Summer Sale! Get unlimited digital access for 13 weeks for $13.
News Opinion Editorial

Why Baltimore isn't Detroit

On the surface, the similarities are striking. Two great American cities that swelled in population and wealth in the first half of the 20th century on the strength of heavy manufacturing, places where family-supporting jobs were there for the taking by anyone with a high school degree. Then a long, slow decline spurred by the flight of industry overseas and residents to the suburbs, racial tension, crime, failing schools, disinvestment, unemployment and abandoned houses.

At the end of that road, Detroit filed for bankruptcy on Thursday, by far the largest American municipality to do so. Forty percent of its streetlights don't work, many people don't even think about calling 911 when they need an ambulance, and the city may soon have to sell off the collections of the Detroit Institute of Arts. Baltimore, meanwhile, is cutting property taxes and planning for a $1 billion school construction binge. The population has stabilized and may be growing, and the biggest controversy in town is over how much the city should subsidize developers who want to build a $1 billion, 28-acre office/residential/retail complex on the waterfront.

It's somewhat unusual to look at Baltimore — particularly in the midst of a violent crime wave — and consider its good fortune. But for all of its problems, and there are many, Baltimore has some undeniable strengths. The city has not completely abandoned its industrial-era economy — the Port of Baltimore, for example, remains a singular economic engine — but it has also undergone a profound transformation. Once a steel and shipbuilding town, Baltimore is now one of the great hubs for health care and biomedical research. The presence of the federal government has provided economic stability during that transition. The recent resurgence of the American auto industry came too late to save Detroit from financial ruin.

The other key difference between Baltimore and Detroit, though, is that city officials and residents here have been willing to make difficult decisions that put it on a more sustainable path. Detroit racked up $18 billion in debt because it borrowed money to support its operating costs and because it was unwilling to demand cuts to the lucrative benefits and pension packages its municipal employees enjoyed. Baltimore has a long way to go before it is held up as a model of efficient, lean government, but city leaders, and particularly current Mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake, have made putting the city on firmer fiscal footing a top priority. The mayor's 10-year plan to control costs, broaden the city's revenue stream and lower property taxes offers little short-term political gain and much pain. Her plan to switch future civilian employees to 401(k)-style retirement plans is unlikely to win her many friends. But it is the kind of thing that separates Baltimore from Detroit and puts us on a path to a better future.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Tired of sticking up for a city that doesn't stick up for me

    Tired of sticking up for a city that doesn't stick up for me

    Recently, a large semi-truck took off the back end of my car, which was parked right next to a "no trucks" sign on Toone Street in Canton. The entire experience was surreal, but initially I was fine because I was just relieved that no one was injured in any way. The truck driver was nice and apologetic...

  • City's costly tax strategy

    City's costly tax strategy

    Baltimore and the Baltimore Development Corporation have found a way to stimulate growth that costs the city money ("Rising wealth, falling school aid," Feb. 8).

  • The importance of Rawlings-Blake's pension reform

    The importance of Rawlings-Blake's pension reform

    Baltimore's active and retired police officers and fire fighters got a good bit of news this week with the release of an annual report on their pension system's finances. Thanks to strong investment returns and increased contributions from both the city and plan members, the system's net liabilities...

  • The message from voters

    The message from voters

    It appears that some of the long-serving politicians who have been addicted to tax and spending increases may have heard the message from voters that it's not their money and we are tired of them wasting our tax dollars ("Rawlings-Blake to create 'tax reform' task force," Nov. 11).

  • City Hall theater

    City Hall theater

    No sooner had the Baltimore City Council taken a strong step in defiance of Mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake's promised vetoes of two controversial bills Monday night than they announced their intentions to cave under the pressure and let her have her way. The council, it seems, is an independent,...

  • How to expand Baltimore's tax base

    How to expand Baltimore's tax base

    I have a couple of suggestions on how to make up for the city's loss of revenue due to state budget cuts ("Miller, black lawmakers voice concern over school cuts," Jan. 29).