Celebrated nuclear ship rests in Baltimore
N.S. Savannah is virtual time capsule from early 1960s
N.S. Savannah, a decommissioned nuclear-powered cargo and passenger ship, is moored at Canton Marine Terminal Pier 13. (July 31, 2011)
She's the N.S. Savannah, a floating time capsule from the mid-20th century that has made Baltimore her retirement home.
For a few brief years during the Kennedy and Johnson administrations she was a nautical superstar, touring the world as an ambassador for the peaceful use of nuclear energy and playing host to royalty. In May 1964 she drew more than 13,000 visitors during a call at Dundalk Marine Terminal.
But she faded from the scene like a doo-wop group pushed aside by the Beatles.
"She was a very interesting ship … in her time," said former U.S. Rep. Helen Delich Bentley, who as The Baltimore Sun's maritime editor wrote about the Savannah in the ship's heyday. "She was really the grande dame on the oceans."
Unlike the Constellation, the Savannah is not a floating museum or a tourist attraction. She is berthed not in the Inner Harbor but at out-of-the-way Pier 13, near the Seagirt Marine Terminal, wedged between a coal terminal and a gypsum plant that combine to keep her coated with layers of black and white dust.
Still owned and maintained by the Federal Maritime Administration and regulated by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission, she is opened to visitors on occasions such as the Maritime Day celebration each May. Groups can arrange tours by request, as long as they don't expect too much in the way of air conditioning, elevators or other modern creature comforts.
Some of the ship's fans dream of turning her into an active cultural and educational treasure, but so far nobody has figured out where the money would come from.
Erhard W. Koehler, the ship's programs manager and full-time cheerleader, said the Savannah is the only U.S. vessel ever to have borne the prefix N.S., for nuclear ship, though a few other countries also had such ships. He said the vessel was conceived in 1955 by President Dwight D. Eisenhower to promote his vision of a world in which nuclear power was put to nonmilitary use — a program known as Atoms for Peace.
"It was the one thing in the program that fulfilled Eisenhower's vision to promote peaceful uses of nuclear power to the world," said Koehler, who has worked aboard the ship since 1993.
Koehler said nuclear power production was discontinued in 1971 when the ship was taken out of service. Residual radioactivity levels are very low, he said, even though the facility will remain under a regulatory regimen that applies to nuclear power plants until 2031.
"Low risk does not mean no risk," he said. "We always treat this facility with a healthy respect."
The Savannah, a sleek 5951/2 feet long and 78 feet wide, was built at a cost of $47.6 million to be the Atoms for Peace flagship. The ship was named after the S.S. Savannah, which in 1819 became the first ship to cross the Atlantic using steam power.
The N.S. Savannah was built in the shipyards of Camden, N.J., and Bentley, then Helen Delich, covered the story when the vice president's wife, Patricia Nixon, waved a radioactive wand to mark the start of work to lay the ship's keel. A year later, Delich was there when Mamie Eisenhower "gave a lusty swing to the bottle of champagne and cracked it on her first try" at the Savannah's christening.
According to Koehler, the Savannah was never intended to make money. He said Eisenhower personally directed that it be designed with aesthetics rather than profitability in mind. To that end, the designers installed fewer booms than on a conventional cargo ship — complicating loading and unloading but preserving the vessel's clean lines.
The ship was completed in 1961 and generated its first nuclear power late that year. In 1962, the Savannah made her maiden voyage from Savannah, Ga., to Norfolk, Va. Koehler said the ship carried 60 passengers at full capacity.
A visitor touring the Savannah enters the era of the Rat Pack and Jackie Kennedy's pillbox hats, with Jetsons-style furniture and ceiling lamps with atomic power symbols worked into the design. Some artifacts of the era are amazingly well preserved, such as the bar in the passenger lounge and a collection of the ship's china. Others are in serious disrepair, such as the upholstery in the passengers' dining room.
Outside the lounge is a deck where passengers once swam in the pool, now covered over, or played shuffleboard.
