Summer Savings! Get unlimited digital access for 13 weeks for $13.


News Opinion Editorial

Tax policy on the fly

Disinclined as we may be to pity the plight of those making more than $500,000 a year, the state Senate, in its attempt to raise more revenue from such top earners, has gone too far. The Senate has adopted a plan that appears to be unique among the 50 states and would violate a cardinal rule of income tax policy, which is that a dollar earned should not cost more than a dollar in taxes. When the House of Delegates takes up the budget, it will have some work to do to clean this mess up.

Gov.Martin O'Malleyproposed what remains the most sensible plan for raising new revenue through the income tax. Rather than changing the rates, his plan was to phase out some exemptions and deductions for the top 20 percent of Maryland earners. That had the benefit of being progressive (the amount it cost any family increased with their income) and of simultaneously providing new revenue for local governments as partial compensation for their adoption of some of the costs of teacher pensions.

But Maryland Realtors engaged in a highly effective public relations campaign designed to convince the public that Mr. O'Malley was seeking to eliminate the mortgage interest deduction. He was, of course, doing no such thing; his plan would have limited the total value of deductions high-income families could claim on their state income taxes to either 90 percent or 80 percent of their value on a federal tax return. Mortgage interest is, of course, only part of most tax filers' deductions, and in any case, most of the value of those deductions is on the federal, not state, tax return. The Realtors' contention that Mr. O'Malley's proposal would make it harder to own a home in Maryland was a major exaggeration, but it succeeded in destroying any support for the plan in the legislature.

Instead, the Senate Budget and Taxation Committee adopted a plan that would have raised income tax rates for most Maryland families. Currently, most Marylanders fall into the 4.75 percent tax bracket, with higher earners paying more, up to 5.5 percent for income over $500,000 a year. The Senate's plan created new brackets starting at $25,000 and $50,000 a year, and generally increased rates for most groups by a quarter of a percentage point. We have concerns about whether that plan would raise more money than is necessary to meet the state's policy goals, but it would at least make the system more progressive, and it would ask relatively little of those at the bottom end of the income scale. A married couple with two kids and a federal adjusted gross income of $50,000 would wind up paying less than $1 more per week.

Where things went seriously off the rails was with a floor amendment adopted on Wednesday that would create a new super-bracket for those who make more than $500,000 a year. The original plan would have raised the rate for that bracket to 5.75 percent. But the amendment called for that rate to apply to a taxpayer's entire income, not just earnings above that amount.

The upshot is this: Earning one more dollar to push your income from $500,000 a year to $500,001 a year would cost an extra $2,482 in state income taxes, or $2,752 if you file jointly. That makes no sense, and it gives the impression that Maryland tax law is hashed out on the fly, with little thought to the consequences. That, more than the fiscal impact on people making a half-million dollars a year, makes this bad policy. It also may well be unique; officials at the National Conference of State Legislators, the Federation of Tax Administrators and the Tax Foundation were unable to think of any other state that has a bracket like this one. That's not the kind of distinction we need to have.

We believe it is necessary for whatever plan the legislature adopts to include some new revenues, and for those revenues to increase the overall progressivity of Maryland's tax system. We just hope the House will come up with a plan that is better thought out.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • The offal truth

    The offal truth

    On Friday afternoon, my neighbor reported a dead deer in front of his house to Baltimore County animal control. On Saturday night, the deer having not been picked up, I contacted them again. By Monday morning, the deer, being completely disgusting and mostly eaten by flies, vultures and foxes,...

  • No major tax rollbacks?

    No major tax rollbacks?

    Senate President Thomas V. Mike Miller told some reporters this week what most State House observers have long suspected — we should not expect some sweeping reduction in taxes during the upcoming legislative session. He also produced a spirited defense of the tax increases approved during Gov....

  • Tax breaks are divisive

    Tax breaks are divisive

    The commentary opposing the proposed tax breaks for corporate donations that help pay for private school tuition by Sara Love of the ACLU of Maryland strikes me as another example of how our new governor acts to ensure his re-election in four years by picking "winners" with his politically-motivated...

  • Rodricks is wrong: Md. tax system is progressive and fair

    Rodricks is wrong: Md. tax system is progressive and fair

    As usual Dan Rodricks gets it wrong. The Maryland tax structure is both progressive and fair ("Beyond race, building a movement for economic fairness," March 30). Let's look at two families A and B. Family A earns $60,000 and B $300,000. For 2014, excluding exemptions and deductions, A pays $2,800...

  • Md. can't keep robbing Peter to pay Paul

    Md. can't keep robbing Peter to pay Paul

    While I applaud the hard work on the state budget put in by House Appropriations Committee Chair Del. Maggie McIntosh and others, I am a little alarmed at their consistent kowtowing to the unions and their annual demands for increased funds despite reports of irresponsible spending.

  • Congress must create a level playing field for bricks-and-mortar businesses and online vendors

    Congress must create a level playing field for bricks-and-mortar businesses and online vendors

    During the next few weeks Congress will have the opportunity to pass e-fairness legislation, which will update our sales tax system and restore fairness to small businesses in our community.

  • Why isn't there enough money to sustain the governor's promised tax cuts?

    Why isn't there enough money to sustain the governor's promised tax cuts?

    Regarding your recent editorial criticizing Gov. Larry Hogan for submitting cuts in education funding, I am among the majority of Marylanders who favored Mr. Hogan in the last election because we supported his proposed budget cuts and call for fiscal responsibility and accountability ("Hogan, Busch...

  • Md. Democrats offer ruinous agenda

    Md. Democrats offer ruinous agenda

    I wonder where the rulers in the Maryland Senate and House of Delegates are going to get the money to fund what Senate President Thomas V. Mike Miller described as the Democratic agenda ("Senate panel rewrites Hogan's charter school law," March 26)? I guess they will do what they do every year...