Get unlimited digital access to baltimoresun.com. $0.99 for 4 weeks.
News Opinion Editorial

Closing Northwestern High

It's understandable that Northwestern High School alumni are dismayed by the Baltimore City school board's decision to close the school in 2016. Northwestern was once a venerable neighborhood institution, several of whose graduates went on to become leaders in the community.

But in recent decades the school has been plagued by problems common to many of the city's troubled public high schools, including poor test scores, low graduation rates, disciplinary issues and an aging physical plant that no longer supports learning commensurate with today's higher standards. Northwestern now lags the citywide averages in dropout rates, pass rates on High School Assessment tests and the percentage of students who go on to college, among other measures. The lawsuit a group of alumni filed last week seeking to block its closure is unlikely to change that or to benefit the students currently enrolled there.

School closures are almost always traumatic events in the life of their communities. Despite its storied history, Northwestern is one of 26 schools across the city slated to be shuttered as part of the school board's ambitious 10-year, $2.4 billion plan to renovate or rebuild 136 dilapidated school buildings. That plan has won the support of thousands of city residents who rallied in Annapolis this week to demand lawmakers approve a long-term state funding commitment to the school system's capital improvement program, despite the fact that the alumni's lawsuit threatens to throw a monkey wrench into the works.

We think the board made the right policy decision in regard to school closings, even though it means some neighborhoods inevitably will lose institutions with long traditions of service. Consolidating operations in fewer buildings will allow the school system to use limited construction funding more cost-effectively and make more efficient use of underutilized space. Ultimately, that will benefit all the city's schoolchildren.

The Northwestern alumni claim the plan to close their alma mater is racially discriminatory because it would disproportionately affect low-income, minority students. But that argument could be made for virtually every school in Baltimore, a city where the overwhelming majority of public school students fit that description. If one were to accept the alumni's reasoning, almost no school anywhere in the city could ever be closed for any reason.

Clearly that was not the intention behind the federal civil rights laws the alumni are counting on to bolster their case. Nor have the plaintiffs offered any evidence of illegal discriminatory intent on the part of the school board in deciding to close some schools and not others. And given the overall demographics of the city's public school population, it's hard to see how the board's decision to close Northwestern could be viewed as even unintentional discrimination.

The school board's mission is not to preserve the legacy of its schools or even to maintain them as community anchors. It is to provide a free and adequate public education to Baltimore's children today and in the future. The school board had to make some extremely tough choices regarding the most practical way to rebuild or replace dozens of some of the oldest school buildings in the state within a reasonable time frame, and that's what it did.

The question Northwestern's alumni should be asking is not whether the school board is intentionally or unintentionally discriminating against low-income, minority students but whether the schools they now attend are adequately preparing them for post-high school success in college and the work world.

Do the schools house modern, well-lighted classrooms, libraries and athletic facilities, state-of-the-art science labs and computer centers? And can schools that lack such amenities be brought up to standard for any reasonable cost in money and time? Far from being luxuries, these are basic tools for learning in the 21st century.

The board made a judgment that the wisest course was to close Northwestern and transfer its students to Forest Park High School, which is slated for extensive renovation and is currently underutilized. That was the right call. One can certainly empathize with the loss Northwestern's alumni feel. But their emotional attachment to a building that, despite many fond memories, can no longer fulfill its educational mission is no reason to deny today's students the opportunity to learn in a more modern facility that is better equipped to meet their needs.

  • Text NEWS to 70701 to get Baltimore Sun local news text alerts
  • Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
    Related Content
    • How to reduce drunk driving
      How to reduce drunk driving

      People who have never been tested on a Breathalyzer are often surprised by just how intoxicated a person has to be to register a blood alcohol concentration of .08. It is enough to slur speech, impair vision, and dangerously alter perception and reaction time. You are, in a word, drunk and...

    • Retirement insecurity
      Retirement insecurity

      The "silver tsunami" predicted for Maryland, where more than 1 million workers have no retirement savings, is one that will sweep the rest of the country, too. As a matter of fact, the Employee Benefit Research Institute says the percentage of Marylanders with little or no savings is about...

    • Charter schools do not equal education reform
      Charter schools do not equal education reform

      As Philadelphia's Superintendent of Schools, I recommended the approval of more than 30 charter schools because I thought it would improve educational opportunity for our 215,000 students. The last 20 years make it clear I was wrong.

    • The U.S. has yet to make good on its promise of reparations to black Americans
      The U.S. has yet to make good on its promise of reparations to black Americans

      Conversations about reparations are not about money but about people and about the way that people are seen and valued in our society. These are difficult conversations, and we have found that what is most challenging about the idea of reparations today is the notion that America still owes a...

    • Hillary Clinton's identity crisis
      Hillary Clinton's identity crisis

      "Is Hillary Rodham Clinton a McDonald's Big Mac or a Chipotle burrito bowl? A can of Bud or a bottle of Blue Moon? JCPenney or J. Crew?"

    • Pre-booking diversion: an alternative to conviction and incarceration
      Pre-booking diversion: an alternative to conviction and incarceration

      In Baltimore City, approximately 20,000 people were arrested for drug-related offenses annually in 2012 and 2013; nearly three quarters for simple possession. And while there has been a great deal of discussion over the last few years regarding the incarceration of individuals for drug...

    Comments
    Loading