Become a digitalPLUS subscriber. 99¢ for 4 weeks.
NewsOpinionEditorial

The money that slipped away

Property TaxLuxury Goods IndustrySilo Point

Baltimore's property tax rate is high (that's one thing that everyone that owns a home or business in the city can agree on) so nothing makes the blood boil quite like news that someone has successfully avoided paying their fair share — except, perhaps, finding out it wasn't a case of avoidance so much as lax enforcement.

That's what appears to have happened in the case of some of the city's priciest condos, as recently uncovered by reporter Jamie Smith Hopkins. Baltimore lost out on more than $10 million in property tax revenue over the last several years because some 200 luxury condos were assessed as if they were little more than holes in the ground.

But the condos at the Ritz-Carlton Residences and at Silo Point were a great deal more than that. Most have had occupancy permits for several years. Perhaps they awaited final details — finishing touches like floor coverings or paint colors — but that's not how they were treated by the Maryland State Department of Assessments and Taxation.

Instead of being assessed for $1 million or more, the premium properties were viewed as worth no more than $10,000 to $55,000 apiece. Somehow, they were judged as not being "substantially complete," which is the point when full market-based tax assessments are supposed to kick in.

Three years after occupancy permits are issued, they are not regarded as substantially complete? Sorry, but somebody in the state agency screwed up in a major league manner on this one.

Make no mistake, the owners of those two prestigious developments appear to bear little or no responsibility for this circumstance. And certainly, we would not blame them for wishing to have lower assessments, particularly in such a challenging real estate market.

But the low assessments were patently unfair for those developers with projects that compete against Silo Point and Ritz-Carlton Residences but must pay thousands of dollars each year in property taxes for unsold units. No doubt they'd benefit from this kind of lax enforcement, too, but they didn't receive it.

And the situation is especially unfair to the residents of Baltimore who pay high property taxes to support such essential services as fire and police protection and public education. You can bet that Joe Average Homeowner would love to get this kind of treatment and pay taxes based on such a faulty assessment process.

Granted, assessing property value is not an easy business, and those who tackle this duty seldom win a lot of popularity contests. State officials have an enormous inventory to track and are bound to make mistakes. It's clear that whenever possible, they prefer to err on the side of caution, avoiding excessively high assessments.

What happened in this case, however, is damaging to the agency's reputation as it can easily be construed as preferential treatment to deep-pocketed private interests. When property owners lose confidence that the tax collector is adhering to the rules, what started as an honest mistake could be viewed as far more nefarious.

Nor is it exactly the only problem with property tax laws (and how they are administered) that has been uncovered in recent months. As The Sun has previously documented, Maryland's property tax credit programs have shortcomings, too. In one case, the law has fueled massive inequities in property tax bills that have been particularly advantageous to the wealthy. In another case, the system has caused people to purchase homes they could not afford (while failing to help others who qualified for assistance because the program wasn't sufficiently publicized).

Although the state is broadly in charge of assessments, it is Baltimore City and the counties who bear the brunt of such mistakes; the state portion of property taxes is much lower than the local share. And in Baltimore, where revenues chronically fall short and the tax rate is twice as high as anywhere else in Maryland, the consequences of those mistakes are so much the greater.

The city has recently put some resources into cracking down on mistaken assessments and ill-gotten tax breaks, but the frequency with which Ms. Hopkins and her reporting partner, Scott Calvert, are uncovering new breakdowns in the system leads one to wonder just how effective those efforts are. Moreover, their reporting has, so far, focused just on Baltimore City; there's no reason to expect that the faults they have discovered here are not repeated across the state.

If a pair of reporters with no greater access to property tax data than members of the general public can uncover so many millions in lost tax revenue, there's no reason every local government in the state shouldn't be doing the same. Clearly, such a project would pay for itself in no time, and elected officials might discover that cracking down on assessments is a whole lot more popular with voters that broad-based tax increases when it comes time to cover budget shortfalls, state or local.

Copyright © 2014, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
Property TaxLuxury Goods IndustrySilo Point
  • A message to the netherworld
    A message to the netherworld

    Blessed with an appetite for good Italian sausage served with peppers and onions, as well as an abundant curiosity, I took myself to The Great Halloween Lantern Parade and Festival last Saturday night without knowing quite what to expect. The only person I'd ever met who had seen the...

  • Repeating our Middle East mistakes
    Repeating our Middle East mistakes

    President Barack Obama's latest foray into the Middle East is unfortunately reactive and uninformed and shows how very little he seems to take into account our bloody history in the region.

  • Democrats run the economy better
    Democrats run the economy better

    There are many reasons to be a Democrat — civil rights, environmental protection, protecting national security without being the world's policeman, and more. Yet, the Democratic Party's strongest advantage over our Republican opponents is that Democrats run the economy far...

  • Frosh for attorney general
    Frosh for attorney general

    Much of the day-to-day work of Maryland's attorney general involves managing a legion of attorneys who provide counsel and legal advice to state government agencies large and small and to various boards and commissions. Nonetheless, the job is not to serve the governor or his...

  • Carroll's transit phobia
    Carroll's transit phobia

    Outsiders might be shocked to learn that Carroll County promotes itself as a tourism destination. From wineries to Civil War sights, walking tours and recreational opportunities, the county touts all sorts of things to come see and do. The official visitors guide beckons with a "Welcome...

  • Daylight saving time [Poll]
    Daylight saving time [Poll]
Comments
Loading