Summer Sale! Get unlimited digital access for 13 weeks for $13.
News Opinion Editorial

Gas tax gets a second look

Anyone who believes that political stalemate over raising taxes or a preference for deferring hard choices were problems unique to Congress has probably never been to Annapolis. Even when one party dominates both chambers, as the Democrats do in the Maryland State House, lawmakers are all too frequently loath to stick their necks out for anything controversial if there's any possibility it might be postponed.

Witness last week's debate over Maryland's transportation finances and the possibility of raising the gas tax. Everyone seems to recognize that the status quo is wholly unacceptable. But aside from local officials (who won't have to answer to voters for a state-level tax hike), there was little sign of broad support for a gas tax increase.

It would not be unreasonable to defer the choice if the federal "fiscal cliff," that other profile in legislative cowardice, remains unresolved by President Barack Obama and Congress at the end of the upcoming General Assembly session. Should that happen, and the nation stand on the verge of another economic recession because of ill-considered across-the-board spending cuts and broad tax increases, then yes — perhaps it would not be prudent not to add some immediate statewide tax increase to compound Washington's failure.

But postponing the gas tax decision under any other circumstance is doing no favor to consumers, whether they are poor, middle class or wealthy. Neglect of Maryland's transportation infrastructure — its roads, bridges, public transit, airports and ports — only hurts the economy and job creation.

And make no mistake, that's where the choice stands. The Maryland Transportation Trust Fund is running on empty in terms of capital investment, and the most recent forecast is that it will be reduced to what's known as "system preservation" (meaning little more than pot hole repair) within five years. But it's really worse than that, since several projects planned for the near future, like Baltimore's Red Line light rail project, lack funding and would grind to a halt much earlier.

That means no widening of the Baltimore or Capital beltways; no replacement for the Harry W. Nice Bridge in Southern Maryland; no planned upgrades on Route 295 or MARC's Penn Line or Route 32 in Howard County. All these and many other "wish list" projects so strongly supported by the business community, local governments and the affected communities would have to be deferred.

Might there be another way to pay for them? Analysts say there are some things that could be of marginal help: public-private partnerships on certain projects, redirecting general obligation bonds (which might otherwise pay for different capital projects), or tapping into a federal loan program may provide some modest help. Ultimately, raising the gas tax from its current 1992 funding level remains the best available alternative.

Critics claim that Maryland would not be so desperate for transportation money if millions hadn't been taken out of the trust fund to help balance the state General Fund budget during the economic downturn. But that's simply not true. Those funds have largely been repaid — aside from local aid (known as highway user revenue) that Baltimore City and the county governments saw cut so that other forms of local aid (for education, for instance) were not reduced instead.

Maryland commuters already endure some of the most congested roads and longest travel times in the country. That translates into a financial loss every bit as real as a dime added to the gas tax. What Gov. Martin O'Malley proposed last year — gradually applying the 6 percent sales tax to gasoline — still strikes us as a reasonable, balanced approach that might raise the cost of a gallon of gasoline 18 cents within three years. Considering the volatility of petroleum prices (the average for regular unleaded in Maryland has dropped 50 cents since mid-September), it probably wouldn't even be noticed.

What would consumers get in return for that? It could leverage billions of dollars in transportation spending, create thousands of jobs and pump up the state's economy at a time of potential federal cutbacks when a bit of stimulus may be in order.

It's time politicians paid less attention to the polls and the public's knee-jerk reaction to the words "gas tax" and paid a little more attention to their long-term interests. It's easy to give voters what they want — more spending and less taxes — but that's exactly how government gets into a mess, whether it's a fiscal cliff or a pot-hole-strewn road network.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Rural counties need a transportation lockbox [Letter]

    Rural counties need a transportation lockbox [Letter]

    This fall, Maryland voters will have a constitutional amendment on the ballot of interest to all state residents, taxpayers and drivers: Question 1, which will create a "lockbox" for state transportation funds.

  • Stop the stopgap thinking on transportation funding

    Stop the stopgap thinking on transportation funding

    As of late last week, the average price of a gallon of regular unleaded gasoline in the Baltimore area hovered around $2.71, about six cents below the national average and a few pennies less than a week ago. One year ago, the average was $3.52. And where are gasoline prices headed in September?...

  • How to fix Md.'s aging infrastructure

    How to fix Md.'s aging infrastructure

    Recent Sun articles and editorials have pointed the way forward for Maryland's aging infrastructure ("States scramble as federal highway funding erodes," Feb. 21).

  • Shouldn't Md. already have been inspecting aging bridges?

    Shouldn't Md. already have been inspecting aging bridges?

    The top transportation official in the state has ordered an immediate inspection of 27 aging bridges. This announcement comes after a slab of concrete from an I-495 overpass struck a car in Prince George's County ("Md. to inspect aging bridges," Feb. 13).

  • A pothole jars home the true cost of tax cuts

    A pothole jars home the true cost of tax cuts

    I just spent $650 for new wheel and a new tire because of damage from a pothole on an urban street. I was not speeding. I needed AAA service at 10 o'clock at night. And it could have been worse.

  • Tell Congress to fix our crumbling transportation infrastructure

    Tell Congress to fix our crumbling transportation infrastructure

    For nearly six years America has not had a long-term transportation bill. While Congress has bickered and passed short-term patchwork bills, our nation's roads, bridges and public transit systems have deteriorated. Moreover, projects to modernize and expand our transportation infrastructure have...

  • Gas tax is wasted

    Gas tax is wasted

    In your editorial, "Congress on the clock" (April 13), you talk about the federal Highway Trust Fund going bankrupt unless Congress acts to raise taxes. Motorists deserve better highways and bridge repair, but the truth is not all of the tax money motorists pay goes to build or repair roads or...

  • What's the cost of lower tolls?

    What's the cost of lower tolls?

    It is my understanding that Maryland's transportation infrastructure is in serious need of maintenance. If that is the case, what could possibly be the point of reducing the tolls on our highways, other than to make political capital ("Panel expected to OK toll reductions," May 7)?