Try digitalPLUS for 10 days for only $0.99


News Opinion Op-Eds

Aronofsky's 'Noah' not your typical Bible flick [Commentary]

Until Film director Darren Aronofsky got his hands on it, the old tale of Noah's Ark had devolved into a cute children's fable of giraffes and elephants and bears and bunnies crowding onto a big boat. Aronofsky has re-envisioned it as what it really has always been: an apocalyptic, end-of-the-world disaster story. Biblical literalists, though, are not entirely happy about this new telling of one of the most ancient stories in the Judeo-Christian tradition.

Aronofsky's "Noah" opened Friday in theaters across America and the big question for Paramount, the studio that paid more than $130 million to produce the film, is whether the large Christian audience that showed up for Mel Gibson's "The Passion of the Christ" and the more recent "Son of God" will pay to see what Aronofsky has called "the least biblical film ever made."

If Glenn Beck has his way, no right thinking person will go see the movie. The eccentric conservative TV and radio commentator has told his followers, "I hope that 'Noah' is a massive failure." Without actually viewing the film, Beck has dismissed it as two hours of "dangerous disinformation" that portrays Noah as a drunk with an environmentalist agenda.

Other religious conservatives, however, have expressed a distinctly different opinion of the film. Among them is Jim Daly, president of Focus on the Family, who previewed "Noah" and gave credit to Aronofsky for telling a compelling story. "It is a creative interpretation of the scriptural account that allows us to imagine the deep struggles Noah may have wrestled with as he answered God's call on his life," Daly said.

On Wednesday night, I went to a screening at Paramount Studios in Hollywood to see "Noah" for myself. I followed it up by re-reading the story of Noah and the flood in Genesis. The contrasts between the two versions are stark.

The story in the Bible is brief -- not much longer than a pitch for a disaster movie -- and Noah doesn't have a word of dialogue until after the waters have receded and his sons find him drunk and naked in his hut. Aronofsky bulks up the sketchy tale, turning it into a cross between "Game of Thrones" and "Waiting for Godot," with some antediluvian "Transformers" thrown in as ark builders.

Arguably, God comes off better in the film than in the book. In the Bible, just 10 generations into his creation, the Big Guy is not happy with the sinful ways of human beings. He wants a re-do, so he drowns everybody but Noah and his family. Then, sounding a little regretful -- "Oops! My bad," sayeth the Lord -- God promises Noah he won't do it again, even though he knows Humanity 2.0 will be just as awful as the first version.

Aronofsky's movie keeps God off in the clouds and lays the heavy choices on Noah while graphically portraying the wickedness and violence of those early humans. You can see why they kind of had it coming. Besides their murderous ways, they were a bunch of polluters who didn't recycle and ate way too much red meat.

The richest part of the film version, though, is the way Aronofsky gives depth and dimension to Noah and his family and the existential issues they face. Yes, he takes great liberties with the details, but, for any Christians interested in something more intellectually rigorous than old fables, Aronofsky's "Noah" would be a great starting point for a Bible class discussion about justice, mercy, faith and obedience.

Paramount may have less trouble than expected attracting a Christian audience already intrigued by the second story in the Bible. The tougher sell might be to a general audience unaccustomed to having their disaster flicks served up with such a grim and challenging vision.

Two-time Pulitzer Prize winner David Horsey is a political commentator for the Los Angeles Times. Go to see more of his work.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • We're going to owe a lot to Caitlyn Jenner

    We're going to owe a lot to Caitlyn Jenner

    Caitlyn Jenner — who purposely did not spell her new name with a K — is going to absorb an unimaginable amount of attention for the rest of her life. Whatever is not emotionally draining is going to be bruising. I do not envy her, but we owe her our gratitude.

  • Hogan fails on forfeiture reform

    Last month, Gov. Larry Hogan vetoed a civil asset forfeiture reform bill that had been passed nearly unanimously by the State Senate. Senate Bill 528 would have closed the "equitable sharing" loophole that perversely incentivizes Maryland's law enforcement agencies to circumvent state forfeiture...

  • The Common Core can't speed up child development

    The Common Core can't speed up child development

    Recent evaluations of the state's preschoolers have determined that only 47 percent are ready for kindergarten, compared to 83 percent judged ready last year. This drastic drop isn't the result of an abrupt, catastrophic decline in the cognitive abilities of our children. Instead it results from...

  • The mixed blessing of Bill Clinton

    The mixed blessing of Bill Clinton

    In Bill Clinton's 1992 election victory, he talked of voters getting "two for the price of one," referring to his wife, Hillary, as a brainy political activist who would bring an added bonus to his presidency. By and large it worked, as her popularity soared, especially among Democratic women.

  • Expanding autism program could help thousands in Maryland

    Expanding autism program could help thousands in Maryland

    In my work with children on the autism spectrum, I have witnessed and been deeply touched by the sacrifices that families make and the struggles they face to obtain necessary services for their children. Their journey to ensure their children have the best lives possible is often frustrating, isolating...

  • Worried about a Craigslist transaction? Head to Annapolis

    Worried about a Craigslist transaction? Head to Annapolis

    Craigslist transactions have taken on a sinister context with reports of people being robbed — and even murdered — during face-to-face transactions.