Unlimited Access. Try it Today! Your First 10 Days Always $0.99

2004: Evanescence

Verdict: If 2002 was the cream of the crop, then 2004 was, well, not. Heather Headley and “Stacy’s Mom” singers Fountains of Wayne haven’t had major hits since their nominations, and for a hard-core rapper such as 50 Cent to win this award would have been a major shocker then and now. But... Richard Hartog / Los Angeles Times