Growing up Alba After playing a up-and-coming dancer-choreographer in the 2003 hit Honey, she came into her own as exotic dancer Nancy in 2005s Sin City, directed by Robert Rodriguez and Frank Miller. Alba received the MTV Movie Award for Sexiest Performance for Sin City. However, shes taken more than a few potshots from critics for acting and was nominated for a 2007 Razzie Award for worst actress for her performance in three lambasted films released last year Awake, Good Luck Chuck and Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer. Hathaway After appearing in The Princess Dairies 2: Royal Engagement and Ella Enchanted in 2004, she came of age and doffed her duds in the dreadful Havoc, as well as Brokeback Mountain. Her Disney ingenue days were officially over. Winner: Hathaway because shes the stronger more versatile actress.
Kimberly French / Focus Features