In Case You Missed It: Baltimore Marathon Photos
NewsOpinionEditorial

Yes on Questions 1 and 2

Laws and LegislationJustice SystemElectionsIllegal ImmigrantsPetroleum Industry

The general public has never been especially fond of lawyers or judges. When Gallup polls Americans asking what professions they view favorably and which they view negatively, the lawyers get a thumbs down every time — although, on the bright side, the federal government and the oil industry are rated considerably worse.

Nevertheless, as the old saying goes, you can hate lawyers until you need one. That's when they become invaluable in allowing a family to adopt a child or prevent an innocent person from being convicted of a crime or in upholding terms of a business contract.

That's something voters need to keep in mind when they go to the polls in November. Of the seven statewide questions on the ballot, the first two — surely the least talked about of all the referendums and potentially lost in all the heated debate over gambling, marriage and college tuition rates for illegal immigrants — has to do with requiring Orphans' Court judges in Baltimore and Prince George's counties to be lawyers.

A lot of Maryland residents probably aren't familiar with the Orphans' Court, the three-judge probate court in each county where disputes over wills and estates are handled. It's an arrangement spelled out in the state's constitution and dates back to Maryland's founding, a time when estate settlements were far simpler than today. It even draws its name from old England of centuries ago, specifically from London's Court for Widows and Orphans.

As appealing as it may sound to have a layman handle family disputes — after all, King Solomon was no member of the Maryland bar — it's not a good policy for complex legalities where such arcane matters as the rules of evidence and civil procedures can be critical. Two years ago, we endorsed (and voters subsequently approved) a similar law to require Baltimore City Orphans' Court judges to be lawyers, and for good reason — the city court is the busiest in the state.

Baltimore and Prince George's counties' courts are not far behind in terms of caseload. The requirement that Orphans' Court judges be lawyers probably ought to be imposed statewide rather than piecemeal, county by county, but the smaller rural counties where the courts are not so busy as their counterparts in Central Maryland have long objected to the change. Thus, Questions 1 and 2 are the best remedy available.

Is there a drawback to barring non-lawyers from judgeships? We don't see one. Just as you wouldn't want someone to perform surgery, no matter of thoughtful and careful, if he or she was not properly educated in the field, there's no call to expect that from a court.

Make no mistake, a lot of Orphans' Court decisions are fairly routine. Judges may be evaluating assets or making sure distributions have been made correctly to heirs. But then District Court judges sometimes handle pretty routine matters of speeding tickets or a tenant failing to pay rent, too. That doesn't mean they don't require a law degree.

Unfortunately, sometimes estates are disputed, and that's when Orphans' Court judges must hold hearings, weigh evidence and interpret the law. Lawyers argue the cases. Large sums of money may be at stake. Surely, it's not too much to expect the judges who hear those cases to understand the law as well as the advocates who appear before them.

Under current law, lay judges must have their rulings reviewed and co-signed by a fellow judge who is a lawyer. That's not a requirement imposed on judges with law degrees. So requiring all judges to be so qualified should also allow the courts to operate more efficiently.

Maryland voters are likely to endorse the measure. They approved the city requirement in 2010 by a greater than four-to-one margin. Still, when there's anything involving lawyers, it's wise to remind the public that they have their uses. As Charles Dickens once observed, if there were no bad people, there would be no good lawyers. Probate is just one of those places where good lawyers are required.

Copyright © 2014, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
Laws and LegislationJustice SystemElectionsIllegal ImmigrantsPetroleum Industry
  • The change we should be making to the Orphans Court

    The year is 2012. Isn't it about time the state of Maryland came up with some name a bit more 21st century than "Orphan's Court"? What a hillbilly name for a court in a supposedly up to date state!

  • The risk Ebola exposed [Editorial]
    The risk Ebola exposed [Editorial]

    The Centers for Disease Control is urging people not to panic over the pair of nurses who tested positive for Ebola at the hospital in Dallas where an infected man was treated last month. Yet polls show the public isn't buying it — a recent survey found nearly 80 percent of...

  • County farm stand [Editorial]
    County farm stand [Editorial]

    Fall is a big time of year for agricultural tourism, from hay rides to apple picking, pumpkin carving and corn mazes. Increasingly, farmers are exploring ways to supplement their income and assure their financial viability, which is particularly important in a state like Maryland where...

  • Police in campaign ads [Poll]
    Police in campaign ads [Poll]
  • Frozen eggs and a woman's career [Commentary]
    Frozen eggs and a woman's career [Commentary]

    News that Apple would begin in January to pay for women employees to have their eggs frozen so they could delay motherhood — and that Facebook had already begun doing it — has jumpstarted the discussion of women and work/life balance.

  • Ebola is no Spanish Flu [Commentary]
    Ebola is no Spanish Flu [Commentary]

    The recent death of Thomas Eric Duncan, the 42-year-old who traveled to Dallas from disease-ravaged Liberia while infected with the Ebola virus, along with the confirmed infection of two of Duncan's nurses, has created widespread concern that an epidemic is imminent in the United States.

  • College: You get out what you put in [Commentary]
    College: You get out what you put in [Commentary]

    I've read the tweets, the blogs and the experts. Yes, yes, I understand that a college degree doesn't guarantee a post-college career. But don't tell this to my peers. Far too often I hear them talk about how they enrolled in college because they need a degree to get a job. While...

  • Smart is not a dirty word [Commentary]
    Smart is not a dirty word [Commentary]

    As the school year hits its stride, many parents and teachers of K-12 students feel overburdened with all-too-familiar concerns about failing schools, common core standards and teaching to the test. Now experts are adding one more thing to worry about: grit.

Comments
Loading