Summer Savings! Get unlimited digital access for 13 weeks for $13.


News Opinion Editorial

Keeping Congress clean

In September 2008, the U.S. financial system was teetering on collapse and the stock market was shaky. But Alabama Republican Rep. Spencer Bachus saw opportunity in the crisis. According to an investigation by the CBS news program "60 Minutes," Mr. Bachus attended a closed-door meeting that month with then-Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson and Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke at which lawmakers were briefed on the probable course of events. A day later, Mr. Bachus bought two types of highly leveraged options, essentially betting that share prices would fall — which they did. A week later, the congressman pocketed a tidy $5,000 profit when he sold his options.

In a town where access to information is power, Washington lawmakers are particularly well positioned to benefit from market information not available to the public. In the corporate world, insider trading is strictly prohibited, and executives caught enriching themselves on the basis of nonpublic information face stiff criminal and civil penalties. But no such rules apply to information members of Congress get while supposedly doing the public's business, and as "60 Minutes" documented, members of both parties appear to have profited from knowledge gained on the job. The temptation for lawmakers to line their pockets through trades that would be illegal for anyone else is an invitation to abuse.

But while one can criticize the ethics of Mr. Bachus, who denies that he benefited from insider knowledge, the fact is that what he did was perfectly legal. That would change if lawmakers passed one of several bills now before Congress that would prohibit members from trading stocks based on nonpublic information they get while performing their official duties. Since the "60 Minutes" report aired, dozens of legislators have gotten behind an effort to revive long-ignored legislation called the STOCK Act, which would also require lawmakers to report purchases and sales of shares worth more than $1,000 within 90 days. (So far, only two Maryland lawmakers, Reps. Donna Edwards and Chris Van Hollen, both Democrats, have signed on as cosponsors.)

The legislation would at least be a start in bringing the rules governing congressional disclosure more in line with those of the private sector, where fund managers must report transactions within 48 hours. Currently, it can take a year or longer before information about a member of Congress' trades comes out. In the meantime, the public just has to take the lawmaker's word that his or her stock profits were based on information available to anyone.

With public distrust of the Congress at an all-time high, lawmakers should at least abide by the same standard they impose on everyone else. That's especially true for the rules against insider trading, where lawmakers, because of their unique access to information, potentially are in a position to benefit more than the people they're regulating. Lawmakers can hardly complain if Congress' reputation for trustworthiness is tanking when they hold others to a standard they refuse to hold themselves to.

The STOCK Act is not perfect. It would certainly be better if all lawmakers had to put their holdings in blind trusts, or at least in instruments indexed to broad movements of the stock market rather than in individual companies that might receive government funds or have their fortunes affected by government regulations. But the proposed law is a start toward making Congress more accountable. Lawmakers have no business using the inside information they get all the time to line their pockets at others' expense.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • The media doesn't just ignore the ethical lapses of liberals

    The writer from Marriottsville must have thrown a shoulder out of joint congratulating herself on detecting media bias in The Sun due to the alleged under-reporting of Rep. Nancy Pelosi's ethical difficulties concerning insider information ("Sun conveniently omits Pelosi's misdeed," Nov. 28). But...

  • Summer camp turns into trauma center in Baltimore

    Summer camp turns into trauma center in Baltimore

    Since the death of Freddie Gray, Baltimoreans have worked to address the underlying problems associated with the civil unrest. While city leaders look for solutions, Baltimore's children are bearing the brunt of the heightened turbulence.

  • Revive Export-Import Bank

    Revive Export-Import Bank

    What independent agency has supported millions of jobs, enjoyed support from Republican and Democrat presidents alike over its 81-year history and doesn't cost taxpayers a dime, actually earning billions of dollars in revenue for the U.S. Treasury? The answer is the U.S. Export-Import Bank, a little-known...

  • Reviewing the riots

    Reviewing the riots

    Maryland's National Guard is reviewing its response to the unrest that followed Freddie Gray's funeral, and its leaders have already briefed the commanders of every other state and territorial guard in the nation on their experience.

  • Ocean City's unwelcome mat

    Ocean City's unwelcome mat

    Either visitors are getting a little wilder or Ocean City residents are getting a bit more sensitive, but the conflict between summer vacationers and those who live in the beach resort year-round has reared its ugly head again. Tomorrow, the Ocean City Council is scheduled to consider legislation...

  • Riot preparedness [Poll]

    Riot preparedness [Poll]

    Is Baltimore any better prepared to handle the type of riots that erupted in response to Freddie Gray's death after experiencing them firsthand?

  • Atlantis awaits: melting ice and rising water for coastal cities

    Atlantis awaits: melting ice and rising water for coastal cities

    Our civilization is built on coastlines. Oceans were the first grocery stores, providing easy protein for early humans who learned to fish and gather shellfish and seaweed. Oceans were the first highways, enabling early exploration, commerce and migration. Oceans remain vital sources of food and...

  • Vice presidency is an important job nobody wants

    Vice presidency is an important job nobody wants

    The common view is that the American vice presidency is little more than booby prize awarded to achieve balance on the national ticket, and is a dead end to further political ambition.