October 12, 2008
Md. court to hear case about gay marriage
8 lawmakers want to join lawsuit as defendants
Maryland's highest court today will take up the thorny question of whether state legislators and other gay-marriage opponents can become part of the highly charged lawsuit filed by couples who want the state to allow same-sex marriage.
Eight lawmakers and the Anne Arundel County court clerk are appealing a Baltimore judge's ruling that they cannot join the lawsuit as defendants.
They contend that the social policy question of same-sex marriage is one for the legislature and Maryland voters - not the courts - to decide. They say they also believe that the state attorney general's office will not adequately represent their lawmaking interests.
The same-sex couples and the attorney general's office oppose the bid by the legislators and others, saying they have no role in defending the constitutionality of the Maryland law. They argue that it is the attorney general's job to defend state laws.
A bill calling for a constitutional amendment banning same-sex marriage is dying in the General Assembly. Its proponents, some of whom are the legislators trying to intervene in the court case, pledged to push for passage next year.
If allowed in, he said, the lawmakers can tie the case in procedural knots to delay reaching the real issue.
"If they are allowed to intervene, this case will be decided in the next millennium," said Andrew H. Baida, a lawyer for the gay couples.
But the lawmakers say they are neither grandstanding nor being obstructionist.
"We don't want to tie up the lawsuit. We want to establish that marriage is between a man and a woman," said Del. Herbert H. McMillan, an Anne Arundel Republican.
Nationally, it is rare for lawmakers to want to become parties in lawsuits. Legislators' bids in other states to become defendants in same-sex marriage cases have been denied.
The Maryland Court of Appeals, which is to hear arguments in the case today, has never ruled on the question.
The legislators, Anne Arundel County Clerk of the Court Robert P. Duckworth, who was running for Congress at the time, and a Baltimore woman asked to become parties in the lawsuit.
Judge M. Brooke Murdock ruled against them in September, without a hearing and before either the attorney general's office or the couples filed responses to their request. They appealed.
Get home delivery of The Sun and save over 50% off the newsstand price
Copyright © 2008, The Baltimore Sun
 Fatal medevac crashFour people died and another was seriously injured when a medevac helicopter crashed in a Prince George's County park. Photos Archived coverage: Ex-councilman Harris killed | Md. police spying City Hall, Dixon investigated | CEG sold for $4.7B  A roundup of crimes reported in Baltimore City and Baltimore County |
Popular stories: Maryland News
- 3 wounded in violent attack outside hotel
- Pit bull attack breaks calm
- One killed in motorcycle crash on Interstate 95
- Peter Hermann: Witness to a crime may be told it never happened
- Push to register voters
Watchdog archive
Is there something in your neighborhood that's not getting fixed? Tell us where the problem is and how long its been there.
 Area farmers' marketsAn interactive map featuring locations, times, photos and other coverage of farmers' markets across the area. |
 | |
My MarylandSubmit photos from around the state and view those from other readers Also see: Charm Cityscapes | |