City hotel proposal gains late support
Fund to help neighborhoods may help chances in 1st key vote
And a major labor union is throwing its weight and possibly its money behind the idea of an affordable housing trust fund - a compromise hotel advocates hope will soften City Council opposition by linking the downtown hotel with neighborhood needs.
But, she said, she won't ultimately support the proposal unless some of its profits help struggling neighborhoods.
"I've never not voted a bill out of committee - a bill deserves to be voted up or voted down," she said. "But that doesn't mean I'm a 'yes' to pass the bill. Those are two different things.
"I do believe we need a convention center hotel. But I'm not willing to support it without it being able to deliver something for communities."
The council is to vote tomorrow on whether to free the hotel package from the committee of the whole, where the council has debated it for more than a month. With Holton's support, the plan appears to be headed for the council floor and a second vote Aug. 15.
But that didn't stop the weekend frenzy.
To lock in support and tilt the expected close vote their way, advocates and opponents spent recent days with ears pressed to receivers, talking offers, gossip and the latest head counts of who's "yes" and who's "no."
"At the last minute things are gonna be coming out of the woodwork," said Councilman Keiffer J. Mitchell Jr.
Mayor Martin O'Malley is pushing the hotel, which would be the city's costliest public project, as the only way to save the faltering downtown convention center.
Although speculation about whether the mayor would succeed has been serious City Hall sport for a while, with the first vote looming, the intensity kicked up a notch.
"The phone has been ringing off the hook," said Councilman Kenneth N. Harris Sr., a vocal hotel opponent who said last week that he could be persuaded to support it under certain conditions. "I don't feel pressured, but I've got people pulling me on both sides."
At the center of the eleventh-hour blitz is a plan by O'Malley and City Council President Sheila Dixon, which aims to mollify community groups that have demanded the city invest in blighted neighborhoods and win last-minute support on the council.
Dixon hinted about the deal Wednesday. Yesterday her chief of staff revealed more details.
Dixon and O'Malley would create a trust fund to provide $59 million over five years to prepare sites for affordable housing. Dixon will ask the Board of Estimates on Wednesday to start the fund with $10 million from the city's budget reserve, said Beatrice L. Tripps.
Over the next four years, Baltimore would expand the pot with money from Community Development Block Grant cash and its income from the Inner Harbor Hyatt. In the second and third years, the city would tap general obligation bonds for $5 million each year.
The city would use the fund to acquire properties and clear sites. When it comes to building new affordable homes, organized labor might lend a hand.
On Friday, officials with the Washington-based AFL-CIO Housing Investment Trust expressed interest in helping, according to Tripps and Ron DeJuliis, president of the Baltimore Building and Construction Trades Council.
Tripps said officials are committed to working on the housing program regardless of whether the convention center hotel is approved. Yet she hopes the plan will convince hotel skeptics that the Hilton won't rise at the expense of neighborhoods.
"What this does is demonstrate that the city is not only focusing on the downtown area," Tripps said. "If this is an issue, it's a possibility they will change their vote."
The need for neighborhood redevelopment is just one reason that many on the 15-member council object to the hotel plan.
Many of them balk at Baltimore getting into the hotel business, wishing the city would instead consider a deal with private investment.
The Baltimore Development Corp., the city's economic development arm, says the all-public financing model is the only viable way to build a hotel. Although the city has had offers to build the hotel with private money - one as recently as last week - BDC officials call the $305 million public scenario superior because Baltimore could keep all of the profits. And BDC officials say the hotel's revenue will easily pay off the city's bond debt.
Portman Holdings, an Atlanta firm that previously bid for the hotel deal, submitted an offer to Dixon last week saying the company could build Baltimore a 750-room convention center hotel for $214 million - with about $50 million in city tax breaks.
"It's misinformation from the BDC that there never was a viable private proposal - that's just not true," said Roger Zampell, Portman's senior vice president of development. "You can make the numbers say whatever you want, depending on what side of the fence you're on.
"If the council is willing to sit down and listen, [a private deal] should be able to be accomplished."
Dixon gave Portman's proposal to the city's finance department for analysis, said Chris Williams, Dixon's spokesman.
Harris, who says he won't support the proposal unless Hilton offers the city upfront a portion of the money it has pledged to guarantee Baltimore's bond debt, said Portman's offer probably comes too late.
"What it's gonna do though, definitely," he said, "is validate people who are 'no' votes."