Unlimited Access. Try it Today! Your First 10 Days Always $0.99


News Maryland Baltimore County Towson

Forum on Common Core yields a lesson in free speech [Editorial]

Maryland educators no doubt learned a lesson Sept. 19: It's better to endure some discomfort at a public meeting when a concerned parent speaks out than endure the fallout when the protester is seized, shoved out of the room, handcuffed and arrested and charged with assaulting a police officer (a charge later dropped).

The incident, caught on camera and viewed widely on the Internet, began when Robert Small, of Ellicott City, spoke out at a meeting in Towson hosted by the state Department of Education regarding the new curriculum standards called Common Core in Maryland.

Small stood and interrupted Baltimore County Schools Superintendent Dallas Dance. The superintendent was conducting a question-and-answer session, but the format called for all questions to be written and submitted.

Small, whose remarks to, among others, state School Superintendent Lillian Lowery, appeared directed as much to the audience as to those seated on the dais. He complained that Common Core would lower educational standards and steer students into community colleges.

Dance tried to engage with Small, saying his questions would be answered. Small did not sit down and an off-duty Baltimore County police officer working as a security guard eventually hustled him out of the room as the parent turned to those in the audience and said, "Don't stand for this. You are sitting here like cattle. Is this America?"

Quite a spectacle.

It must be said that Small did speak out of turn and that Dance, Lowery and the others hosting the forum were no doubt caught off guard.

Yet therein lies the lesson. Aside from all the rhetoric about Constitutional guarantees of free speech, mere common sense suggests the whole flap could have been avoided if the panel had answered Small's questions head on, creating the appearance of an open instead of closed dialogue. Small deserved to be treated with more patience and respect than he got. "Hands off, let's talk" should be the default setting.

Regardless of the pros and cons of the new educational standards, we think many will recognize some kinship with the vociferous Robert Small. Call it our common core, and a hopefully a teachable moment should a situation such as this arise again.

Copyright © 2015, The Baltimore Sun
Related Content
  • Let's provide opt-out on PARCC
    Let's provide opt-out on PARCC

    The term, "limousine liberal" was coined in the early 1970s to underscore the hypocrisy of families like the Kennedys who sent their children to private schools of their choosing while the school of choice for ordinary Americans was left to the state and a quota system.

  • Common Core blows up testing [Letter]
    Common Core blows up testing [Letter]

    State officials deeply vested in new Common Core curriculum mandates and tests want us to believe that marked student declines on state tests since Common Core moved into place aren't Common Core's fault ("MSA warning signs," July 14). Even though Common Core is supposed to be more difficult than...

  • Curriculum changes deserve failing grade [Letter]
    Curriculum changes deserve failing grade [Letter]

    I think the new curriculum is not good at all ("MSA warning signs," July 15). As a country, we focus more on test and test scores than we actually do on teaching these kids. The old ways of doing things were better and way more effective.

  • Defending a defense of Common Core [Letter]
    Defending a defense of Common Core [Letter]

    Thank you for an intelligent explanation of the theories behind the Common Core standards ("In defense of Common Core," June 27). You detailed the purpose behind the English and math standards with examples that should make sense to most people. Rather than move students through grades with a minimum...

  • Sun doesn't understand Common Core [Letter]
    Sun doesn't understand Common Core [Letter]

    The "new higher standards" that The Sun's editorial board has just discovered as it defends the Common Core are of great interest to those who were responsible for the learning program of students for the past 50 years ("In defense of Common Core," June 27). It is also an incredible insult to those...

  • More research is needed on the Common Core standards [Letter]
    More research is needed on the Common Core standards [Letter]

    As a long-time educator, I recognize the need for the Common Core State standards and strongly support them. However, as the standards have been rolled out in the public schools, some major concerns have been raised ("In defense of Common Core," June 27).