Get unlimited digital access to $0.99 for 4 weeks.
News Opinion Editorial

Maryland's redistricting road show

In 2001, when Gov. Parris N. Glendening appointed a five-member advisory commission on the redrawing of legislative and congressional district lines, some questioned whether the entire exercise — including a dozen public hearings — would all be for show. Some speculated at the time that it would not be the desires of the various communities about how they should be joined together in districts that would determine the final maps but, rather, cold political calculations made behind closed doors in the governor's office — calculations made to reward friends, punish enemies and, overall, get more Democrats into elected office.

It is a mark of progress, of sorts, that a decade later, nobody is asking questions like that. This time, there is virtually no doubt that the redistricting process is fundamentally political in nature and governed by self-interested politicians. They're not even particularly subtle about it. Rep. Steny Hoyer has made it known that he and his fellow Democrats will be producing their own proposal for congressional district maps (no commission required), and the talk in Annapolis is about making a play for adding a seventh Democrat to the state's eight-member House delegation — though not necessarily by going after freshman Rep. Andy Harris in the Eastern Shore-based 1st District. There is also talk of lumping more Democrats into Rep. Roscoe Bartlett's Western Maryland-based 6th District to make it competitive.

In some sense, this is an inside game with more consequence for politicians than voters. The worst excesses of an earlier era of redistricting are illegal — no longer can lines be drawn to minimize the representation of minorities in Congress or the State House — and voters, of course, remain free to behave differently from how the party strategists expect. The increasingly sophisticated use of computers to manage the drawing of congressional districts hasn't kept control of one or both chambers from changing repeatedly in recent years. And sometimes districts that are supposed to be a lock for one party become competitive, such as in Maryland's 1st in 2008.

But the effect of gerrymandering on our democracy is subtly corrosive. It feeds into cynicism that the system is rigged and contributes to a polarization of Congress and state legislatures that limits our ability to handle the major challenges the nation faces. Our response to the looming deadline on the federal debt limit, taxes, the economy, war and any number of other issues might be entirely different if our representatives were chosen in districts based on community interest rather than partisan interest.

Because of the date of Maryland's primary elections next year, the congressional district maps will get drawn first, likely during a special session of the legislature in the fall. They do need to be redrawn. An ideal district in Maryland would have 721,694 people, and with the exception of the 3rd, 4th and 8th districts, all of them are currently far from the mark. The 7th District, represented by Democrat Elijah Cummings, is nearly 62,000 people below the magic number, and the 5th District, represented by Mr. Hoyer, who is the second-ranking Democrat in the House, is too large by more than 45,000 people. Reps. Andy Harris in the 1st and Roscoe Bartlett in the 6th both need to shed thousands of voters, and Rep. C.A. Dutch Ruppersberger in the 2nd needs to pick up about 21,000 more.

How that will happen is through a complex negotiation between Democratic incumbents, who want to maximize the safety of their own districts, and party leaders, who may try to take some reliably Democratic precincts away from them to boost the chances of some challenger against one of the state's Republicans. In the last redrawing of the maps, that was accomplished by peeling voters away from incumbent Democrats throughout the Baltimore region and lumping them into then-Rep. Robert L. Ehrlich Jr.'s district to create an opportunity for Mr. Ruppersberger, who was then term limited as Baltimore County executive. (For good measure, the map drawers had the 1st District snake around from the Eastern Shore to grab Mr. Ehrlich's townhouse in Mays Chapel.)

Community interest appeared to have little to do with it; after all, it is hard to imagine that someone in Randallstown stood up at a public hearing and suggested connecting her community with Cockeysville, northeastern Baltimore City, Aberdeen Proving Ground, Dundalk, Cherry Hill, and Fort Meade and the National Security Administration in a district shaped like the claw of a crab, after it has been pounded a few times with a mallet.

It would be nice to think that a neutral third party could be found to handle this task, but the track record there isn't perfect either. After Mr. Glendening's legislative district maps were thrown out by the Court of Appeals in 2002, the judges drew a map of their own. While an improvement on the governor's proposal in a number of respects, the court's map contained its own logical peculiarities. The justices decided, for example, that it's OK for legislative district lines to cross jurisdictional boundaries everywhere in the state except for Baltimore City.

But even if there is no ideal way to draw district maps, Maryland's system could stand for improvement. Allowing the governor to appoint all members of the advisory committee, and allowing the governor to modify that committee's plan (or scrap it entirely) before submitting a map to the General Assembly for approval, concentrates too much power in one person's hands. Changing that would require an amendment to the state constitution, and under the current balance of power in Annapolis, there is virtually no chance that will happen. All voters can do is raise a ruckus, at the public hearings and at the ballot box, and hope that one day elected officials will put the people's interest above their own.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • National political groups bypass Maryland
    National political groups bypass Maryland

    Third-party groups wait for results of redistricting

  • A matter of trust
    A matter of trust

    At an emotional meeting this week, members of the Baltimore City Board of School Commissioners found themselves struggling to explain their recent initiative to allow the city's School Police Force, which is separate from the Baltimore City Police Department, to carry weapons inside school...

  • How to reduce drunk driving
    How to reduce drunk driving

    People who have never been tested on a Breathalyzer are often surprised by just how intoxicated a person has to be to register a blood alcohol concentration of .08. It is enough to slur speech, impair vision, and dangerously alter perception and reaction time. You are, in a word, drunk and...

  • Retirement insecurity
    Retirement insecurity

    The "silver tsunami" predicted for Maryland, where more than 1 million workers have no retirement savings, is one that will sweep the rest of the country, too. As a matter of fact, the Employee Benefit Research Institute says the percentage of Marylanders with little or no savings is about...

  • Charter schools do not equal education reform
    Charter schools do not equal education reform

    As Philadelphia's Superintendent of Schools, I recommended the approval of more than 30 charter schools because I thought it would improve educational opportunity for our 215,000 students. The last 20 years make it clear I was wrong.

  • The U.S. has yet to make good on its promise of reparations to black Americans
    The U.S. has yet to make good on its promise of reparations to black Americans

    Conversations about reparations are not about money but about people and about the way that people are seen and valued in our society. These are difficult conversations, and we have found that what is most challenging about the idea of reparations today is the notion that America still owes a...

  • Hillary Clinton's identity crisis
    Hillary Clinton's identity crisis

    "Is Hillary Rodham Clinton a McDonald's Big Mac or a Chipotle burrito bowl? A can of Bud or a bottle of Blue Moon? JCPenney or J. Crew?"

  • Pre-booking diversion: an alternative to conviction and incarceration
    Pre-booking diversion: an alternative to conviction and incarceration

    In Baltimore City, approximately 20,000 people were arrested for drug-related offenses annually in 2012 and 2013; nearly three quarters for simple possession. And while there has been a great deal of discussion over the last few years regarding the incarceration of individuals for drug...