Get unlimited digital access to $0.99 for 4 weeks.
News Opinion

Privatizing retirement benefits is a mistake

Thomas Firey of the Maryland Policy Institute offers a libertarian approach to economic security in retirement ("Better pension reform," July 27).

Mr. Firey argues that because some Illinois teachers chose in 1998 not to take a "buy-in" for increasing their eventual pension benefits, Maryland state employees should be able to "buy-back" future pension benefits. The employees would receive cash now in exchange for benefits they would otherwise be entitled to when they retire, thereby reducing the state's long-term pension obligations.

This suggestion does not represent sound public policy.

The Illinois teachers who turned down an increase in their retirement pensions probably were satisfied with their existing benefits and thus chose to save their cash for other uses. This is not the same as getting cash now in exchange for a small pension in the future.

It is more like a number of schemes have surfaced in recent years for "privatization" of all insurance programs. These schemes make the employee responsible for most or all of his or her future security.

It may appear laudable for each of us to take complete charge of our affairs. But that really isn't really feasible. Many private schemes just aren't reliable; and when they prove not to be, what then?

Neil Curran, Baltimore

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Funding young scientists
    Funding young scientists

    This month, Johns Hopkins University President Ronald J. Daniels sounded an alarm about the difficulty young science researchers have in obtaining the grant funding that they need to launch their careers. In an article in Proceedings of the National Academy of the Sciences, he noted that the...

  • A 'role model deficit' for young black men
    A 'role model deficit' for young black men

    Young men may imitate what they do see. They definitely will not imitate what they don't see.

  • Street policing doesn't belong in school
    Street policing doesn't belong in school

    In recent months, there has been a flood of video evidence of police violence in our communities. Earlier this week, a gut-wrenching video surfaced that shows a school police officer violently attacking three young girls inside one of our middle schools. The incident starts when one of the...

  • Marissa Alexander's out of jail, but not yet free
    Marissa Alexander's out of jail, but not yet free

    Marissa Alexander got out of jail last week, but she is not free. At best, she enjoys only a species of freedom, a defective freedom thatimperfectly resembles the real thing. 

  • The changing face of higher education
    The changing face of higher education

    We have been reading for some time now about the demographic shift that was occurring in the nation, but I don't think we in higher education have truly digested the impact it will have on our institutions. Two weeks ago, the Southern Education Foundation released a report, A New Majority,...

  • Obama sticks to his comfort zone
    Obama sticks to his comfort zone

    More than week after his State of the Union address, political observers are still trying to figure out what President Barack Obama's game is. That's because rhetorically and substantively, he seems to be in another world.