Try digitalPLUS for 10 days for only $0.99


News Opinion Editorial

Banned in Bel Air

When a book flies off the shelves by the millions within a month of publication and zooms to the top of the New York Times best-seller list, it's safe to assume that whatever its literary merit (or lack thereof), it probably is not a good candidate for censorship. When a title is "hot," so to speak, everybody wants to read it.

For better or worse, that seems to be the case with British author E.L. James' "Fifty Shades of Grey," which reviewers describe as a steamy tale of kinky sex that makes the usual exemplars of the bodice-ripping romance genre seem tame by comparison. Local libraries around the country have been scrambling to keep up with demand after record numbers of readers requested the title (and its two sequels).

But sorry — if you live in Harford County, you're just out of luck. In deference to the delicate sensibilities of local residents, library officials there have refused to circulate a book they say is way too racy for their family-oriented clientele. Not only won't they buy the book for their readers, they won't even borrow a copy from other jurisdictions that have it. To patrons who request it, they politely suggest checking a copy out from the Sodom and Gomorrah that is the rest of Central Maryland.

This sort of prissy high-mindedness would be laughable if the issue weren't so serious, and not only because Harford County seems to be the only subdivision in the state to enforce such a ban. What it comes down to is an arbitrary exercise of government power to squelch ideas that someone in authority doesn't like.

Or put it this way: Public libraries absolutely have no business banning books simply because they don't approve of what's in them. The mere threat of such casual censorship is more dangerous than anything that might be contained between the covers of a novel, even a risque one.

What is truly strange is the capriciousness of the library's decision, given that it circulates other works that are equally if not even more suggestive than Ms. James.' "Lady Chatterley's Lover," the 1928 novel by D.H. Lawrence, was considered so scandalous that authorities banned it in the U.S. until 1959. Yet it appears in the Harford County library's online catalog. So does Vladimir Nabokov's "Lolita," a work so unconventional that one critic denounced it as "the filthiest book I have ever read" and "sheer unrestrained pornography" when it was published in France in 1955.

Both books, of course, are now considered classics of 20thcentury literature. But such judgments were impossible to even guess at when they first appeared, simply because few were allowed to read them. Hardly anyone today seriously thinks either novel poses a mortal threat to the republic, and they're routinely taught in college literature courses. We should have learned by now that suppressing books, be they religious texts, political and historical tracts or fanciful works of fiction, rarely makes us safer. It only leaves us more ignorant of our own and others' possibilities.

Clearly, some books are not appropriate for 12-year-olds, and "Fifty Shades of Grey" almost certainly is one of them. It's a librarian's job to screen what's available on the shelves for young readers, and that responsibility must be taken seriously. But adults are perfectly capable of making up their own minds about whether a book is worth reading, and they should be free to make that choice without interference from the self-appointed censors at their local public library.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Small businesses' fast track to ruin

    Small businesses' fast track to ruin

    It's said all the time — everyone loves small businesses. They're the backbone of our communities, creating jobs and making our country stronger. For an organization like the Chesapeake Sustainable Business Council, we take it a step further — our aim is to strengthen and rebuild underserved communities...

  • The two-front war on heroin

    The two-front war on heroin

    The most encouraging words spoken at the recent Baltimore Summit on Maryland's heroin problem were made by the person charged with leading the state's pushback on this evil drug and the terrible consequences it bestows on the community, the family and the taxpayer.

  • School reform needs reform

    School reform needs reform

    It's time to put the narrative to rest: teachers are not lazy, incompetent, uncaring union thugs who need to be monitored by lengthy student testing and supplanted by devices. This tired, poorly drawn image brought to you by the so-called education reformers is falling to the truth, and public...

  • We're going to owe a lot to Caitlyn Jenner

    We're going to owe a lot to Caitlyn Jenner

    Caitlyn Jenner — who purposely did not spell her new name with a K — is going to absorb an unimaginable amount of attention for the rest of her life. Whatever is not emotionally draining is going to be bruising. I do not envy her, but we owe her our gratitude.

  • Baltimore's deadly May

    Baltimore's deadly May

    Baltimore just endured what appears to be its highest homicide rate for a single month since it started keeping track of killings. The 43 murders in May were the most of any month since 1972, and on a per capita basis they outstrip that grim record by far. Mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake took note...

  • The Common Core can't speed up child development

    The Common Core can't speed up child development

    Recent evaluations of the state's preschoolers have determined that only 47 percent are ready for kindergarten, compared to 83 percent judged ready last year. This drastic drop isn't the result of an abrupt, catastrophic decline in the cognitive abilities of our children. Instead it results from...