Summer Sale! Get unlimited digital access for 13 weeks for $13.
News Opinion Editorial

Time for 'Occupy' to grow up

New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg and his counterparts in several other cities may have done the protesters of the "Occupy" movement the biggest possible favor by kicking them out of the parks where they have erected tent cities for the last several weeks. Many protesters in New York; Oakland, Calif.; Portland, Ore. and other cities where the encampments have been dispersed are vowing to keep their round-the-clock protest going despite police orders, but that would be a mistake. They should take this opportunity to start a new, more pointed phase of their movement.

Polls show large majorities of Americans agree with the protesters' complaints that income inequality has grown to dangerous levels in this country and that corporations and Wall Street have grown too powerful and hold too much sway over our elected leaders. But the problem is that the only clearly articulated and fervently pursued goal of the occupiers is the right to camp in public, and that their most organized efforts have gone into securing tents, warm socks and peanut butter, not social and economic justice.

Baltimore has its own "Occupy" protest at McKeldin Square in the Inner Harbor, and it has, fortunately, not seen the kind of problems that have led mayors in other cities to clear the encampments. There have not been reports of violence, and the protest there is not so large as the recently dispersed encampment in Manhattan's Zuccotti Park, which fostered unsanitary conditions.

Still, Baltimore officials have experienced the same frustration in dealing with the protesters as Mayor Bloomberg's office reportedly did. The movement is so rigidly un-hierarchical that it refuses to acknowledge that anyone could negotiate the terms of its encampment on its behalf. That has led to a frustration on the part of officials here and elsewhere who are sympathetic to the protesters' message but at a loss for how to accommodate them in an orderly way, and it has meant that a great deal of the protesters' time and energy has gone into advocating for a right to 24/7 occupation of public parks and squares, as opposed to restoring a level playing field for Americans.

It's time for the "Occupy" protests to grow up. Even the Canadian magazine Adbusters, which helped spark the movement, has suggested that the protesters consider changing gears and "use the winter to brainstorm, network, build momentum so that we may emerge rejuvenated with fresh tactics, philosophies, and a myriad projects ready to rumble next spring." What that means is that the movement needs to start rallying around specific remedies to the problems it has identified, and it needs to directly engage in the political process.

Perhaps it could fight for a restoration of the Glass-Steagall Act, which prevented banks from also acting as investment houses and insurance companies but was partially repealed during the Clinton administration. It could advocate for the so-called "Buffett rule," which would eliminate a loophole that allows those whose income is primarily derived from investment gains (like its namesake, Warren Buffett) to be taxed at far lower rates than middle-income Americans. It could push for the end of tax breaks for oil companies. It could fight against the reauthorization of the Bush tax cuts for the wealthy, or for stricter campaign finance disclosure to mitigate the corrosive impact of the influx of corporate money into politics that was facilitated by the Supreme Court's recent Citizens United decision.

But whatever the direction the protest takes, it needs to prove that it's something more than a toddler sitting on the floor in a sulk because it doesn't want to go to bed. Occupy protesters, you have our attention. Now do something with it.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Occupy detractors must feel threatened

    Columnist Robert L. Ehrlich Jr. has certainly written quite a flamboyant article regarding the Occupy movement ("Occupy movement got America wrong," Sept. 23). In it, he states a disconnect between them and the so-called "middle class," a catch-all term he uses to project his own identity. Most...

  • The importance of Occupy

    The Occupy Wall Street movement was created to make people aware of issues that aren't usually discussed in the mainstream corporate media: the greed of the powerful, the destruction of the environment, violence against women and gays and the perpetual war waged for oil and other resources, with...

  • Ehrlich carries 1 percent's water

    In his recent column ("'Occupy movement got America wrong," Sept. 23), Robert L. Ehrlich Jr. illustrates the denial of economic reality in America that is continually propagated by the 1 percent. At the heart of his argument is the idea that the American Dream is alive and well, the happy meritocracy...

  • 'Occupy' is gone? We'll see in November

    Robert L. Ehrlich Jr.'s column about the first anniversary of the Occupy movement betrays a hubris, a willful stupidity, and the usual threadbare deceptions ("Occupy movement got America wrong," Sept. 23). Such are the building blocks of the corrupt edifice that Occupy seeks to dismantle.

  • Occupy movement got it right

    Former Gov. Robert L. Ehrlich Jr.'s column on the Occupy movement summed up the us vs. them Republican party platform (Occupy movement got America wrong," Sept. 23).

  • Conservatives see media bias no matter the facts

    The usual whining from the extreme right about media bias is evident in a recent letter from Stephen Sewell ("Sun lavishes attention on 'Occupy,' ignores tea party," Sept. 24). The writer is long on allegations and short on facts.

  • Sun lavishes attention on bumbling 'Occupy,' ignores effective tea party

    Let me get this straight: a spontaneous movement arises and takes up the name "Tea Party" based on historical actions and the acronym "taxed enough already," amasses a very large number of either followers or sympathizers, and literally reverses the party breakdown in the U.S. House of Representatives...

  • Occupy Baltimore: a historical footnote

    It's sad to see a good idea fizzle, and that's what's happened to Occupy Baltimore ("The 1 percent are winning," Sept. 18). But, the movement didn't just "fizzle," it committed suicide.