Try digitalPLUS for 10 days for only $0.99


News Opinion Editorial

Pensions, bonuses and county budgets

This is the season when local governments finalize their budgets for the next fiscal year, and the grousing about their penurious circumstances is in full swing. Some are even complaining that the state's revised budget and tax plan — signed into law by Gov.Martin O'Malleythis week — has put a serious crimp in their finances.

In particular, they blame the state's decision to shift a portion of the cost of teacher retirement contributions to Baltimore City and the counties as ruinous to their own budgets. Already, Harford County Executive David Craig has decided he will not offer the one-time, $650-per-worker bonuses he promised county and school employees.

But there's just one problem with the narrative that portrays the state's elected leaders as the tax-and-spend bad guys and their local government counterparts as their innocent victims. In the vast majority of cases, counties are in better shape for fiscal 2013 as a result of the recent special session, particularly when compared to the "doomsday" budget that they would have faced otherwise.

That's because, while the teacher pension shift is going to cost local governments millions of dollars, the various tax increases lawmakers also approved are going to offset that cost. In some cases, local governments come out way, way ahead.

Take Anne Arundel County, for instance. The teacher pension shift will cost the county nearly $11.5 million next year. But because the legislature raised the income tax, applied the recordation tax to "indemnity mortgages," increased the tax on little cigars and smokeless tobacco, and raised the fees on death certificates, among other actions, the net effect is that Anne Arundel will be receiving $8.8 million more from Annapolis than it was previously due, for an overall 5.6 percent increase in state aid.

And the county is hardly alone. From the Eastern Shore to Western Maryland, the majority of counties are coming out ahead in a similar fashion. Only eight of the 24 are net losers, with Harford County suffering the biggest loss of all — about $4.8 million, according to a recent report by the Maryland Department of Legislative Services.

There are a number of reasons for Harford County's misfortune. One of the biggest is that the county receives no extra education aid under the Geographic Cost of Education Index that tries to offset cost-of-living differences. That was funded under the revised budget agreement.

But then, Mr. Craig could scarcely be surprised by any of this. Lawmakers have been talking about requiring local governments to share in the teacher pension obligation since the county executive served in Annapolis more than a decade ago, and the move was regarded as a near-certainty in the weeks leading up to the regular 90-day session. Under the circumstances, he was wise to only have been proposing one-time bonuses instead of permanent salary increases.

As much heat as Governor O'Malley and Democrats have taken for their pension decision, it's important to keep some perspective. The shift is gradual (over four years) and it has no impact on the state's direct aid to school systems. By fiscal 2016, the counties will face a collective $67 million shortfall from the move, but that's hardly a catastrophe. The state's additional pension payments are expected to increase more than twice as much over the same period.

Had lawmakers not simultaneously increased taxes and fees, the story would be a bit different, of course. But even so, it's hardly unreasonable for local governments to share in the pension costs just as they share in salary costs.

Nevertheless, the fact that the General Assembly agreed to raise taxes actually reduces the likelihood that most local governments will have to raise taxes, too. That's fortunate because they have far fewer budget-balancing options available to them. Often, the choice for counties comes down to layoffs or raising property taxes, two particularly unpleasant options.

Harford's situation is atypical, of course. Withdrawing the bonus should more than make up the fiscal 2013 shortfall, but not for future deficits. Mr. Craig, a Republican, is often mentioned as a possible candidate for governor in 2014, so how he balances his county's budget — whether through cuts, taxes or a combination of the two (and whether those choices satisfy county residents) — could provide a rare opportunity for him to make his mark in statewide politics.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Maryland's unfriendly business climate kills another 1,000 jobs

    Maryland's unfriendly business climate kills another 1,000 jobs

    Maryland is incredibly unfriendly to business with its heavy burden of regulations, high taxes and an out-of-control minority business enterprise extortion process that enriches a few African-Americans without hiring the inner city minorities it is designed to assist ("The Bechtel blame game,"...

  • Senator displays his own arrogance

    Senator displays his own arrogance

    State Sen. Paul Pinsky writes an appropriately-named commentary condemning corporate lobbyists and maintaining that he and his fellow Democrats will fight against this "corporate victory" in the past election ("Post-election arrogance?" Nov. 14). That's funny. I was under the apparently mistaken...

  • Hogan's fiscal realities

    Hogan's fiscal realities

    When Republican Larry Hogan was elected governor this month, his platform was narrow and clear: Roll back as many of the tax increases of the last eight years as possible. When he made that promise, he knew he faced a $405 million shortfall in this year's budget and next year's as soon as he walked...

  • Congress must create a level playing field for bricks-and-mortar businesses and online vendors

    Congress must create a level playing field for bricks-and-mortar businesses and online vendors

    During the next few weeks Congress will have the opportunity to pass e-fairness legislation, which will update our sales tax system and restore fairness to small businesses in our community.

  • A bad investment

    A bad investment

    Maryland's film industry employs a lot of good people, mostly highly skilled laborers. Because the state has been home to a string of television series over the years, of which "Veep" and "House of Cards" are only the latest, many of them have set down roots here and have contributed to the community...

  • No major tax rollbacks?

    No major tax rollbacks?

    Senate President Thomas V. Mike Miller told some reporters this week what most State House observers have long suspected — we should not expect some sweeping reduction in taxes during the upcoming legislative session. He also produced a spirited defense of the tax increases approved during Gov....

  • Can Hogan get state spending under control?

    Can Hogan get state spending under control?

    A recent report failed to recognize that the major contributors to Maryland's and every other state's fiscal problems are their government employee pension plans ("Business groups look to reduce tax burden for some," Dec. 5).

  • Hogan's fiscal rhetoric meets reality

    Hogan's fiscal rhetoric meets reality

    When Gov.-elect Larry Hogan proclaimed the need for "strong medicine" to cure Maryland's fiscal state, he drew some jeers from the Democrats in Annapolis. The O'Malley administration bristled at the notion that he was bad-mouthing the incumbent governor's fiscal management. Sen. Richard Madaleno...