Summer Sale Extended! Get unlimited digital access for 13 weeks for $13.
News Opinion

Driver's licenses for all drivers

In Annapolis, some conservative Republicans — having apparently not taken notice of the 2012 election and the conundrum facing their party over its hard-line immigration stance at the national level — are lambasting a proposal to expand and make permanent a two-tier driver's license system in Maryland. One even warned that Maryland could soon become a "Disneyland" for illegal immigrants.

But it is opponents who are living in a Disney-like fantasy land if they can't see who the chief beneficiary would be of any system that seeks to ensure all Maryland drivers meet minimum standards of knowledge and competency and are eligible for insurance. That would, of course, be everyone who ever chooses to drive on roads in this state.

The Senate approved the driver's licensing measure this week with that pragmatic goal in mind. There are approximately 275,000 immigrants living in Maryland who lack lawful status. Many of them drive (and even have licenses now). Do we bar them from renewing or acquiring a license? That only increases the likelihood that they will not be properly trained and insured.

On the other hand, would such hardship cause these immigrants to vacate the country they now call home — and may have called home for a generation or more? One need only look to the rest of the United States, where an estimated 11 million illegal immigrants reside with or without a driver's license, to know that's not the case.

When President George W. Bush signed the REAL ID Act into law in 2005, we warned that forcing the Motor Vehicle Administration to enforce federal immigration policy was unwise. The law stemmed from the need to create a de facto national identification card, particularly to verify the identity of passengers on planes or visitors to federal facilities.

But evolving federal regulations also allow states to offer a second-tier driver's license, one that won't necessarily be accepted at airports (at least not after this summer, according to the U.S. Department of Homeland Security) but will do what a driver's license is designed to do — make sure the applicant meets minimum safety standards.

That seems like a reasonable accommodation. And far better than encouraging a black market for fake Maryland driver's licenses or having to deal with a lot of unlicensed drivers. This isn't a handout; it's a matter of self-protection. Until Congress crafts immigration policy that provides a future for the nation's undocumented immigrants, states will likely have to make more such choices. At least a dozen states are contemplating similar plans.

Immigration opponents tend to conjure up images of illegal immigrants as criminals or welfare layabouts. In reality, they are people like the recent 18-year-old high school graduate who came to the U.S. as a baby and who President Barack Obama has pledged not to deport.

Last year, voters endorsed in-state college tuition rates for such taxpaying individuals under the Maryland Dream Act. Don't we also want to ensure that these future college graduates — young adults who may have no memory of living anywhere but the United States — have a way to go to work and live a productive life? What could possibly be the point of denying them a driver's license?

The notion that this accommodation might endanger national security is laughable. To suggest that implies that Transportation Security Administration agents are incapable of reading a driver's license properly. If so, those responsible for airport security have bigger issues than a two-tiered license to worry about.

Admittedly, this is not the ideal solution. Far better for Washington to finally craft some sensible immigration policy that provides a path toward citizenship for those who are living here, leading productive lives and deserving of that opportunity. Then a two-tiered driver's license might not even be necessary.

But that probably won't happen until the GOP puts less energy into vilifying immigrants and more into coalescing behind a compromise with the Democrats. Immigration reform would be better for the future of the Republican Party, for the nation's economy and for the safety of our highways. In the meantime, stop-gap efforts like a two-tier driver's license are going to be needed.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • U.S. not alone in birthright citizenship

    U.S. not alone in birthright citizenship

    The local front man for anti-immigrant hysteria thinks it is time to change the 14th Amendment and myriad Supreme Court precedents to exclude children of non-citizens born in the United States from birthright citizenship ("Illegal immigration is costly," Aug. 24). He neglects to mention that the...

  • Don't cheerlead for foreign worker visa expansion

    Don't cheerlead for foreign worker visa expansion

    I am not comfortable with the H-2B foreign worker visa program, yet The Sun reported a flattering, one-sided report on its expansion, giving credit to Sen. Barbara Mikulski for "cutting red tape" to once again rescue her major campaign donors in the landscaping and seafood industries ("Md. seafood...

  • What is immigration costing Md.?

    What is immigration costing Md.?

    I read with interest The Sun's article, "More school money sought" (Jan. 12). The article notes that the superintendent of Baltimore County Public Schools is requesting an 8.7 percent increase in the school budget. In part, the increase is needed due to "an influx of children in need" and "to hire...

  • Let's show compassion for young immigrants [Letter]

    Let's show compassion for young immigrants [Letter]

    Maryland saw an influx of unaccompanied children from Central America this summer. Today, we have more than 3,000 of these kids. I'm glad Maryland is harboring, them but each has a sword of Damocles over his or her head ("Montgomery Co. is latest to limit immigration detainers," Oct. 7). As Customs...

  • Trump is right about immigration

    Trump is right about immigration

    It comes as no surprise that The Sun's editorial board has jumped on the anti-Donald Trump bandwagon trumpeting the usual racist label when they have no other legitimate counter argument ("The summer of hate," July 13). The editors obviously have not read nor comprehended the scope of the 1996...

  • Immigration standoff

    Immigration standoff

    There is something truly unsavory about targeting for deportation immigrant children — particularly those known by the shorthand of "dreamers" who were brought to this country at a young age by their parents — but that was the priority of House Republicans last week. Not all in the GOP went along,...

  • We need data, not guesses on the economics of immigration

    We need data, not guesses on the economics of immigration

    John Fritze and Luke Broadwater's article "Baltimore weighs in on immigration lawsuit" ("Jan. 24) does an excellent job of identifying some of the potential economic pros and cons of undocumented immigrants living in our communities. It discusses "a federal lawsuit that has divided state and local...

  • Democrats side with foreigners

    Democrats side with foreigners

    Democrats are telling Republicans to put the American people first and pass a clean Department of Homeland Security funding bill because Democratic senators will not accept anything other than a clean bill ("Congress OKs deal to avoid shutdown at Homeland Security," Feb. 27). Republicans say they...