Get unlimited digital access to $0.99 for 4 weeks.
News Opinion Editorial

Jobs for city residents

Baltimore City Solicitor George Nilson appears to have shot down a proposal to require businesses that receive large city contracts or tax breaks from City Hall to hire local residents for 51 percent of new jobs they create. Last week, Mr. Nilson said the bill could violate a section of the U.S. Constitution barring discrimination against job-seekers based on where they live. But the bill's sponsor, City Council President Bernard C. "Jack" Young, insists the measure is needed to address the city's stubbornly high unemployment rate.

Everyone agrees that creating more jobs for city residents is a worthy goal. The question is how best to accomplish that. Mr. Young's bill calls for unspecified criminal sanctions on employers who fail to meet the hiring threshold, but that could also scare off some businesses. There's also the matter of matching employers' hiring needs to the skills of city job applicants. Those questions, on top of the bill's potential vulnerability to legal challenges, have rightly raised doubts about whether a local hiring requirement represents the most practical approach to reducing city unemployment.

But there are alternative approaches. The city could set hiring goals for businesses that receive city contracts that don't involve criminal penalties, much the way it handles its efforts to encourage minority- and women-owned businesses. Companies could satisfy those goals by making a good-faith effort to hire a certain percentage of their workers from among local residents without fear of penalties for adjustments that take into account the the availability of workers with needed skills in the local labor pool. Financial or other incentives for hiring local workers could be built into city contracts, or contractors on large jobs could be required to open hiring centers in the city.

Moreover, Baltimore should look beyond using its purchasing power to increase the number of gainfully employed city residents. Baltimore already has an array of incentives for certain city employees, such as police officers and school teachers, to live in the city. Those could be expanded to appeal to other kinds of workers. Getting more such people to live in Baltimore — Mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake has set a goal of 10,000 new families over the next decade — could drastically lower overall unemployment and indirectly create new jobs by attracting businesses to neighborhoods undergoing revitalization. The city should also examine its licensing and regulation system to eliminate unneeded barriers to business creation in the city.

Mr. Nilson says a number of other cities around the country have approved local hiring requirements, only to see them struck down by federal court judges on constitutional grounds. Those that have not are in places where either the laws have not been challenged or the complaints were not brought under the Constitution's Privileges and Immunities Clause, which governs such cases.

If he is right that any measure mandating preferences for private employment based on residence is unlikely to survive constitutional muster, council members may well decide they don't want to go down that road, only to reach a dead end in court. But at the moment it's still unclear whether the city can't rewrite the proposal in terms that don't violate the Constitution — for example, by targeting job applicants' employment history or other attributes that don't specifically refer to residency.

What's certain is that the city's unemployment problem isn't going away, and that needs to be addressed. Mr. Young is to be commended for raising this issue. Now that the city solicitor has raised questions about his proposal, Mayor Rawlings-Blake should work with Mr. Young to find alterantives that can pass legal muster.

  • Text NEWS to 70701 to get Baltimore Sun local news text alerts
  • Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
    Related Content
    • Putting Baltimore to work

      The Baltimore Sun editorial board's recent focus on the issue of local hiring ("Jobs for City Residents" January 9) is appreciated as increasing job opportunities for city residents is the central focus of the Mayor's Office of Employment Development (MOED). Under the leadership of Mayor...

    • Mayor is promoting local hiring

      A recent Sun editorial ("Jobs for city residents" January 9), suggests that city government has done little to promote local hiring and job creation and that by ensuring proposed city ordinances are legally-sufficient, the Baltimore City Law Department is somehow impeding the city's progress.

    • Mr. Obama's 529 brouhaha
      Mr. Obama's 529 brouhaha

      Rarely does a president flip-flop on an initiative presented in the State of the Union address as quickly as Barack Obama did this week. He reversed himself on 529 college savings plans on Tuesday, which was just seven days after his speech to the nation. Such a political miscalculation is...

    • Defeating Boko Haram
      Defeating Boko Haram

      The bloody attacks in Paris this month that left 20 people dead, including the three attackers, riveted the world's attention on the growing threat Islamist extremist groups pose to the democracies of Western Europe. Yet even as the French people were mourning their loss, an even more...

    • Under Armour police uniforms [Poll]
      Under Armour police uniforms [Poll]
    • Realizing a 'Greater' Baltimore
      Realizing a 'Greater' Baltimore

      Though people may describe the region around Baltimore City as "Greater Baltimore," area leaders — from government, business, non-profits and academia — could do more to fully embrace that term and develop the potential it implies. Doing so is a critical component for the...

    • Medicare 'quality indicators' diverge from quality care
      Medicare 'quality indicators' diverge from quality care

      Health and Human Services Secretary Sylvia Burwell announced this week that, through the Affordable Care Act (ACA), Medicare would be taking drastic steps to assure that doctors are paid not for visits and procedures, but rather for the value of their work. The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid...

    • Exercise: find the time for it
      Exercise: find the time for it

      The early-morning holiday shoppers of last month have been replaced at the mall by early-morning walkers, some of whom have begun new exercise regimens for the new year.