk in the stacks and wrote a thesis on Alfred Lord Tennyson," Williams remembers. "I had no unpleasant experiences, but the work was hard. In one of my classes there were 500 students, and I was the only black."

The lure of teaching brought Williams back to Baltimore, where she worked 39 years in the city system, becoming principal of the prestigious Eastern High School. Of the four-decade period in which African-Americans were barred from University of Maryland graduate schools, Williams says, "I have no bitterness. It was all so stupid."

Gloria Carrington, 82, took classes at NYU during the summer, staying with an aunt in a Harlem apartment. "The classes were huge and mostly white," Carrington remembers.

Carrington eventually became the first black social worker at Margaret Brent Elementary in what is now Charles Village. At year's end, her principal told her she could not attend the faculty party at a segregated restaurant.

"That was tough," says Carrington.

Two city superintendents, John L. Crew Sr. and Alice G. Pinderhughes, received out-of-state scholarships, though Pinderhughes never earned her degree. Rebecca Carroll and Pearl C. Brackett, who earned teaching certificates together at Coppin in 1936, rose to the top ranks of city schools after earning their advanced degrees, Carroll at the University of Chicago (where she met her future husband, the late James Carroll) and Brackett at NYU. Pinderhughes, Carroll and Brackett have died in recent years.

Not everyone forgave and forgot. John S. Ward, 78, who was a ranking administrator in both Baltimore city and county school systems before his retirement, applied for one of the scholarships in the mid-1950s but was told the program was being phased out.

Years later, Ward earned a master's at the University of Maryland, "but it was not a pleasant experience."

"In fact," he says, "I never went back to the university after I graduated. ... Somehow the outrage of being rejected all those years burned deeply into me. They were so damn hurtful."

George H. Callcott, a University of Maryland historian, traces UM's resistance to the famed College Park president Harry Clifton "Curley" Byrd, who ran the university in the years after World War II.

"He thought of himself as a great liberal, promoting education for blacks," says Callcott. "But he wanted to keep them on the Eastern Shore, away from the College Park campus."

Another president, Martin D. Jenkins of historically black Morgan State, regularly twitted Byrd. African-Americans preferred such colleges as the University of Pennsylvania, Jenkins said publicly, "because they do not have a high regard for the quality of instruction in Maryland."

Lena Lee remembers "a lessening of tension" 50 years ago when the Brown decision came down. "There had been warning signs that times were going to change, and we had better get ready for it," she says.

Still, says Gibson, the UM law professor, "they didn't stop giving out scholarships until 1957, three years after Brown. That's how long it took to stop the steering."

Copyright © 2014, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Is artificial turf causing cancer?
    Is artificial turf causing cancer?

    Synthetic turf fields are made of a synthetic grasslike material, to which 40,000 ground-up rubber tires are added as "in-fill." It is the out-gassing of chemicals from these ground-up rubber tire "crumbs," as well as the rubber crumb dust, that pose the greatest health concern to the athletes.

  • Rent or buy?
    Rent or buy?

    My daughter is newly married, and my son is returning to Maryland with his young family after completing his military service.

  • High incarceration may be more harmful than high crime
    High incarceration may be more harmful than high crime

    Recent events show that black lives in Ferguson, Staten Island and beyond are insecure, burdened by the police surveillance and criminal justice involvement that are most heavily concentrated in neighborhoods of color.

  • As the ruble collapses, how dangerous is Russia?
    As the ruble collapses, how dangerous is Russia?

    Live by high oil prices, die by low oil prices.

  • Entrepreneurs have a role to play in solving our nation's problems
    Entrepreneurs have a role to play in solving our nation's problems

    Four years ago, Vinay Bhargava had an epiphany. The Google executive was giving a talk to students at Thomas Jefferson High School for Science and Technology in Virginia. The students, bright, tech-focused and driven, had no idea how the college admissions process worked, or where to begin.

  • Caret: a man with 'vision and charisma'
    Caret: a man with 'vision and charisma'

    There was a moment when I realized that Bob Caret just might be crazy. It was in 2005, during one of the periodic meetings I had with the then-Towson University president. He was laying out his vision for what he called a "metropolitan university." To Mr. Caret, schools like Towson should serve...

Comments
Loading