Get unlimited digital access to baltimoresun.com. $0.99 for 4 weeks.
News Opinion Editorial

Dick Lugar's warning for America

The hit men of the tea party can carve another notch in their collective gun belts this week with the ouster of Indiana Sen. Richard G. Lugar, a 35-year veteran of the U.S. Senate. Whatever mojo the conservative firebrands had in the 2010 GOP primaries, when they ousted party moderates right and left, is apparently still working for them.

Longtime incumbents are not easily toppled, but Mr. Lugar's vulnerabilities were well-documented prior to Tuesday's Indiana primary: The six-term senator is 80 years old, has lived in Northern Virginia for decades (despite using a 1970s-era address for voting purposes) and seemed to voters far more interested in foreign policy than in the daily concerns of the folks back home.

Nor did it help that Mr. Lugar, ever the Midwestern gentleman, didn't go after his opponent, state Treasurer Richard E. Mourdock, with the same vigor the challenger demonstrated against him. Conservative groups spent millions of dollars to support Mr. Mourdock, who expresses a clear preference for confrontation over compromise with Democrats.

So while Mr. Lugar is an imperfect poster child for the death of Republican moderation, his defeat still echoes the sad reality of U.S. politics in the second decade of the 21st century: The gulf between Republican and Democrat, conservative and moderate (let alone progressive) has never been greater in living memory.

What was Mr. Lugar's crime that sparked such disdain? It was those occasional moments when he showed a willingness to find common ground with the other party. Even his votes in support of President Barack Obama's Supreme Court nominees were treated as treasonous. In contrast, Mr. Mourdock claims the only way forward is for the GOP to seize total control and never give ground to the other party. He is best remembered beyond Indiana's borders for vigorously opposing President Obama's auto industry bailout, despite the thousands of jobs it saved in his state.

In conceding defeat, Mr. Lugar urged Mr. Mourdock, if ultimately elected to the Senate, to reconsider his promise of bringing even greater partisanship to Congress. "He and I share many positions, but his embrace of an unrelenting partisan mindset is irreconcilable with my philosophy of governance and my experience of what brings results for Hoosiers in the Senate."

Indiana, which advertises itself as the "Crossroads of America," may now reflect a political crossroads, of sorts, in a hopelessly divided country. Mr. Lugar is not the only pragmatic Hoosier to struggle with the polarization that has descended on the nation's political scene.

Two years ago, Sen. Evan Bayh, a two-term Democratic moderate and former governor, announced he would not run for re-election because of the "brain-dead partisanship" that had infected Congress. His seat is now occupied by Sen. Dan Coats who, in an earlier term in the Senate, once questioned the timing of President Bill Clinton's attack on terrorist bases in Afghanistan and Sudan in 1998 as potentially linked to the Monica Lewinsky scandal.

Mr. Lugar's departure is not just some changing of the guard or passing of an old lion of the Senate, but one more straw on the camel's back of sensible decision-making. The Senate, in particular, needs members of both parties to work together given that it's highly unlikely either party will muster a 60-vote, filibuster-proof majority next term.

Yet it will have to accomplish this without the handful of centrists who will be leaving after the November elections, including Democrat Jim Webb of Virginia and RepublicanOlympia J. Snowe of Maine. Any hope for a do-something Congress would seem slight, at best, no matter whom we elect president.

To paraphrase Mr. Lugar, voters may hate the policies of one party or the other, but they hate even more when Congress is unable to make decisions. Perhaps the next Congress will rise to the challenge when push comes to shove and inaction gives rise to genuine crises. But it's far more likely that the insights of a six-term senator will have fallen on deaf ears, and the next term will bring more of the same partisan paralysis.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • The tea party's war on common sense
    The tea party's war on common sense

    Defeat of Dick Lugar robs the nation of what it needs most -- a reasonable man

  • Street policing doesn't belong in school
    Street policing doesn't belong in school

    In recent months, there has been a flood of video evidence of police violence in our communities. Earlier this week, a gut-wrenching video surfaced that shows a school police officer violently attacking three young girls inside one of our middle schools. The incident starts when one of the...

  • Look to animals to cure Ebola
    Look to animals to cure Ebola

    GlaxoSmithKline and Merck will test new Ebola vaccines in West Africa this month. They're racing to cure this disease that causes severe hemorrhagic fever in humans and other mammals. To date, Ebola has claimed more than 8,600 lives and infected more than 20,000 people in Sierra Leone,...

  • Why Black History Month?
    Why Black History Month?

    Every February, college professors like myself are tasked with reminding students and the general public of the significance of Black History Month. Undoubtedly, many people understand the potential value behind a designated month dedicated to this part of American history. Our country is...

  • Lexington Market overhaul [Poll]
    Lexington Market overhaul [Poll]
  • Mr. Obama's 529 brouhaha
    Mr. Obama's 529 brouhaha

    Rarely does a president flip-flop on an initiative presented in the State of the Union address as quickly as Barack Obama did this week. He reversed himself on 529 college savings plans on Tuesday, which was just seven days after his speech to the nation. Such a political miscalculation is...

  • Defeating Boko Haram
    Defeating Boko Haram

    The bloody attacks in Paris this month that left 20 people dead, including the three attackers, riveted the world's attention on the growing threat Islamist extremist groups pose to the democracies of Western Europe. Yet even as the French people were mourning their loss, an even more...

  • Another snow job
    Another snow job

    The network meteorologists barely had time to come up for air while "forecasting" the latest snowstorm non-disaster. Politicians, fearing what might happen to their approval numbers if a blizzard hit, went on TV to announce they were taking proactive measures. New York City Mayor Bill...

Comments
Loading