Summer Sale Extended! Get unlimited digital access for 13 weeks for $13.
News Opinion Editorial

Keep them in class [Editorial]

It's heartening that Baltimore City's new schools CEO, Gregory Thornton, has made limiting the number of out-of-school suspensions for the system's youngest children a priority in his first weeks on the job. In doing so he has sent a strong signal to principals and teachers that they need to find alternative methods for disciplining troublesome or disruptive students and that kicking kids out of school is rarely effective and should only be used as a punishment of last resort.

This week, Mr. Thornton told school board members that from now on principals will be required to consult with the central office before suspending pre-kindergarten and kindergarten students. Last year Baltimore schools suspended more 4- and 5-year-olds than any other jurisdiction in the state, a practice many educators believe is too extreme for such young children and may be counterproductive as well.

That's because one of the goals of early education is to teach children the basic social skills they'll need to function in a classroom setting. But they can't learn those skills if they're not in school, and their absence is likely to set them up for more serious problems in later grades. In nearly all cases it's preferable to keep them in school where educators can continue to engage them than to simply send them home — particularly since dysfunction at home may well be the root of the misbehavior in the first place.

Realistically, there's very little that 4- and 5-year-olds can do that poses a genuine threat to the safety of their teachers or classmates. Mr. Thornton acknowledged that students who bring weapons to school are an exception and should be dealt with accordingly, but very few pre-kindergarten and kindergarten students fall into that category. In all other cases, Mr. Thornton says, it's the responsibility of principals and teachers to find out what's causing the unwanted behavior and address those problems rather than suspend the student.

That's in line with a broader Maryland Department of Education policy to encourage school districts across the state to reduce the use of out-of-school suspensions as a means of disciplining children. Students who are suspended not only are more likely to continue having difficulty adjusting when they return, they are also more likely to fall behind in their classes, have to repeat a grade, drop out of school altogether or get into trouble with the law.

The state board of education is also rightly concerned by the demographic disparities in out-of-school suspension policies, which disproportionately affect low-income, minority and special education students. Black and Latino children are suspended at far higher rates than their middle-class white peers, and the difference is reflected in the academic achievement gap along racial and class lines. Reducing such disparities is crucial to raising achievement levels for all Maryland students, and it needs to start in the earliest grades.

Nothing in what Mr. Thornton is proposing would force teachers to suffer indefinitely under unsafe or extremely disruptive conditions, or for other children to be held captive to a troubled student who monopolizes the teacher's attention. There are a range of other ways educators can deal with unruly children, including in-school suspension, after-school detention or out-of-school classes that children are still required to attend. Mr. Thornton needs to ensure that the district is providing teachers with the kind of support they need to take advantage of such alternatives. But the general rule should be that in all but the most egregious cases sending very young children home because of a behavioral problem is inappropriate.

By issuing this new policy directive at the very beginning of his tenure, Mr. Thornton has shown that he understands how much is at stake for Baltimore's children and that he is committed to building on the reforms put in place by former schools CEO Andrés Alonso. In his effort to boost student achievement levels, Mr. Alonso made it a priority to keep as many children as possible in school, where educators can continue to work with them. That policy is reflected in the significant gains city students made in recent years. Mr. Thornton's decision to focus now on the school system's youngest children is a logical extension of that strategy, and it will benefit them throughout their school careers.

To respond to this editorial, send an email to Please include your name and contact information.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Why schools matter

    Why schools matter

    When will we realize that Baltimore only can move forward when we support our schools and communities ("Langston Hughes community to fight school closure before a judge," May 17)?

  • SEED School achieves excellence

    SEED School achieves excellence

    Congratulations to the students, teachers and parents of the graduating class of New Town and Dulaney high schools for the achievement of 100 percent acceptance to college ("Newtown, Dulaney had 100 percent college acceptance rate," June 29).

  • Sauls was a great school board chair

    Sauls was a great school board chair

    As a former city school board student member, I developed great relationships with several school board members and the board chair. I would like to join others to express my appreciation to Shanaysha Sauls for her outstanding service to our city school system ("New leadership appointments for...

  • Schools need resources, not reform

    Schools need resources, not reform

    There are so many assumptions embedded within Donald Manekin's recent commentary that I find problematic that I'm not sure where to even begin ("Reinventing Baltimore's schools," June 29).

  • Free college?

    Free college?

    Baltimore officials are considering applying to a program that would cover the tuition expenses for any city graduate attending one of Maryland's public colleges and universities. The program promises a free college education to every city student who finishes high school, no strings attached....

  • Pay for college with military cuts

    Pay for college with military cuts

    As a long-time antiwar protester, I was stunned to read "City applying to program that would promise college scholarships for all students" (July 15). This is a remarkable idea which must be supported. But how will this idea be funded?

  • There are better ways to help Baltimore than free college tuition

    There are better ways to help Baltimore than free college tuition

    I reacted with dismay to the proposal to offer full college tuition scholarships for all Baltimore high school graduates ("City applying to program that would promise college scholarships for all students," July 15).

  • Free college won't create jobs

    Free college won't create jobs

    Most Americans understand that nothing is free, so why is it that politicians and some government employees do not understand this? They want free college, free lunches, free medical care ("Free college?" July 17).