After Pino's 16-yard strike to Johnson put the ball on the Loyola 1-yard line on St. Paul's next possession, Rawlings bullied in for the go-ahead score.
An 18-yard screen pass from Pino to Rawlings ballooned the lead to 19-7 by halftime.
Loyola showed some fire of its own early in the third quarter when Evans rifled a pass to senior wideout Trevor Janoskie streaking down the middle of the field for a 35-yard touchdown.
Later, Evans completed a 60-yard scoring pass to senior wideout Mike Meurer late in the fourth quarter after Rawlings' third touchdown had given the visitors 26-14 advantage.
"We played hard and we fought hard until the end," Loyola coach Brant Hall said. "But we have to develop a greater level of concentration from the beginning of the game to the end. We just had too many mental mistakes."
SP 7 12 0 7 26
Loy 0 7 7 7 21
SP-Pino 3 run (Welsh kick)
Loy-Evans 8 run (Rowley kick)
SP-Rawlings 1 run (Kick failed)
SP-Rawlings 18 pass from Pino (pass failed)
Loy-Janoskie 35 pass from Evans (Rowley kick)
SP-Rawlings 1 run (Welsh kick)
Loy-Meurer 60 pass from Evans (Rowley kick)