Unlimited Access. Try it Today! Your First 10 Days Always $0.99

Opinion

News Opinion

Transit a dubious public expenditure, not an 'investment'

While I agree with Scot Spencer's recent assertion that "investments" must create jobs ("Md. must make sure transit investments create jobs here," Sept. 18), I think an "investment" in mass public transportation is a net loser. Until the farebox can cover at least the operating expenses, don't "invest" a dime in it. The whole concept of mass transit is a social engineering project intended to locate jobs, housing, etc., where the government wants them, not necessarily where people would choose to live and work. It's a form of welfare intended to subsidize those who chose not to use their own cars or for those who have made poor choices in life and can't afford to provide their own transportation.

The whole "investment" word usage is a snow-job as well. We can thank Gov. Martin O'Malley for that word-usage travesty. Progressives (why can't they just call themselves what they are, liberals), seem unable to use the proper words, "spending projects." An "investment" implies a positive return on spending; it's highly likely that any positive benefits would fall well short of the negative total return from mass transit projects. The conundrum faced by such dubious federal laws such as Buy America, is that such mandated buying or hiring programs inflate the cost projections, furthering the gap between expenditure (investment) and benefit. When will the madness end?

Let the market play out, its record of success far exceeds that of government.

Craig R. Piette, Reisterstown

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Shouldn't Md. already have been inspecting aging bridges?
    Shouldn't Md. already have been inspecting aging bridges?

    The top transportation official in the state has ordered an immediate inspection of 27 aging bridges. This announcement comes after a slab of concrete from an I-495 overpass struck a car in Prince George's County ("Md. to inspect aging bridges," Feb. 13).

  • A pothole jars home the true cost of tax cuts
    A pothole jars home the true cost of tax cuts

    I just spent $650 for new wheel and a new tire because of damage from a pothole on an urban street. I was not speeding. I needed AAA service at 10 o'clock at night. And it could have been worse.

  • Tell Congress to fix our crumbling transportation infrastructure
    Tell Congress to fix our crumbling transportation infrastructure

    For nearly six years America has not had a long-term transportation bill. While Congress has bickered and passed short-term patchwork bills, our nation's roads, bridges and public transit systems have deteriorated. Moreover, projects to modernize and expand our transportation infrastructure have...

  • Gas tax is wasted
    Gas tax is wasted

    In your editorial, "Congress on the clock" (April 13), you talk about the federal Highway Trust Fund going bankrupt unless Congress acts to raise taxes. Motorists deserve better highways and bridge repair, but the truth is not all of the tax money motorists pay goes to build or repair roads or...

  • The transportation lockbox [Editorial]
    The transportation lockbox [Editorial]

    Our view: Vote 'yes' on Question 1 and lock down state transportation funding — but don't expect Annapolis to throw away the key

  • Put 'trust' back in Transportation Trust Fund [Letter]
    Put 'trust' back in Transportation Trust Fund [Letter]

    A proposed state constitutional amendment creating a firewall for the Transportation Trust Fund will be on the ballot this fall, and while the legislation is flawed, it deserves voter support. The legislation (Senate Bill 829 of 2013) received bipartisan support in both the House and Senate.

Comments
Loading

64°