Get unlimited digital access to baltimoresun.com. $0.99 for 4 weeks.
News Opinion Editorial

Shalit release: A flawed deal between sworn enemies

Both Israel and Hamas are claiming victory in the prisoner swap that will free more than 1,000 Palestinian prisoners from Israeli jails in exchange for Sgt. First Class Gilad Shalit, an Israeli soldier kidnapped by militants five years ago and held captive ever since. But don't mistake that for anything that might advance the peace process. If anything it may foretell more violence.

This deal, in which about half the Palestinians and Mr. Shalit were released Tuesday, wasn't conceived as a confidence-building move that was part of some larger, strategic vision to coax the two sides toward reconciliation. Instead, it was a short-term political fix calculated to shore up support among the hardest of hard-liners in both camps.

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu was willing to break with Israel's oft-stated policy of refusing to negotiate with terrorists only because he needs the political boost from fulfilling a campaign pledge, and because it was apparent that the overthrow of autocratic leaders in the Arab world was making it unlikely he could get a better deal for Mr. Shalit's release.

But whatever short-term advantage Mr. Netanyahu gains from bringing Sergeant Shalit home comes at a steep price. By striking a deal with Hamas, he implicitly undermined the credibility of his only viable negotiating partner, Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas, whose government in the

West Bank offers the only realistic alternative to Hamas. At the same time, he remains boxed in by the extreme right wing of his governing coalition, which would likely collapse were he to make any serious move toward reopening peace talks with Mr. Abbas.

Mr. Netanyahu vehemently opposes Mr. Abbas' current campaign to short-circuit a negotiated peace through U.N. recognition of Palestine as an independent state — and rightly so. But the Palestinian Authority is a far better prospect as a peace partner than Hamas, which remains committed to Israel's destruction. Hamas members are already saying they want to take more hostages to trade for the thousands of militants still held by Israel. That should hardly make Israelis feel safer.

Hamas, whose harsh rule in Gaza has caused its popularity to plummet, is just as interested in undermining Mr. Abbas as Mr. Netanyahu is. Faced with the potential loss of its headquarters in Damascus as a result of the popular uprising against Syrian dictator Bashar al-Assad, and fearing declining support from Iran, the group is eager to enhance its stature with the new government in Egypt, as well as with Turkey and other regional players. By securing a deal that included the release of hundreds of militants aligned with Mr. Abbas' Fatah faction as well as its own fighters, Hamas strengthened its claim to represent all Palestinians, not just those in Gaza.

Thus, while the release of Gilad Shalit may be cause for celebration by his family and many others who followed his case, it hardly bodes well for the cause of peace. The product of a flawed deal between sworn enemies who have no intention of reconciling, it provides a momentary boost for Mr. Netanyahu and possibly a much more lasting benefit for Hamas, but at the price of raising the risk of more hostage-taking and violence. Most of all, it displays the tragic failure of leadership in a region that desperately needs it if the prospect for a negotiated settlement between Israel and the Palestinians is ever to become a reality.

It is unconscionable that an innocent young man like Sergeant Shalit should be made to suffer as a pawn in the conflict between Israel and the Palestinians. He emerged from captivity with a message of hope that his release could be a catalyst for peace in the region. But unless Messrs. Netanyahu and Abbas take the opportunity to return to the bargaining table, it may only make matters worse.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Israel paid a steep price for Sgt. Shalit's release

    The gaunt appearance of Israeli army Sgt. Gilad Shalit after five years illegal detention in Gaza without a single visit by the Red Cross or other international humanitarian organization threw into sharp contrast the full faces and healthy physiques of the Palestinian murderers released from...

  • A matter of trust
    A matter of trust

    At an emotional meeting this week, members of the Baltimore City Board of School Commissioners found themselves struggling to explain their recent initiative to allow the city's School Police Force, which is separate from the Baltimore City Police Department, to carry weapons inside school...

  • How to reduce drunk driving
    How to reduce drunk driving

    People who have never been tested on a Breathalyzer are often surprised by just how intoxicated a person has to be to register a blood alcohol concentration of .08. It is enough to slur speech, impair vision, and dangerously alter perception and reaction time. You are, in a word, drunk and...

  • Retirement insecurity
    Retirement insecurity

    The "silver tsunami" predicted for Maryland, where more than 1 million workers have no retirement savings, is one that will sweep the rest of the country, too. As a matter of fact, the Employee Benefit Research Institute says the percentage of Marylanders with little or no savings is about...

  • Charter schools do not equal education reform
    Charter schools do not equal education reform

    As Philadelphia's Superintendent of Schools, I recommended the approval of more than 30 charter schools because I thought it would improve educational opportunity for our 215,000 students. The last 20 years make it clear I was wrong.

  • The U.S. has yet to make good on its promise of reparations to black Americans
    The U.S. has yet to make good on its promise of reparations to black Americans

    Conversations about reparations are not about money but about people and about the way that people are seen and valued in our society. These are difficult conversations, and we have found that what is most challenging about the idea of reparations today is the notion that America still owes a...

  • Hillary Clinton's identity crisis
    Hillary Clinton's identity crisis

    "Is Hillary Rodham Clinton a McDonald's Big Mac or a Chipotle burrito bowl? A can of Bud or a bottle of Blue Moon? JCPenney or J. Crew?"

  • Pre-booking diversion: an alternative to conviction and incarceration
    Pre-booking diversion: an alternative to conviction and incarceration

    In Baltimore City, approximately 20,000 people were arrested for drug-related offenses annually in 2012 and 2013; nearly three quarters for simple possession. And while there has been a great deal of discussion over the last few years regarding the incarceration of individuals for drug...

Comments
Loading