Some of the best-preserved sections are on the business end of the ship. Equipment on the bridge is mostly original, including a high captain's chair made for the slightly built original skipper, Koehler said. The galley has an early generation of microwave oven so the ship's cooks could "nuke" food long before that shortcut became commonplace in American homes.
Koehler said the Savannah carried a total of 842 passengers on voyages between 1962 and 1965 despite a series of interruptions because of labor disputes.
But with only 60 spaces, there weren't enough passengers to run the service at a profit, Koehler said. After three years, he said, the Maritime Administration got out of the cruise business and hauled cargo only.
During its roughly nine years in cargo service, the ship made calls at 45 foreign ports, including cities in northern Europe, the Mediterranean, and Asia, Koehler said. The Savannah even made at least one trip in support of the Vietnam War.
"Kind of ironic for Atoms for Peace," Koehler said.
However, some ports remained closed to the ship because of local skittishness about nuclear power — especially in Japan, Australia and New Zealand.
Stan Wheatley, chief engineer in 1963-1964, says the crew was hand-picked for diplomatic as well as technical skills. "We had the best of the best. You really couldn't have asked for better people."
By 1970, the Nixon administration decided there was no further need to subsidize a money-losing demonstration project. The Savannah was taken out of service, and America's nuclear-powered merchant shipping was consigned to history's dustbin.
Retirement hasn't been easy on the Savannah. In 1972, she was moved to her namesake city to be part of an Eisenhower memorial. But Georgia decided the maintenance costs were too high, and the ship wound up in South Carolina, as part of a Charleston maritime museum.
There, the ship was pounded by Hurricane Hugo in 1989, which left her interior with severe water damage. Her museum career ended in 1994 and after repair work at Sparrows Point she was consigned to the James River Reserve Fleet in Virginia — a gentle way of saying she was mothballed.
By 2008, the Maritime Administration was looking for a new home for the Savannah. Baltimore was chosen because Vane Brothers, the owner of Pier 13, submitted the low bid, Koehler said.
For now, there are no plans to take the Savannah out of Baltimore. The maritime agency's lease continues through May 2016. After that the government would have to open the contract up to new bids, but a U.S. Department of Transportation spokeswoman said a Baltimore berth would have an advantage because towing costs would have to be considered in the price.
The Savannah's status remains a bit muddled. Koehler says she is not a museum but an active ship — with a small crew of federal employees and contractors who maintain her and watch over the decommissioned reactor.
The Maritime Administration's function is to prevent deterioration of the ship but not to perform restoration work — "a pretty expensive proposition," he said.
Still, the agency has done some preservation work along with repairs in such places as the captain's stateroom, where there had been serious water damage. At least one passenger stateroom has been restored to an approximation of what it looked like in 1964, with original furniture. To say the least, it bears little resemblance to the cruise ships of today.
If any serious restoration work is undertaken, it will likely be through the N.S. Savannah Association, a nonprofit group of former crew members and other "friends" of the ship.
Wayne Britz, president of the association, said the Savannah — designated by the National Park Service as a national historic site — deserves to be preserved as cultural and educational resource.
"It's also a beautiful ship, so it would make a very nice addition to some port as a tourist attraction," he said. "We would like it to be Baltimore."
Britz, a former second officer who served aboard the ship from 1966 to 1970, said the association would like to see the Savannah be self-sustaining but believes "it might need some help to get off the ground." He said the group would like to get some help from Congress but knows it's a tough time to get money from Capitol Hill.
Federal Maritime Administrator David Matsuda said the agency hopes the ship can be preserved after its nuclear license expires in 2031. Options include continued federal ownership, donation to a private entity or a public-private partnership. Given the vessel's historical status, it is unlikely to be scrapped, he said.
What seems unlikely is any quick comeback for America's nuclear-powered commercial vessels.
Wheatley, who moved on to a career in high-speed ship research, expects Russia to lead the way in using nuclear power for non-military ships. But the former chief engineer, at 85 still active at California State University at Long Beach, hopes a new generation of compact nuclear reactors will put the United States back in the game.
"Hope springs eternal, because I still think it's the way to go," he said.