Unlimited Access. Try it Today! Your First 10 Days Always $0.99
News Opinion Editorial

Alonso's departure: A blow and an opportunity

Baltimore schools CEO Andrés Alonso's resignation at the end of this academic year is a major blow to a city whose trajectory he helped change. There can be little doubt that the energetic and rapid reforms he implemented in the city's long-struggling school system have set the stage for broader renewal and growth in Baltimore. But city leaders also need to look on his departure as a tremendous opportunity, a chance to bring in a new superintendent who will build on Mr. Alonso's successes. The city school board has promised a national search for his replacement, and it should settle for nothing short of greatness. Baltimore, under Mr. Alonso's leadership, established itself as the pace-setter for education reform in America, and the combination of his accomplishments and the city's eagerness to support often difficult reforms should make this one of the most attractive positions for a superintendent in the nation.

Mr. Alonso, paraphrasing race car driver Mario Andretti, adopted as his mantra the notion that if you feel totally in control, you're not going fast enough. Indeed, Baltimore's schoolchildren have only one chance to get an education, and Mr. Alonso felt keenly that they could not wait for the adults who run the school system to get it right. Upon his arrival here six years ago, he began a radical decentralization of a system that had grown top-heavy, sending money and autonomy to principals while cutting the North Avenue headquarters staff by a third. He closed schools that were failing and opened new, better ones. He made teachers, principals and other administrators responsible for personally contacting students who had dropped out and urging them to come back. He reduced out-of-school suspensions and established an alternative school on North Avenue. He expanded school choice, embraced charter schools and hammered out a landmark teacher contract that will link pay with growth in student performance.

The result: The dropout rate is down, the graduation rate is up, and student test scores are substantially higher than they were when he arrived. Crucially for a city seeking a rebound, the list of city schools that can now compete with the best options in the suburbs has steadily grown, making it easier for families to choose to stay here.

Mr. Alonso has not been perfect. Cheating scandals at some schools — and a bungling of the district's investigation into them — hurt public trust in his leadership and raised doubts about the gains he had made. Stories of financial mismanagement — lavish meals on school system credit cards; hefty overtime bills for Mr. Alonso's driver and others; a $250,000 renovation of the information technology chief's office suite; overpayment of staff; and uncollected debts — made clear that Mr. Alonso had not completely vanquished the waste and inefficiency that plagued the system before his arrival. And his attempt to hire as his chief deputy the former school board president — who turned out to have a record of personal financial troubles and who lied about his academic qualifications — looked like the fruit of hubris.

But the real trouble Mr. Alonso faced was that the rapid rise in test scores the system's students posted during his early years had plateaued. The ideas he put in place when he came to Baltimore, it seems, could only do so much to improve performance, and it was not clear what Mr. Alonso had for a second act. Given all he had accomplished so far, the school board certainly had reason to give him the benefit of the doubt. But Mr. Alonso's decision to resign so that he can spend more time with his ailing parents gives the board the chance to find someone who can build on Mr. Alonso's reforms to the district's structure and governance and achieve a similar degree of success in improving classroom-level instruction. Mr. Alonso has created a situation in which success is possible; his replacement needs to provide teachers with the training and resources to guarantee that they achieve it.

The board cannot settle for second-best, and it shouldn't have to. Some cities — including the one 45 miles to the south — have balked at the kind of difficult reforms Mr. Alonso enacted. Baltimore embraced them and asked for more. And if the freedom that implies isn't enough to attract stellar candidates, we can offer a major sweetener: a $1 billion school construction and renovation program approved this spring by the General Assembly. Not many urban school districts offer that kind of opportunity.

Baltimore owes an enormous debt to Mr. Alonso for his passion, insight and vigor. He accomplished more in his six years here than his predecessors had in a generation. But we cannot allow his departure to set back the cause of school reform. Baltimore's schoolchildren can't afford that.

  • Text NEWS to 70701 to get Baltimore Sun local news text alerts
  • Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
    Related Content
    • City schools' self-inflicted wound
      City schools' self-inflicted wound

      The Sun's report this week that Baltimore City school employees were paid $46 million last year in accrued leave, bonuses, overtime and other benefits is an embarrassment that couldn't come at a more inopportune moment. The department is already facing a $72 million budget deficit next year,...

    • Charter school roadblock
      Charter school roadblock

      Republican Gov. Larry Hogan campaigned on a pledge to increase the number of charter schools in the state, which currently has one of the most restrictive charter school laws in the nation. By making charter schools easier to open and operate in Maryland, the governor hopes to give parents more...

    • Charter schools and public accountability
      Charter schools and public accountability

      The charter school bill currently in the Maryland General Assembly would not permit schools run by "private institutions" ("Miller urges senators to pass Hogan's charter bill," March 17).

    • Moving forward in city schools
      Moving forward in city schools

      Baltimore City schools CEO Gregory Thornton says he wants to roll back some aspects of his predecessor's policy that gave principals more authority over budget and staffing decisions at their schools. No doubt some adjustments are due in the governance structure instituted by former schools CEO...

    • Rebuilding trust
      Rebuilding trust

      Baltimore's legislative delegation on Friday backed off its support for a plan to allow the city's School Police Force, which is separate from the Baltimore City Police Department, to carry guns inside school buildings. The city school board never offered a convincing rationale for proposing...

    • Charter schools alone aren't enough
      Charter schools alone aren't enough

      Thanks for David W. Hornbeck's trenchant commentary on charter schools ("Charter schools do not equal education reform," Feb. 27).

    • Parents oppose armed school police because they don't trust them
      Parents oppose armed school police because they don't trust them

      The Sun correctly identified trust as issue at the heart of the debate over whether school police officers should be allowed to carry weapons inside school buildings ("A matter of trust," Feb. 27).

    • City Council asleep at budgeting switch
      City Council asleep at budgeting switch

      Baltimore voters and taxpayers, it's time to kick these long-serving politicians to the curb. How can anyone sit on the City Council's education committee and not know how these appointed heads of these government agencies spend tax dollars with no accountability ("City Council members...

    Comments
    Loading