Get unlimited digital access to $0.99 for 4 weeks.
News Opinion

The demise of moderate Republicanism

Among the casualties of the 2012 presidential election, along with Mitt Romney, was the vanishing breed of moderate Republicans of which he once was a star, until his embarrassing lurch into conservatism.

Mr. Romney first failed to win the GOP nomination in 2008 as a moderate governor of heavily Democratic Massachusetts. Four years later, he shed the middle-road path followed by his late father, George Romney, who won three terms as governor of Michigan but failed to win the Republican presidential nomination in 1968.

That year, the father hewed to the moderate course but was easily outmaneuvered by Richard Nixon, who seized both the center and right wing of the party. By the time son Mitt became the GOP standard-bearer 44 years later, moderate Republicanism was not merely a shadow of its former self but virtually a ghost.

So Mitt Romney simply changed his ideological spots. The transformation was a manifestation of how the party had evolved over half a century. It went from the orthodox conservatism of Sen. Robert A. Taft of Ohio to the centrism of Richard Nixon, and then to the extremism of Barry Goldwater and his more pragmatic 1964 cheerleader, Ronald Reagan, in1980.

Along the way, the liberal Republicanism of Nelson Rockefeller and Jacob Javits came and went. Eventually, only a few GOP moderates, such as Maine Sens. Olympia Snowe (now retired) and Susan Collins, were left to carry the fallen standard of bipartisanship against the onslaught of right-wing evangelicals and anti-establishment tea partiers.

This devolution of moderate Republicanism was well chronicled in 2012 in "Rule and Ruin: The Downfall of Moderation and the Destruction of the Republican Party, from Eisenhower to the Tea Party," by political scientist and historian Geoffrey Kabaservice.

The book traced the erosion of moderate influence after the Eisenhower presidency, and how the conservatism and anti-intellectualism of Goldwater, after surviving the Nixon years of accommodation with all factions, blossomed under Reagan and more destructively under George W. Bush.

It underscored how Nixon first achieved a centrist image with such initiatives as revenue-sharing with the states at home and his opening to China abroad, as well as his de-escalation of the American combat role in Vietnam.

Nevertheless, the author wrote, "Nixon's rhetorical conservatism, his willingness to polarize the country around controversial social issues, and his abuse of his office and the rule of law made moderates turn against him. Watergate depressed the faith that Americans had in government generally, which ultimately damaged moderate Republicans as well as liberal Democrats."

At the same time, Mr. Kabaservice noted, the moderate Ripon Society believed that "only progressive Republicans, unscathed by the scandal" could "restore to the party an image of integrity and objective government," optimistically proclaiming "the combination of independence, intelligence and integrity makes them ideal for party leadership."

But even before Watergate, the GOP moderates had failed to identify and boost a credible party leader who could withstand the Nixon-Agnew mobilization of the so-called "Silent Majority" of anti-liberal, anti-government naysayers in which right-wing conservatism flourished.

In Watergate's aftermath, the party temporarily fell to Nixon's standby, the congenial Gerald Ford, who leaned on conservative support to the degree that he acquiesced in the dumping of his hand-picked vice president, liberal Nelson Rockefeller, and still lost in 1976.

In 2000, party moderates who allowed themselves to be lulled by George W. Bush's "compassionate conservatism" were soon driven off by his 2003 invasion of Iraq and nation-building misadventures there and in Afghanistan.

The author of "Rule and Ruin" concluded : "The Bush years demonstrated anew that conservatives were skilled at politics but deficient at governing, and that a Republican Party without moderates was like a heavily muscled body without a head. ... If moderation remains long absent from one party, let alone both, the consequences are likely to be dire. ... Political movements based on dogmatic, unthinking certitude may be fatal to American values."

The GOP's surviving moderates in 2012 conceivably might have found their savior in the old Mitt Romney. But not in the once-moderate leopard who changed his spots to be an acceptable fit in the party that by now bears little resemblance to his father's middle-road political home.

Jules Witcover is a former longtime writer for The Baltimore Sun. His latest book is "Joe Biden: A Life of Trial and Redemption" (William Morrow). You can respond to this column at

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Out of the White House and onto the dole
    Out of the White House and onto the dole

    Why are we paying millions in pensions and expenses for our ex-presidents?

  • A matter of trust
    A matter of trust

    At an emotional meeting this week, members of the Baltimore City Board of School Commissioners found themselves struggling to explain their recent initiative to allow the city's School Police Force, which is separate from the Baltimore City Police Department, to carry weapons inside school...

  • How to reduce drunk driving
    How to reduce drunk driving

    People who have never been tested on a Breathalyzer are often surprised by just how intoxicated a person has to be to register a blood alcohol concentration of .08. It is enough to slur speech, impair vision, and dangerously alter perception and reaction time. You are, in a word, drunk and...

  • Retirement insecurity
    Retirement insecurity

    The "silver tsunami" predicted for Maryland, where more than 1 million workers have no retirement savings, is one that will sweep the rest of the country, too. As a matter of fact, the Employee Benefit Research Institute says the percentage of Marylanders with little or no savings is about...

  • Charter schools do not equal education reform
    Charter schools do not equal education reform

    As Philadelphia's Superintendent of Schools, I recommended the approval of more than 30 charter schools because I thought it would improve educational opportunity for our 215,000 students. The last 20 years make it clear I was wrong.

  • The U.S. has yet to make good on its promise of reparations to black Americans
    The U.S. has yet to make good on its promise of reparations to black Americans

    Conversations about reparations are not about money but about people and about the way that people are seen and valued in our society. These are difficult conversations, and we have found that what is most challenging about the idea of reparations today is the notion that America still owes a...