Medical aircraft crashes on rise

Ariz. accident that killed 6 seen as part of 'disturbing trend'

Associated Press

July 1, 2008

FLAGSTAFF, Ariz. - Accidents of medical aircraft are at a "disturbing" level, a federal safety official said yesterday as he arrived at the scene where two helicopters collided, killing six people.

"We're very concerned about that," National Transportation Safety Board chairman Mark Rosenker told reporters. "We're going to work very, very hard to make sure we understand exactly what happened here ... and make recommendations to prevent it from happening again."

The collision Sunday near Flagstaff Medical Center, in which seven people had initially been reported killed, also critically injured a nurse and rained debris near a residential area. Two emergency workers suffered minor burns in an explosion in the wreckage of one of the aircraft.

"It kind of scares me," said Lawrence Garduno, who lives nearby. "If this had happened a half-mile closer, it could have fallen on our house."

There have been nine serious accidents with emergency medical aircraft this year, six of them involving helicopters, NTSB spokesman Ted Lopatkiewicz said. Sixteen people died in the helicopter accidents, including the six in Sunday's crash, which had the largest death toll. Rosenker called the numbers a "disturbing trend."

One of the helicopters that crashed Sunday was carrying a patient with a medical emergency from the Grand Canyon, officials said. It was operated by Classic Helicopters of Woods Cross, Utah.

The other helicopter, operated by Air Methods from Englewood, Colo., was coming from the nearby community of Winslow, said Capt. Mark Johnson, a spokesman for the Flagstaff Fire Department.

The victims from the Classic helicopter were identified as pilot Tom Caldwell, 54; paramedic Tom Clausing, 36; and the Grand Canyon patient, Michael McDonald, 26. Flight nurse James Taylor, 36, was in critical condition yesterday at Flagstaff Medical Center.

On the other helicopter, the victims were identified yesterday as pilot Pat Graham, 50; flight nurse Shawn Shreeve, 36; and patient Raymond Zest, 54.

"We've been in business 20 years, and these are the first fatalities we've experienced," said Matt Stein, a pilot with Classic Helicopters subsidiary Classic Lifeguard Aeromedical Services in Page, Ariz. "They were all heroes. They were out doing a great service for their communities."

Aaron Todd, chief executive of Air Methods Corp., said yesterday that his company's helicopter was being flown by a veteran pilot. Citing the investigation, he declined to discuss details.

Flagstaff Medical Center President Bill Bradel said yesterday that the hospital was not releasing any details on the crash, instead focusing on family members of those who died.

"I watched our trauma team work diligently trying to save the lives of the victims of this terrible crash," he said.

Both aircraft were Bell 407 models, said Ian Gregor, a spokesman with the Federal Aviation Administration.

Stein said it was rare for two medical helicopters to attempt to land at a hospital at the same time. Flagstaff Medical Center doesn't have flight controllers, he said, and it's up to the pilots to watch each other as they approach.

The falling debris set off a brush fire, which spread to 10 acres before it was contained.