Summer Sale! Get unlimited digital access for 13 weeks for $13.
News Maryland Howard County Columbia

MSA testing should be bypassed if it has no relevance [Editorial]

The usefulness of student assessment testing as a gauge of school progress has been debated for years. The argument in favor is that the tests are a tool to evaluate schools and teachers because the tests are tailored to what is being taught in the classroom — the curriculum.

But what if the tests do not match the curriculum? The fundamental purpose of the tests would then be gone — test questions would not correspond to class lessons. Would it serve any purpose to give the test anyway?

State officials, in plans to be considered by the Maryland State Board of Education this month, say yes, the Maryland Student Assessments test should still be given. Not only that, but the state will spend $6 million to administer the tests.

At the heart of the problem is a transition from old to new. A previous curriculum is being phased out, to be replaced with the new Common Core curriculum. But a test tailored to the new curriculum will not be in use until the 2014-15 school year.

Many in Maryland education, especially teachers' unions, are scratching their heads over the state's decision to administer a test whose results will measure little or nothing.

"It doesn't make sense to give a test that you know is not aligned to what you are teaching because that is just a waste of everyone's time and, frankly, money," Donna Harris-Aikens, the National Education Association's director for education practice and policy, told the Sun.

State officials say the MSA is necessary because the tests are required by the federal No Child Left Behind law. But the federal Department of Education routinely grants waivers of NCLB provisions and other states have taken advantage.

California, for example, has decided not to test at all, and other states are expected to follow its lead, while some states have created interim tests to bridge the gap between old and new curriculum.

The Maryland State Education Association and the superintendents association in Maryland are calling for a one-year moratorium on MSA testing. Others are suggesting substitute tests that would satisfy the federal requirement while also yielding useful information about classroom progress.

We think state education officials should reconsider their position on testing during the curriculum transition. Maybe this is a year for a breather — add some classroom lessons whose purpose is not explicitly test-oriented. Maybe a little more, dare we say it, for more math or reading is in order. In any case, a better use can almost certainly be found for the time, effort and money needed to administer the MSA tests.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Stop obsessing over student testing

    Stop obsessing over student testing

    Another school year, another new curriculum, another new standardized test, another year where too many graduating seniors will get good grades, pass the tests and still need remedial courses in college, and another set of excuses, some new and some recycled. And another year for politicians to...

  • MSA test is not only mandatory but useful

    MSA test is not only mandatory but useful

    We read with interest The Baltimore Sun's recent editorial calling for Maryland schools to skip testing every student in grades 3-8 this year because new assessments aligned to the curriculum will not be available until the 2014-2015 school year ("Md. should skip the MSA," Sept. 16). Like the Sun's...

  • Md. should skip the MSA

    Our view: Spending money on a test that doesn't tell us what we need to know isn't a wise use of taxpayer dollars

  • Maryland awarded $5M grant for new Pre-K assessments

    Maryland was named one of seven states awarded millions in grant funds from the U.S. Department of Education to develop a new assessment for pre-kindergartners, officials announced Friday.

  • Success of Roving Radish program is no small potatoes [Our View]

    Success of Roving Radish program is no small potatoes [Our View]

    If there is another county in the United States that takes a greater interest in the nutritional needs of its citizens than Howard County, we haven't heard about it. This has led to snarky comments by many, including occasionally ourselves, about the nanny notions of many in county office.